《Forbidden (Benny X reader)》Part 13- me or them

Advertisement

Im in my room waiting for it to be 1pm so I can go play at the sandlot. I hear a knock at the door but Jordan is downstairs so he gets it. A few minutes later I hear the front door slam shut and stomping up the stairs. My door swings open. Jordan walks into my room.

Before I am able say anything he says "You're dating benny!!" I'm in deep shit.

"Wait what" I'm confused. Who would've told him?

"And you've been playing with the sandlot boys" he looks furious "I can't believe you y/n!"

"I'm sorry!" I yell

"Out of everyone in this town, you choose my biggest enemies!" He yells

"I didn't want to hurt you!" I say "I'm really sorry."

"Me or them." He says after a few seconds of silence.

"Jordan.." I say

"Choose y/n! Me or them!" He yells. I stay silent unsure who to pick.

"Fine, be like that" he begins to walk off.

"You." I say in defeat. I knew I had to choose. I love benny and the other sandlot boys but Jordan has been by my side since I can remember and he's the best brother someone could ask for, except from the fact he's making me choose between him and my friends. He turns back around.

"You gotta prove it to me." He says. I give him a confused look.

"How?!" I ask

"You're gonna go to the sandlot and tell them you don't want to be friends with them and you never liked them in the first place." He said

"Don't make me do that, please Jordan" I beg

"Then you clearly choose them." He says. I've never seen Jordan like this but I know he's only being like this because he is mad. Unfortunately he will be mad for quite a while so I have no choice but to do it.

Advertisement

"Fine I'll do it." I say "what about benny?"

"You're gonna break up with him." I look at him in disbelief. I sigh before pushing past him and leaving the house. I feel tears in my eyes. I really don't want to do this but I have to. I finally get to the sandlot. I see all the boys in the dugout. As I'm walking over, they all notice me. I wipe the tears from my eyes and take a deep breath.

"Hey y/n, you okay?" Benny asks, noticing I look upset.

"Um I need to uh talk to you all about something" I find it difficult getting the words out my mouth. My eyes start to water.

"Okay!" They all say.

"I uh don't want to be friends with you guys anymore" I say.

"Well actually I never even" I'm struggling to get the words out if my mouth. "I never even liked any of you in the first place."

"Y/n what's going on?" Benny asks "be honest"

I know I can't tell him the truth. "We need to break up" saying that makes me cry harder than before.

He looks at me in shock. I start walking away before I can see there reaction.

"Whatever, we don't care."

"Yeah yeah we don't care!"

"Our team is better without you!"

"I knew you were just like your brother!"

"Yeah we should've never let a Philips join our team!"

I walk home. I see Jordan sitting outside. I give him a death stare before walking into the house.

    people are reading<Forbidden (Benny X reader)>
      Close message
      Advertisement
      You may like
      You can access <East Tale> through any of the following apps you have installed
      5800Coins for Signup,580 Coins daily.
      Update the hottest novels in time! Subscribe to push to read! Accurate recommendation from massive library!
      2 Then Click【Add To Home Screen】
      1Click