《Erotic Book Club (E.B.C) 2019》The Will To Serve (Feedback)
Advertisement
I loved this book! I read the first chapter and was hooked! I loved how you portrayed the characters, and even without knowing anything about them, I liked them right away, and that didn't change throughout the book. Great character development, all of them! I love your writing style. It is easy to read, it flows nicely, great dialogue! It needs a little editing, but there was nothing too major that it bothered me.
I've read the book before I read your help request, but I saw your author's notes about showing instead of telling. I'm struggling with that as well, so I'm no help with that. But I didn't notice anything, partly because I was so into the story. And I never felt like you were over-explaining. At some point, though, I skipped the author's notes ;)
I have no idea about the BDSM community, but I do hope it is like you described it. I loved the respect your characters showed, and that example of how it shouldn't be done was well executed in my eyes. I loved the emotions you conveyed (you see, I'm using that word a lot ;) ), and this book went straight on the list of my favorite reads! I will definitely read the prequel! Great job!
~Lilly
I don't have a lot to give as far as feedback here because I've discussed the book privately with the author and I've given suggestions via comments. I love the book, especially Lani and Jacob. My biggest suggestion was to not hold back. The reader likes the background information and drama. Explaining events in detail makes them connect with the character's emotions connected to the event and you don't have to worry about getting gritty at times.
I have also suggested that this book be situated as book two, once what was supposed to be the prequel is finished. I think that will help the readers connect to the characters even more if read in that order. In all though, I found it easy to binge read this story and I love the author's clear and concise way of storytelling. She describes exactly what is necessary and important without bogging down the story with unnecessary information.
The pacing is good and the spicy scenes are well done. The author knows she's found a fan in me.
~T
The Will to Serve is about Luna, a sub, and her dom, Jacob. A former dom has come into the picture to stir up old emotions in Luna to which Jacob must deal with. This is what I think the story is about. Going into the story I didn't expect to become so engrossed in this story as fast as I did. The writing style is really good like it's easy to read through. The flow was on point. The characters were believable though I will be reading further to find out more about Luna as her story does interest me. I'm curious about her past. The author was on point with the characters and the descriptions. In my opinion, she does a good job with storytelling. I thought there was a perfect mix of showing and telling. From the few chapters I read, I will definitely be checking out more from this author.
Advertisement
~Ellen
From the excerpt, I'm expecting another Dom/sub romance. The issue with the previous Dom is a bit confusing for me. The author alludes that he physically hurt her by not accepting her limits. But then, she also is said to have lost since confidence because he ghosted her.
In the initial meeting between them, he makes some comment about him expecting her to wait for his return.
Character-wise, Luna is said to be a powerhouse with this strong personality. But the writing portrays her as submissive even when away from Jacob. She doesn't come across as the type of person who says no often.
I like, however, that the author evokes emotions with her characters. For example, I don't like Bryan. He comes across as the kind of man that likes to exploit those he perceives to be weaker.
~Csuigar
What did you think the book was about?
The book is about a contracted BDSM relationship and the female protagonist has fairly strong feelings for the male lead and wants more than a contracted relationship. That was my overall vibe for the chapters I read.
Did you feel that the book filled your expectations?
For the most part, it was good. I stumbled a lot throughout the writing, there are several fragmented sentences where words seem to be missing, and I couldn't follow the overall sentence and figure out what was meant by it. So I do think it would fill my expectations a lot more if the writer does a full edit sweep over their writing. None of us are perfect and I even messed up big time in my own writing. But reading your writing aloud will help a lot and give is such a better flow.
What about the plot?
I've seen this type of plot before with contracted BDSM. I think as long as it different and unique unlike other novels it has a lot of potential in being a great read.
Do the characters seem real and relatable?
I haven't felt much for the characters from what I read. The first chapter was a long sex scene and I didn't see names at all. So I was disconnected from the characters from the chapter since there was no identity on them, only "she" and "he" I think if the writer would like more reliability from the beginning, to add character flaws and other quirks at the start. Add who they are and what they mean to each other to give the first chapter meaning. Then I think the relatability will flourish for the writer.
How was the pacing of the chapters you read?
The pacing was good through the chapters. I didn't feel rushed through different scenes or dialogue.
How was the description of the chapters?
This area I highly suggest to have an active voice instead of passive voice. A passive voice tends to have words "had, were, was, is." It usually put in front of an adjective or verb. The passive tense word can be removed in front of the verb. The verb with an ING ending should be replaced with an ED ending or S depending on what tense you are using. It will make the descriptions and action active and will give the book a better overall flow. I tend to remove these words as much as possible in my writing and restructure descriptions to avoid them.
Advertisement
Describe what you liked or disliked about the authors writing style?
What I mentioned for improvement are in the other questions. I do feel the writer did well on her sensory details and internal dialogue. She does well in trying to display the characters emotions, feelings, and sensations. She does some basic sensory details to help paint a picture for the readers to see. Overall, I think she has a lot of great components down. We all have areas to improve on and I hope my suggestions help her out a bit when it comes to editing.
Would you read more of the author's work?
Of course :) Thank you for letting me read.
~Steph
This book exceeded my expectations. It had a strong beginning and I could really feel what the characters were feeling in each situation as the story progressed. The plot was realistic. Overall I felt that the story flowed together well. The characters were very relatable and reacted appropriately. The descriptions were what stood out the most about this novel. The Weakest part of the story I felt was that I felt lost at certain periods, which happened around the chapter 3-4 part. I found I was able to figure out what was happening after reading on though. The pace worked well, I did feel that it picked up pace after the first two chapters. I would definitely consider reading more of your work as it is on par with other published novels.
~Genelle
Review: The will to serve.
Read 7 Chapters so far.
It took me a few chapters to understand what the book was about, but I personally enjoy those kinds of beginnings. I didn't really know what to expect before I started reading. Mainly because I just browsed through the description and didn't really study the cover. After studying it later: I really liked the cover. It's sensual and reveals the theme in an elegant way. The description was okay, but it didn't really give justice to the amazing writing you get to enjoy once you've started reading. I'm not sure if I would have read the book just based on the description, but I'm sure glad I did. Once I started reading it, it was hard to put down. Suggestion: Maybe add a longer sample-section in the description?
The first chapter was a really good way to start the story. It sets the scene for what kind of book it is, and gives an introduction to the main characters that intrigued me but without giving too much away too soon.
It's a very realistic plot and it is supported by very human and believable characters. For me, it's mainly the human insecurities, the fear of the consequences of communicating truthfully and the stigma around untraditional sexuality that makes it relatable.
My impression of Luna so far is that she is fragile and vulnerable, and I can't really see the strength that she herself refers to in the first chapter. Still, I like her as a sub, find her relatable and am curious to see how she develops throughout the story. Jacob is portrayed a bit different than other Dom's in stories I've read, but it's refreshing. I like that he's gentle, caring. and protective, and that it seems to be personality traits that he's always had. They are not something Luna is pulling out of him, even if he feels differently about her then previous sub's.
I like the pacing of the chapters. They move the story along in a pace that keeps me interested. I have a tendency to lose focus if the chapters in between the two main characters interacting get too long or take the story too of course from what I want to read about (main plot). This is not an issue here. I did not skip a single paragraph and it wasn't because this is a book club read and I felt I had to read everything. I wanted to.
The story has really good descriptions. I get the information I need to follow the story and picture the different settings. For someone who isn't as familiar with the BDSM-world, it helps to understand the story.
The descriptions of intimacy are especially good. They are by far my favorite parts. I've had a few flushed cheeks reading it. I like that there is no hurry and that the detailed descriptions make it easy to follow every movement, every touch, every breath. It's the kind of attention to detail an erotic story needs to make the reader blush and feel the tugs and stirrings in their own body.
All in all, a really well-written story that will be staying in my library as a favorite.
~Kay
My heart was shattered when Luna told Jacob about her past with her previous Master Bryan. I realize that trust is the number one thing in the BDSM community and I read that a lot of Masters or wannabe Masters as I called them, abuse that kind of trust to do things their way by not letting their submissive control too. This story is rather dark but kinda good. But to be honest, it didn't pull me in like other erotic novels I've read. It kinda makes me feel like most people who want to join that community needs to understand that it's not about forcing people or controlling them to do their bidding. It's about trust and understanding of each other and helping others to shed away their insecurities that will get in the way while doing this lifestyle. But all in all, this story is very good just really dark.
~Jasz
Advertisement
- In Serial119 Chapters
From The Strongest Job of Dragon Knight, To The Beginner Job Carrier, Somehow, The Heroes are Depending on Me
Axel Granz, the strongest dragon knight of them all has switched his job to become a beginner carrier. Relieved that he can finally take off his legendary dragon knight’s helmet and escape the responsibilities of an elite S-class worker, Axel eagerly starts his new, low-class job!
8 380 - In Serial110 Chapters
Nine Paths Of Asura-Edited To Chapter 13
ATTENTION: Currently editing the first 40 chapters. This story is over 5 years old, so if you want it to sound like it's in English, give me a day or two to get the beginning up to snuff with the later stuff! Read at your own risk! One day, when a young boy, Lineir, is scavenging alone in the abandoned Old City he angers a horde of undead. Chased all the way back to the New City, he escapes the fearful undead but gets several of the local city officials killed in the process! The next day his back is infected with a strange undead curse mark and the city officials are after his head! Follow Lineir's story as he uses his wits and the help of a mysterious master to cheat death and one day, Fate itself!This is an old story from the beginning of my writing journey. If you want something that is currently being updated I recommend: https://www.royalroad.com/fiction/38965/rethe-worst-system-leveling-turned-me-into-a-zombie You can also find the Discord here: https://discord.gg/KUQ5HrnkHG Note-Have no fear the chapter lengths are supposed to be erratic until Chapter 10 ish where you can expect standard chapter lengths. Original Description of the overall story universe-This story is about a middle world where fate itself has been broken. That means that those who would have lived ordinary lives, can now lead extraordinary lives, lives which could alter the overall scheme which the gods have put in place. But as these once ordinary individuals are freed from fate, the greater world is shaken as fate fails to control the order of things. While mortals squabble on the ground, will anyone look to the sky and see that it is falling?
8 126 - In Serial13 Chapters
An Extra-Ordinary Story about Ordinary People
In a different world, a different reality, where ordinary people occasionaly have extra-ordinary powers for no particular reason, we follow a number of characters, trying their best to live in this strange yet normal world. We have our first character, a currently nameless but sentinent creature who happened to find himself in the body of a strange fungus after an unknown incident that robbed him of not only his former body but of his memory, as well. Secondly, we follow Smith, a high-standing man who doesn't even need to explain which Smith he is, on top of the world, yet human enough to meet said fungus. And thirdly, we have another nameless character, who is burdened by the ability to summon things that he doesn't want. A charming gang, who will (most likely) meet at some point. --- All and all, it's a twist on the common super-hero world, where all super-heroes have somehow dissappeared, but not the possibility for new ones. The series that feature the mushroom-dude are the 123 ones, the stories that feature Smith are the ABC ones, and the ones that feature our newest character, the summoner-dude, are the abc ones. Neat, huh? Also, just a word of warning? The 123 ones are kind wierd, and you can skip the first few chapters and go straight to the ABC ones without missing too much. But I'd rather you didn't, since i really enjoyed writing them. In ABC and abc, the format changes to a more typical form, with proper grammar and stuff. So if you dont like the 123, I'd love it if you gave the ABC a chance :^) Anyhow, I hope you enjoy it!
8 127 - In Serial28 Chapters
Talk Music To Me
When Judaline gets a call from her college's latest soccer star, she doesn't expect him to be a goof. But self-proclaimed goofball, Caleb White makes it his mission to impress the sassy girl with cheesy song lyrics, childish talks and lots of laughter. One phone call. Many songs. Lots of smiles. "So do you like the Beatles?" ''Y-yeah, why do you-" "Hey Jude, don't make it bad-" "Please don't." "Take a sad song and make it better." " ............" __________________________________These are a series of dialogues over text/call.____________________________________HIGHEST RANKING: #1 Call#1 Dialogue #2 Pick up lines
8 189 - In Serial86 Chapters
Zero Falls: Season One
After escaping their abusive household, twins Bill and Will Cipher, find refuge in a strange town of Zero Gravity. It doesn't take long, before danger lurks around every corner, as the twins encounter many oddities, monsters, and even godlike beings.To survive, they need strong allies. But, will they find the strength to trust others, including each other?
8 159 - In Serial27 Chapters
A BadAss Romeo and his Prince
Just a TAETEE story because i was missing them a lot..Tabby
8 193

