Aricka paces nervously waiting for her turn to audition with Andrew. A lady comes out, and says, "Aricka Howell?" she nods, and follows the lady in.

When she saw Andrew, she almost fainted. "Hi," he says, "I'm Andrew Keenan-Bolger. You must be Aricka; I've heard a lot about you."

"I've heard a lot about you too," she answers. They do a dialogue together, and then sing the big duet between Jack and Katherine. The whole time Aricka wasn't herself, but Katherine. In love with Jack Kelly, who'd snuck up on her like Dan had on Aricka.

After the auditions, all the women were called back in. "Thank you for your time today ladies. Andrew, will you announce the name of our new Katherine?"

"It would be my pleasure." Andrew smiles, and says, "Aricka Howell, you are our new Katherine Pulitzer!" she gasps, and starts crying, while Andrew comes and hugs her. "Congratulations."