We was in the clubroom for the break when I heard Chika said "hey Taylor are you sure about this" I was going over a few papers and I said "yes I am" Riko said "but two years ago, we can't them to tell us about what happen to them" I look over at the third years and said "would you tell me what happen if I ask" Kanan didn't say anything so I sigh and said "I'm trying to help" she said "nothing happen" I said "alright fine but when I figure it out don't say anything got it" she turn away and Ruby said "do this really have something to do with them being school idols" I sat down both school idol form one from the third year and the other from Mimi on them and said "I got to figure why their school idol club got approve while her didn't" Mari said "but there wasn't another club besides our" I grab the papers and said "maybe she couldn't recruited enough people" I heard someone said "hey the trial is starting back up" I saw a girl sticking her head into the room then Chika said "okay" I heard Ruby said "hey Taylor you still want me to stand next to you still" I said "yea I need my good luck charm in this, unless you don't want to" she smile and said "no it's fine" I nod and we walk back out there. When we was standing out there Ms. Tsurumi said "alright Taylor since you think what happen two years ago is link to this then please start us off" I said "alright as we know Ini had some kind of grudge against Kanan but why would that be, well let look back two years ago when they was school idols together" Lucy said "your not using this trial to solve their problem are you" I shake my head and said "no I'm not, anyway if it's alright with you I would like to call Dia to take the stand this time" I heard her said "huh why me" I said "I want to go over the story you told me" she nod and when she took the stand I said "will you please tell everyone what it was like when you first create the school idol club" she nod and said "well in the begin you could say we went through the same problem as Chika and the girls" I said "when you started this club would say you might of challenge someone to see who was going to start it" she said "of course not, why would you say that" I said "maybe you didn't mean to but you did challenge someone without thinking" I heard Kanan said "we never knew anyone else who started a club" I said "why did you disband then" they didn't say anything so I said "oh I bet you felt bad for someone who tried to stand out but couldn't over you three" Dia said "quit talking Taylor" I notice Ini in the crowd getting mad so I said in a low tone "just a little more" I turn to Mari and said "two years ago who was the director" she said "I don't......" I said "I bet you payed him off to destroy anyone else who try to start......" Kanan said "be quiet" I smile and heard Ini said "you know nothing" I said "oh but I think I do" she said "you just blame everyone till you find the truth, that's how you play this game" I said "why don't you tell everyone what really happen that day" she said "I'm not being sucked in on this" I said "that's alright cause what happen to Kanan, Dia, and Mari doesn't have anything to do with Mimi but truth of what happened to her lies in them" Lucy said "good luck getting anything from them, it look like they're not going to talk" Ms. Tsurumi said "if they don't want to talk then you can't force them to" I said "hey Dia if I take a guess what happen would you tell me if I'm right" she said "I guess" I said "so what you told us that because you couldn't perform in Tokyo you disbanded because of that, but I think the real reason someone like you and Kanan would fake stage fright is to protect a friend like Mari right" she said "well your not far off" I said "I know after you girls went to Tokyo and got back you disbanded then Mari moved away, so did you do that for her future" she only nod and Lucy said "what does this have to......." I said "now let move back when they create the idol club, Mimi wanted to also create a club but after seeing those three had made one she felt powerless to try" I heard Ini said "your wrong" I said "either tell everyone what happen with your sister or keep quiet" Lucy said "how do you know their sister" I sat the club form with Mimi name on it then said "this form have her full name on it and correct me if I'm wrong but she have the same last name as your Ini" she didn't say anything then I heard Mari said "but we didn't know" I said "a girl who doesn't have friends can be invisible, so that was her goal with that idol club, to stand out and make friends" Ini said "but after those girls disbanded the club she ran away from home" no one said anything then Ms. Tsurumi said "so is that why you blame Kanan for attacking Sayuri" she said "yea that the reason but you have no proof that I attack her" I said "we can wait for Sayuri to wake up, but I figure it out why you attack her" she said "why would I attack her, she's just a lonely girl with no friends like me" I said "easy, she was the poor girl who show up at the right time" I sigh and said "what would happen if Ruby showed up in her place" she didn't say anything and I said "you would've attack her and still place the blame on Kanan but allow me to tell you this, I don't care why you did it but don't ever break up a friendship for revenge got it" she said "but it because of them that my sister....." I said "your wrong, if you haven't talk to your sister then don't start placing blame on other people" she didn't say anything so I said "I think we're done here" Lucy hit the stand and said "how is it that I can't win no matter what" I walk over to Ruby and said "cause I have something I want......." I turn around so they can't see me and put my hands together then mouth the word "protect" she sigh and said "whatever" after she walked off Ms. Tsurumi said "good job Taylor, you maintain to solve another case yet again" I said "thanks" I notice Mari and Kanan wasn't around so I said "hey where Kanan and Mari" Dia said "oh they're around" I smile and said "alright I'm getting tired so....." Riko said "you smiled" I said "woof woof" she said "you suck" I laugh and said "I didn't smile" Ruby said "you laugh too" I sigh and said "I'm going home later" I left before anyone could stop me. When I was out by the gate I hid behind a tree and waited for the girls to come out, I saw Dia locking the gate then I heard Chika said "you really care for them huh" Dia said "yea but now their your problem now, warning they're a handful" she said "then maybe I should you should as well" Dia said "I'm way to busy with the student council" she said "oh come on, we just need one more to make Aqours compete" I saw Ruby run up with a idol uniform and said "My dear sister, welcome to Aqours" I smile and said "well with that Aqours have nine members" I heard You said "I think you mean ten" I sigh and said "how did you know I was here" she said "well your easy to read now" I walk out from behind the tree then said "fine your right with that Aqours is now ten" Hanamaru said "oh does that mean......" I turn around and said "I'm not performing" I heard them laughing and after they got done talking we headed home for the day.