《Erotic Book Club (E.B.C) 2019》Just Got With It (Feedback)
Advertisement
1) What did you think the book was about?
Just Go With It is a story about Megan. It follows her and her new crush, Noah. Megan isn't feeling her current boyfriend, but she is digging Noah. It's a story that tells how these two get together. At least that's what I got from reading the first five chapters.
2) Did you feel that the book fulfilled your expectations?
I didn't have many expectations for this story. But I didn't expect it to start in the way it did. I expected a heated chase or game of cat and mouse. I didn't expect Megan to already be sort what of an expert at flirting.
3) What about the plot? Did it pull you in; or did you feel you had to force yourself to read the book?
I felt that I had to force myself to read Just Go With It. It started off in a very common way a high school story would. The plot doesn't get exciting until after chapter 4 when the two main characters actually have a face to face flirty conversation (I'm not counting their mini conversation in the three chapter.
4) Do the characters seem real and believable? (Basically, can you relate to their predicaments? To what extent do they remind you of yourself or someone you know, if they do at all?)
I can't say I relate Megan because I wasn't the party type, but I can say she is sort of a believable character. I do find it slightly unbelievable that she suppressed her wild self when with her boyfriend. If the author had of shown she did some of the same stuff she used to back in high school I could have accepted it. She basically waits until her boyfriend is gone on a golf trip to get wild. To me, I'll say she would still be a wildish person when her boyfriend is present.
5) How was the pacing of the chapters you read?
The pacing was ok to me. It read nicely. I just didn't like some aspects of the story. Nevertheless, it has a lot of potential.
6) How was the description of the chapters you read?
The main issue with this story is that it tells a lot instead of showing the scenes in the first few chapters.
7) Describe what you liked or disliked about the writer's style? (Why?)
I like that the flow was easy to read through. Like reading through was easy with the word choice the author chooses. I disliked the beginning chapter. It started with an alarm going off instead of when she first bumped into Noah.
8) Would you read more of the author's work?
The writer's strongest: I think you did pretty good with the details. I understood everything perfectly.
The writer's weakest writing trait: I don't think you gave enough sensual descriptions as the story heavily relates on sensual descriptions.
Help request: I thought your summary was on point. It was fine to me.
Overall personal thoughts: I feel that this story has a lot of potential. It just needs to start in the middle of the action before moving into the backstory.
~Ellen
Your story has a lot of potential. The pacing is decent and the storyline flows well. The steamy scenes are nice and I am glad that the MCs don't cross the line until the BF is out of the picture. Now for some things that you can hopefully use to improve your work and take it to the next level.
Right off the bat, in chapter one, there is a problem with tense changing. You flip back and forth from present to past tense, so keep an eye out for that. It is pretty rampant with tenses changing mid-sentence in some parts. There are also a lot of grammatical errors. All that can be addressed with a good editing session.
Advertisement
I'd like to know why you italicize all the dialogue? I was honestly confused by that. Typically, italics are reserved to denote internal speech or to emphasize something of importance. There were also way too many uses of ellipses in places that weren't appropriate. Again, those are grammar issues. It could also do with some better formatting i.e. shorter paragraphs, making dialogue its own paragraph. In fiction writing, a paragraph can be one sentence. So don't be afraid to use the enter button. In general, especially on WP, shorter paragraphs are easier to read.
All these things really disrupted my reading in some places and took me out of the story making it hard to get through. Other than that it was just hard for me to relate to the characters, but not everyone will and that doesn't mean you're a bad writer. I'm probably not your target audience anyway as this is a new adult book. I believe you will only improve as you go and I would certainly read more of your work in the future. Best of luck and keep writing! ♡
~Clarity
The story is about Megan that suddenly falls out of love in his boyfriend Christian. Then later find interest to Noah who also shares the same feeling. The plot and concept are actually nice, it is written in a way like the Author is talking to her reader.
In reading three chapters, I'm glad that they don't jump on each other easily but rather start to tease which is good to develop more attraction before jumping into the fire.:)
The aggressiveness really fit for calling this an erotic story. The description is also nice and you can picture it naturally. And it is not so hard to understand, all is fit to the idea she wants to display. I will definitely be going to continue reading it :)
~Ariane
I read fourteen chapters. The blurb needs a little editing, especially concerning the missing commas. I had to read some sentences twice to understand them. Adding the correct punctuation would definitely help with the flow and make me want to read the book a little more. The blurb gave me an accurate idea of what this book is about, though: Girls meets boy, and sparks fly. And fly they did. The two had great chemistry and were cute and hot together! Good job on describing that.
The flow overall was okay. What put me off was the formatting though. Why did you put all dialogue in italics? And sometimes it was confusing who said what as there wasn't an actual dialogue tag but the reaction of another person. There were grammar issues like time switches, and some of the paragraphs were really long.
The plot was okay, didn't pull me in 100% though. I was cringing at Megan's attitude when they went to that party because she did have a boyfriend still, even though she was sure she would break up with him. I'm glad that it occurred to her at some point, though, and that she didn't hook up with anyone. And I think she should have broken up 'properly' with her ex before she started kissing Noah. All that made me not like her much. And I found her pushy best friend, who kept telling her she needed to hook up, a little annoying to be honest. I loved Noah, he was a nice, sweet, and hot character – until he disappeared on her. I get that he was scared, but that was just a dick move. That made me a little mad at him. Luckily, he made up for it. The further I read, the more the characters came across as a little immature. I'm not sure if I'm thinking that because I'm way past those college years (which I never attended either) and have no idea about what college students are like. Maybe you painted a pretty good picture.
Advertisement
Even though you try to explain how they never ran into each other, it seemed a little unrealistic, especially when they seemed so into each other at first sight.
The writing style was good. There was a more telling rather than showing, though. Avoid too much of the words see, hear, feel, or watch/look at him/her. For example, don't say 'I could hear her whisper', but 'She whispered'.
It was great that you mentioned the issue of protection, even if it was after the deed ;)
Even though the story is a little predictable, with some editing, it could be really good.
~Lilly
When I read the blurb I figured this was a story about a girl that's bored in her relationship and cheats with someone new and more exciting. I was wrong. There was no cheating.
The plot was interesting as I couldn't figure out why she stayed with the guy. Also, I continued reading because I wanted to know more about the wild past the author kept mentioning.
The characters are believable. However, not really relatable for me. The story moves at a reasonable pace. I like that the author evokes emotions. I've felt outraged on behalf of Megan at least twice. I've also felt Noah's rage and confusion over his budding feelings.
As it relates to the blurb a little reworking can generate more interest. For example:
Megan and Christian have been together since high school. Now In college, their love is stronger than ever... or is it.
I like details. Especially in the sex chapters. I would read more of this author's work.
~CSuigar
You have a really great solid foundation to this story. The book flows nicely and the descriptions to the chapters are great. But there are a few things you need to address.
You have major grammatical errors that don't necessarily disrupt the flow of reading every time, but sometimes it does.
Proofread for punctuation mistakes. You have a lot of run-on sentences. Sentences that don't have periods instead of commas, and continue almost into a complete paragraph. When you have a character speak in the middle of a paragraph you don't have quotations around what they are saying.
Also, some of your paragraphs could be broken up into two different paragraphs. In a few, there are two or three completely different points you are trying to get across all rolled into one half page paragraph. It would help the readers flow if you broke them up.
Watch out for changing tense. I noticed in several chapters you would start out in first person then switch to she and her. Even when yours still in the main female characters POV.
I'm going to leave you with the same advice a few people gave me on my own book, look into getting an editor!
Keep it up, and I hope this helps!
~Callie
I think the description aptly described what the story was going to be about. A college girl who had not realized she wasn't satisfied with her relationship until "he" showed up.
The book did fulfill my expectations in the story and I did not feel like I had to force myself to read it.
The characters are totally relatable to people that I knew in college and the situations are certainly familiar although I suspect I was a lot tamer than she was based on what was described of her in high school.
The chapters were a good place and there were not huge gaps or out of sync time lapses.
The writer did a good job with descriptives and the flow of the story. Grammar was good, I didn't notice any glaring issues with structure or run on sentences.
I would read further works of this author.
~CC
Ok so to answer your question about the summary I didn't love it. If I had gone just off The summery I might have taken a pass but let me tell you I'm glad I didn't because I read every last chapter.
This book was so good that I finished it in like 2 days. I loved the characters and that's not an easy feat. Even when the ex goes nuts her response was relatable and Noah's response was relatable. I found myself saying "Yeah, I could totally see this happening in real life."
I can't tell you how to change your summary because that isn't a strength of mine. I can only speak to what I felt when I read it. When I'm reading summaries I'm looking to see what kind of experience am I going to get? That's hard for me to quantify so I'll just say that you have a gem here. Your book is amazing and I can't wait for what comes next from you.
~Catherine
Not gonna lie, this really wasn't my cup of tea. I couldn't get myself to like Megan or Noah. Maybe it's because in my eyes sex is the least important part of a relationship, but I just could not relate to either of them. Also, it felt like it had some pacing issues, namely that it felt rushed. But with all that being said, I bet others loved it, it just wasn't for me.
~Medula
The help request seemed to focus on the summary, so I think I will start there. I didn't mind the summary.
Did it accurately represent the story? I'm not entirely sure. I think that a little rewording might help to make it more reflective of what actually happens. For example, it starts off explaining that Megan has a boyfriend that she has been with for a while, then goes on to explain later that she meets Noah (I like all the stuff between that, by the way). I feel like adding in something about the fact that Megan is just waiting to break up with her boyfriend might help the summary better match the story.
Another suggestion I have is reducing your use of ellipses (...) in the summary and the text in general. Your words should be adding all of the drama and suspense they need, without having to use ellipses. In some cases, just starting a new paragraph would have the same effect and make your writing seem much smoother. In others, they are just unnecessary.
Now, for some more general comments on the formatting and grammar in the story. I personally find the fact that all dialogue is in italics to be very disruptive. It is probably also a lot of extra work for you. Leaving it as normal text is fine, especially as you have all the quotation marks in the right places anyway. I would save the italics for the characters internal thoughts because there are a couple of places where it is hard to tell the difference between the narrative voice and the protagonists' internal thoughts. I had to reread several spots because of this.
I will admit being very biased on this next part of feedback but using numerals rather than words is a pet peeve of mine. For example, if Megan had two shoes, it looks more polished if you write "two shoes" rather than "2 shoes".
Ok, so I feel that so far you must be thinking I disliked everything. That isn't true at all. Despite the grammatical and formatting things, which are all very easy fixes, I found the story interesting. I loved how Megan's voice came through in the text, and it was very easy to get a good sense of who she was early in the piece. Even with the very socially-questionable concerns some might have about her getting so flirty before she had broken up with Christian, I think you did a good job of showing why. Admittedly, she was very quick and out-there with Noah, but hey- go for it girl.
The relationship between Noah and Megan is sweet to see. I really think your title is perfect, given the content of the novel. I love how they dance around things for a while. So many people just rush straight to sex without giving it time to build. Overall, you've done an excellent job narrating the story. Thank you for sharing.
~Liv
Advertisement
- In Serial18 Chapters
Begin the End
The legend of Alexander Wren, was a tale passed down through generations. Telling of a hero's quest to pull his love back from the gate of death. The story told is always a happy one.The hero slays the beast, saves the girl, lives happily ever after. However this is merely a folk tale, a story told to children. The truth is much more sinister This is the true story of Alexander Wren, the beginning of the end.The very thing that led us here, to the day the mortals die.
8 102 - In Serial24 Chapters
Born of Shadow
Lena has always known that the world if full of monsters. What she didn't know, was that she was one of them.Alone, but for her best friend, Lena masters her supernatural powers and joins up with a team of hunters in their war against the supernatural creatures that destroyed her family.But she's not only fighting the monsters. As her feelings grow for her best friend, Evie; she must confront the creature that's haunted her nightmares for years.
8 182 - In Serial11 Chapters
Meridian Memoirs
Hiatus
8 151 - In Serial7 Chapters
Milky Way: Story of Eden
In the year 5016, THE MILKY WAY FEDERATION has expanded research facilities and space colonies throughout the Galaxy. The dastardly ABRENO REGIME has sent spies into Federation Controlled science facilities in deep space. On the edge of the Vakkaro Star System, a lowly dwarf star gives light to a single small ice planet. This solar system is restricted allowing only FEDERATION ships to enter. On the small planet of FC-1293-Keta, resides a large science base for the INTERGALACTIC SOCIETY OF SCIENCE dubbed THE EDEN SCIENCE COLONY by the organization.While the possibility of a spy is low, tensions are high. Scientists work every hour in this colony on advanced experiments in order to better life in the Galaxy and for THE FEDERATION.
8 89 - In Serial10 Chapters
Midthalion Saga
+++Working on new chapters. Share what I've posted with your friends and family! Be sure to build strong bonds with those who are important to you. We only have each other in this world for so long!+++ Can Roderick XXIII gather together and train a party of adventurers to clear out Madeon Caves and bring peace to the wildmarches of Midthalion? Sent from his home monastery in the west to the wildmarches of Midthalion, Roderick the Holy Avenger is devoted to living out his oath to bring the Holy Light to the dark corners of the world. He enlists the help of an old friend, Ulrich Vogelbrandt the dwarf druid, to train and prepare a fighting force capable of defending the west from the evil they both see gathering and growing in the east. Eoroth is an ode to Tolkienesque epic fantasy, Robert E Howard and H.P. Lovecraft's pulp fiction, and Gygaxian Dungeons & Dragons. I like to write about serious topics because I think it's fun. I hope it makes for a fun read. Place: Eoroth, a vast, flat world with many continents set in oceans that reach out and mingle with the Celestial Sea. Our story takes place on the continent of Thalion in the middle, unsettled region called Midthalion. Peoples: Races in Eoroth aren't different species; the species of man is just incredibly diverse, consisting of many known races (and perhaps some unknown). There are no humans in Thalion. Thalion's races include variations of elves, dwarves, halflings (billowits), pierros (clownish men), bergeracs (long-nosed and swarthy men of honour), orcs, trolls, goblins, and hobgobs. The Church: There's one dominant religion in Westhalion. The faith of the elves is an analogue to Roman Catholicism while the dwarves practice an Eastern Orthodox analogue. (Forgive me for not having figured out names yet.) The practitioners worship a triune god (the All-Father, Son-of-All, and Holy Light). There are many powers in heaven, all created by God. These include the Twelve High Thrones, individual, created beings who take on the role of guiding mankind in different aspects, drawing them closer and closer to God. (That should be the essentials. I could write pages on the theology. Comment where something's unclear in the story.) Natural World: There are plants and animals in Eoroth, but the world is also inhabited by spirits called aeons. Aeons are transformative beings; in the wild, they'll change based on whatever is happening nearby. Pollute a pond? Expect to see toxic toad-men running around. Leave a bunch of dead bodies strewn across a battlefield? Expect the place to become haunted with ghouls and ghasts. Druids are important for making sure that the aeons are pacified; that their needs are met so that they don't become rampaging monsters. Where the wilderness becomes overgrown, so too do the aeons. Aeons and People: Long ago, men learned how to trap aeons in stone tablets and use them for war. Now, anyone can capture an aeon into a special staff made by a druid. Men train, raise, and bond with these aeons. Druids often build entire ranches devoted to raising healthy aeons as allies and companions. Aeons are divided into twelve known families, and the church sees these as corresponding with the Twelve Thrones in Heaven. Direction: My goal is to get the story to one million words by June next year. I have tons of content in mind for the world. I want to release novels set in different ages of the world depicting different historical events. I hope to expand the setting into a tabletop role-playing game as well as a series of old-school JRPGs. But, it all begins with writing some stories and publishing my novels.
8 235 - In Serial16 Chapters
Summoned To Another World! Is This... A Love Dungeon?!
Bradley is a misogynistic learning-impaired alcoholic-in-denial who wakes up after a fateful night of binge drinking. He's chained to a wall, covered in shackles, and waits anxiously for Jigsaw to tell him to eat his own leg. When this doesn't happen, he finds a key and escapes the dark, possibly erotic dungeon, only to discover that he is still completely screwed: his poor life choices have transported him through space and time, across dimensions, and to another world, full of magic, monsters, and explosions as far as the eye can see! Will he surpass his crippling limitations to discover the true meaning of strength? Will he unravel the mysterious tale of the Hero and the Demon Lord, and bring peace to the entire continent? Will he navigate through legions of [hussies], [wenches], and [concubines] to find a woman worthy of calling a wife? Who would also be willing to settle for him? ...probably not.
8 203

