《How to Write Stories People Will Love》Question 76: How to edit
Advertisement
asks: I just finished a story and am not sure how to start editing. Can you offer some tips?
There are entire courses for editing your own manuscript, but I'll do my best to provide a solid base to start on.
When you finish your story, don't immediately scroll to the beginning and start editing. The work is still too fresh, and you're more likely to miss things that need fixing. Let it rest for at least two weeks. You don't have to stop writing. Go work on something else for awhile. I like to give my manuscripts at least a month in between drafts. Lately it's been more like two to three months due to other writing projects and writer's block.
This is a great way to gauge the pacing of a chapter. When your brain hears an audio version of your story, it is more likely to notice when things develop too fast, or when dialogue sounds forced. This is especially important for those of you who are speed-readers. Speed reading skips through words and gleans meaning without stopping to "feel" them. I'm a slow reader because I hear words when I read them. This helps me catch typos and repetitive words as well.
If reading aloud isn't feasible because you're never alone, at least mouth the words. Slow down and pronounce the words with your mouth, like you're reading aloud but without sound. In a noisy room, I can usually get away with whispering the text. Even though you may not physically hear the sound with your ears, your brain still will.
This is a weird one, but it works! A lot of professional writers print out their work and edit it that way. A different medium helps you see the work with fresh eyes. I tried that once, and even with a shorter story, it felt like an incredible waste of paper and ink. Then I discovered that, when I copied a chapter from Word (which was in Georgia font) into Wattpad and then read it over, I started catching things I didn't see before!
Advertisement
Our brains have an incredible capacity to acclimatize, to filter out extraneous information in order to process things more efficiently. We don't want this when we're trying to edit, so we have to do what we can to make it stop filtering things out. Changing the font tricks the brain into thinking this is something new because it looks different from before.
Editing requires multiple passes. You start with high-level issues like plot and characterization, which may require adding or rewriting some sections. No point in streamlining sentences when you'll have to do it again later due to changed content.
When the broad issues have been addressed, you can start on the more granular issues, like pacing. Long-winded descriptions can be cut or more setting details can be added. What you should be editing has been the topic of many of these chapters, so I'm not going to repeat all that. This chapter is more about how.
Line edits should be toward the end of your editing cycle, where you streamline sentences and choose strong verbs and all that. If you do this out of order, it will be wasted effort when things get cut or replaced. Worse, you may not want to cut what needs cutting because you've already put all that work into fixing it up.
As mentioned previously, we want to address broad, far-reaching issues first, then work our way down in specificity. Here's a general (likely uncomprehensive) list:
HIGH LEVEL ISSUES
Plot holes or inconsistencies
Characters don't seem to have a purpose
Character hasn't completed their arc of development
MEDIUM LEVEL ISSUES
Pacing seems too slow or fast in some places due to too much or too little description
Backstory needs to be added or cut back
Dialogue feels wooden or unnatural
Characters not acting like they should
Lack of tension
LOW LEVEL ISSUES
Sentences are bloated with unnecessary words
Too much telling when it should be showing
Passive sentences
Weak verbs
Misspelled words and incorrect grammar are the smallest items to fix, yet hugely important. Programs like Word or Open Office (which is free) have spelling and grammar checkers built in. There are also online checkers like Grammarly and Scribens. I wouldn't waste an entire editing pass on just proofreading for spelling and grammar. If you didn't catch them during your first several passes, you're not likely to catch them now. Get external help.
Any editing tips of your own you'd like to share?
Advertisement
- In Serial38 Chapters
Karl
This story follows a young man, Karl, as he is abruptly reborn in another world as a goblin without explanation. He struggles to find out why it happened to him as he explores a world that is both unnervingly familiar and yet still strange. *** I have given this story several content tags that may not fit the early chapters, such as litrpg. It will take a few chapters for those elements to be introduced.
8 211 - In Serial8 Chapters
Obsession x Mana
The modern world had become exposed to a new element which became unanimously known as "Mana" after a freak meteorite incident, creating people with superpowers and monsters that threaten life on Earth. Perun, the "Progenitor" of the meta-humans retired as a war hero and created a Dark Guild, its members being the war orphans he had adopted throughout his career. His peaceful life of filling paperwork begins to collapse as the nightmare of his "Awakening" becomes increasingly unbearable, forcing his once-powerful abilities to turn dormant. Unbeknownst to Perun, the problem children he had adopted since young, have grown up into girls with cheat-level abilities due to the properties of his mana; they became meta-humans far beyond the level of humanity, powers that contest a twisted love monopoly for their father. Should anyone bare their fangs (or romantic interest) towards their beloved one, their sweet facades shall break with no hesitation. When their seemingly unaware Master is forced to return to the center stage again as a "Level 1" character like the rest of the world, his obsessive daughters shall move beneath the shadows to create his new legend. This is the story of yanderes & obsessions.
8 86 - In Serial9 Chapters
Colossus of Catastrophe
A world where he's stuck in a game like setting. Sign him up! Except that Lazarus found himself stuck in a cave with nothing but glowing crystals and the skittering of rats. And according to the glowing blue box he'd been affected by unforeseen circumstances and transported to the world of Zara. What the hell was that?! He didn't like caves at all! He didn't get any powers! Only this blue box fixed in front of him... Hello this book will be a lit-rpg in a fantasy world. It will be primarily action and adventure. I dislike characters who get tied down and suckered, so if your looking for kingdom building or large interpersonal relations this isn't it. There will be some but it won't be the focus. He will be somewhat of an antihero but more in the sense that Lazarus will be free. I'm not the most experienced writer, but I would love feedback to improve. Thank you for reading!
8 190 - In Serial11 Chapters
BASE Status: Update (BASE Status 2)
Augmented reality like you’ve never experienced before!No more need for headsets or other devices to dive into a virtual world, everything comes right from your BASE unit!Try out this brand new experience with Shades of the Spirit World! After saving Helheim Fallen Online from certain company destruction and a lot of people from harm, Willow’s life seems to be going in the right direction. She has a job, her best friends in the guild she plays in and plans for the future. A future that she never thought she’d be able to get not even six months ago, a future that was kept from her because she’s autistic. Now an update to the BASE (Bioelectrical Augmented Synapse Enhancement) unit and platform open up a world of opportunities for her. It promises a full virtual reality experience but as an augmented reality instead, something she’s been wishing for for years. The new game that’s going to be released at the same time as the update, Shades of the Spirit World, at first just seems like a fun way to spend the time. It’s not the most complicated or involved of games, but it looks beautiful. That is, until some strange things start to happen in the AR world. Some AI are showing very human traits, more so than anything she’s seen before.And when there are reports of AI going rogue and killing other AI, something the game hadn’t been programmed to do, things start to get really interesting.
8 194 - In Serial11 Chapters
The Sanctuary Core
Summoned to balance the miasmas of Dungeons, so called Sanctuaries- everything opposite of what a dungeon is and does, serve to counter death with life and bring balance to the world. Serving as a Sanctuary Master in charge of managing one of these defenses, Thomas Cutter is pulled from his own world along with his home. Aided by a helpful nymph and a magical book for controlling his territory, Tom must grow his lands enough to halt the dungeon that lay deep in the southern mountains or die in failure. Disclaimer / Author’s note: I’m writing this story purely as something to do. If you choose to read it, I’m glad, but it’s certainly more written for my own enjoyment than anyone else’s, so… sorry if it’s not for you. With that, do be gracious with me, as well as offer whatever helpful criticisms you might have. I’d be much obliged. Enjoy!
8 160 - In Serial10 Chapters
-ateez little space-
𝘐𝘧 𝘺𝘰𝘶 𝘸𝘢𝘯𝘵 𝘢𝘯𝘺 𝘢𝘵𝘦𝘦𝘻 𝘣𝘰𝘺𝘹𝘣𝘰𝘺 𝘸𝘳𝘪𝘵𝘵𝘦𝘯 𝘱𝘭𝘻 𝘳𝘦𝘲𝘶𝘦𝘴𝘵 𝘵𝘩𝘢𝘯𝘬𝘪𝘦𝘴 :>Editor: @pjmsprinkles
8 86

