《Book reviews *Requests Closed*》'My little El' by Mini_Peppermint'
Advertisement
'My little El' is the story of Eleanor, a rich girl struggling to survive, and Lucas; her neighbour, her bully, and a badboy.
That's all I can say about it, really. The moment I see the word 'badboy', I start squinting in suspicion. Call it prejudiced, but Wattpad and badboys… simply is a risky combination. And boy (pun intended), this story is risky.
First of all, while the events unfolding in the story seem to be decently-crafted, I have no idea where this story is going. What is it supposed to be? A love story? Crime drama? Social commentary? I have no clue. While it's great to combine aspects of and mix certain genres together, I do believe a story should have an idea of what it's trying to be. With this story, I mostly feel like we're walking around aimlessly. So, well-crafted or not, I'd like to urge the author to give some thought to this question: 'what is my goal as I write this and how can I convince my readers I know what I'm doing?'
Mind you, you don't actually need to know what you're doing. The readers just need to think you do. That's a secret of the trade, y'all.
Moving on to the characters. They're interesting enough; I like how Lukas has more depth than originally thought, and the plot twist with René was interesting. However, when it comes to character relationships, I do need to say this:
Look. I get it. Wattpad loves badboys, and it especially loves getting them wrong. A badboy, in Wattpad's vocabulary, seems to be 'toxic creepy psycho with a hidden soft side'. That… is not necessarily what a badboy is. Wattpad likes to romanticize these toxic creepy psychos it loves so much, and Lukas, so far, meets the criteria of being one. Author, unless you're deliberately trying to portray what will culminate in a unhealthy relationship, I'll ask you to read over what you wrote and examine it carefully. Because the two characters I'm seeing in this story have a long, long fucking way to go before they can even have something resembling a normal relationship, and even then, the bad start they had seems so immense I have trouble believing anything good can ever come out of it.
Advertisement
On to the GPS. While choice of words and spelling are very good, the sentences and their structures are wobbly as hell and the interpunction isn't to write home about either. A shame, because the narrative voice sounds very interesting, and I really liked some metaphors I saw. It's a shame those are weakened by the wonky sentences, which makes the story harder to read and more difficult to understand. I'd recommend some editing.
I think this has potential if the flaws are straightened out. For now, I'm going to stick with this rating: 6.5
Advertisement
Legend of the Empyrean Blacksmith
LEGEND OF THE EMPYREAN BLACKSMITH After being kicked out of the orphanage due to turning 15, Lino finds himself stranded on the streets. With motivation to become the best blacksmith in the world, he seeks to become a disciple of the Bridge Village's best blacksmiths, only to be kicked out of all of them. He soon finds himself roaming the streets aimlessly on an empty stomach, jobless, peniless and homeless. After hiding himself in an alley when night fell, the reality finally catches up to him - he was truly alone. Yet, morning come, he is greeted by a knee of an old man who, after beating him for sleeping in the old man's 'backyard', takes him in. Finally being given a helping hand, he clutches tightly onto it, becoming the old man's disciple and learning the ways of the crafting, naturally while flirting with the old man's wife in his free time. Little did he know that this encounter would spark an adventure that would take him to the heights he never believed even existed, and would let him meet people he'd only read about in the books. It's a story of Lino - an orphaned child who would come to be known by many names, but only one that he'd ever truly accept: Empyrean Blacksmith. Release schedule: 3 times a week (Mon, Wed, Fri) If you want to further support me, you can visit my Patreon page: BeddedOtaku Patreon You can find the glossary here. It's currently incomplete but I do update it once in a while.
8 410The Devil's Parcel
Throughout known history, men have been trying to attain Everlasting Peace in this world, but all attempts ended up in war. Lilith and her friends are trying to get by in this world and complete their goals, but it's hard when people are trying to destroy it at the same time. Lilith will have to face challenges to reach her goals, but can she do it?
8 203The Student Council | Ray
(y/n) (l/n) never liked the idea of having a group of people to be close to. But when her best friend introduces her to the student government, she tries it for the sake of the good of her wellbeing.Let's hope she survives in the fated council room of secrets, rivalry, and romance.
8 446Princess with blue eyes | completed
Ер бусын цэнхэр нүдтэй гүнж мэндэлжээ. Neptune гараг даяараа баярлан цэнгэж байвч хааны ордон тийм биш байлаа. Гүнж цэнхэр нүдтэй. Усан цэнхэр мэт. Гэвч зарим үедээ гүн цэнхэр болж хувирна. Хаан Гүнжийг ордноос холын хол руу явуулж насанд хүртлээ ирэхийг нь хориглоно. Цэнхэр нүдтэй гүнжийг амьдралыг төсөөлөөрэй.
8 139Heart and Soul (Stingsu, Sting X Natsu)!
What happens when Sting and Rogue are beaten by Natsu in the grand magic games?! Well... we've seen that! What happens when they were beaten so horribly they were knocked out for days instead of hours and aren't cleared to return to their inn? Well that's where things go sidestep and start rolling in a different direction. No close calls with death for lector, and a whole lot of new friends and family for Sting and Rogue! Some characters are a little out of character because I'm a pretty shitty author, and I created my own idea for how to portray them somehow so... yeah!(Sting X Natsu)Any Rogue X Erza vibes, and jokes, aren't a ship but rather something quite devious that was cooked up for another relationship, *wink wink* *cough* Jellal *cough*
8 182Are you for real?! (Naruto various x reader)
Welp, you read the title.It's one of those OP modern reader ones.........!I do not own Naruto, credits to Masashi Kishimoto for making it!Status: OngoingStarted: March 20, 2022Ended: -Book 1.
8 129