Calliope, Dean and Sam get their gear out of their cars, and head for the cemetery following the men that were pretending to be Sam and Dean, "Rufus, Bobby keep up" the fake Dean says to them.

"You all right?" Sam asks Dean.

"Trying to be" Dean says as they continue to follow the other boys.

"So where were we?" the fake Sam asks the fake Dean.

"Dr. Ellicott has just zapped your brain" the fake Dean says.

"Right, got it. Ahem" the fake Sam says, "Why are we even here, Dean. You just following Dad's footsteps like a good little soldier? You that desperate for approval?" he goes onto say changing his voice.

"This isn't you" the fake Dean says.

"That's the difference between you and me. I got a mind of my own. I'm not pathetic" the Sam says to the pretend Dean.

"So, what are you gonna do, Sam? Kill me" the pretend Dean says.

"Man, I am so sick of you telling me what to do" the pretend Sam says.

"All right, you know what? That's it. That is it" Dean then says clearly frustrated with the men pretending to be him and his brother.

"What's wrong Bobby?" the pretend Dean asks him.

"I'm not Bobby, okay! You're not Sam. You're not Dean. What is wrong with you? Why in the hell would you choose to be these guys?" Dean asks frustration in his voice.

"Because we're fans, like you" the guy pretending to be Sam says to him.

"No, I am not a fan, okay. Not fans. In fact, I think that the Dean and Sam's story sucks. It is not fun, it's not entertaining. It is a river of crap that would send most people howling to the nuthouse. So you listen to me, their pain is not for your amusement. I mean, you think that they enjoy being treated like circus freaks?" Dean says to them.

"Uh-I don't think they care, because they're fictional characters" the pretend Dean says.

"Oh, they care, believe me. They care a lot" Dean says as he walks past them.

"He, uh, he takes the story really seriously" Sam explains as they all head off for the cemetery.

The five of them use their flashlights and start looking around for the graves of the boys and of Letica Gore. "Found the four boys" Dean then says looking over at Sam and Calliope.

"And here's Leticia Gore" Sam says as him and Calliope find a stone with the woman's name on it.

Dean then looks over at the guys that came with them, "Uh, what are you guys doing?" Dean asks them.

"We're looking for bones, genius" the pretend Dean says, "They gotta be around here somewhere" he adds.

"Okay, generally, bones are in the ground" Dean says as him, Sam and Calliope put their bags down, getting their shovels out.

"Yeah, I know that. I'm just—" the pretend Dean sees them taking shovels out, "Wait, hold on. Are you guys serious" he asks.

"Deadly" Dean tells him.

"We're not really digging up graves, you guys. We're just playing the game" the pretend Sam says.

"You want to win the game, don't you" Calliope says to them as her Sam and Dean get started.

Dean and Calliope were digging out the grave, as Sam stood with the other boys. Just then Calliope hits something, and they realize they found the coffin. As Dean goes to pry it open the wind starts to pick up in the cemetery, and it begins to get chilly.

Dean opens the coffin to discover the skeleton of Leticia Gore inside, "That's not a plastic skeleton. That's a-that's a 'skeleton' skeleton" the one guy says.

"You just dug up a real grave" the other guy says.

"Yeah" Dean says looking up at the men.

"You guys are nuts" the one guy says looking at Sam.

"I thought you said you wanted to be hunters" Sam says to him.

"Hunters aren't real, man, This isn't real" he says to Sam, as both men start to walk away.

"My God, you guys have seriously lost your grip on this" the other guy says as he turns to look back at Sam, he has a look on his face.

"What?" Sam asks.

"Naughty, naughty, naughty" they then hear a creepy woman's voice say as Sam goes flying across the grounds. Calliope then jumps out of the grave, seeing the other boys starting to run away, but get stopped by Letica's ghost. Calliope grabs the rock salt and starts pouring it all of the bones, as Dean tosses the lighter fluid all over, and flicks his zeepo open, lighting the bones on fire. The ghost then screams and disappears in flames, as Calliope helps Sam get back up.

"Real enough for you" Dean says once he's out of the grave and looks at the men.

Sam, Calliope and Dean put their things back in their cars and head back inside the hotel, where they see the guys seated at the bar, getting shots, "That was really—" the one guys says.

"Awful, right" Dean comes up behind them saying, and they both turn to look at them, "Exactly" Dean adds. Dean then reaches into his pocket taking a bill out, and places it on the bar, "Rounds on us, guys" he says patting the one that had been pretending to be him.

"See you around, boys" Calliope says as she turns to walk away with Sam and Dean.

"Hey, how did you know how to do all that?" the one asks them.

"We, umm" Sam says as Dean and Calliope both look at him curious at what he was going to say, "We read the books" he says and the three of them walk away.

"Hey, Chuck" Dean says as they spot Chuck standing nearby talking to the man in charge of the convention, "Good Luck with the Supernatural books and screw you very much" Dean tells him, as they make their way to leave the hotel. Dean, Sam and Calliope walk up to the doors, and the boys go to push them open, when the doors don't budge. Dean plays with the lock thinking it might be stuck, and tries again. Calliope pushes him aside, and she tries opening the door, and it still doesn't move. She then focuses on it, trying to use her abilities to get it open, and they are sealed shut.

"That's weird" Dean says to Sam and Calliope.

"Definitely" Sam and Calliope say together. The three of them then split up and go around checking each and every exit in the building. Calliope even tried using her powers to get out, and she was able to get outside the building. She tries opening the doors from the outside, and they are not even opening to allow people entry into the building. Calliope then gets herself back in using her abilities, and looks for Sam and Dean.

"Hey, anything?" Dean asks Sam and Calliope.

"Every exit's locked" Sam tells him.

"I was able to get out using my powers, and the doors are locked from both sides. It seems like there is almost-"Calliope says.

"Something's keeping us in?" Dean finishes saying for her.

"Yeah, this is bad" Sam says.

"Gee, you think, Sammy?" Dean sarcastically says.

Just then they hear a woman screaming, and the three of them race off, finding the girl that had been dressed like Letica from earlier, "Don't go in there" she says to them.

"Go, get downstairs, now" Calliope says to the girl and she takes off running.

Sam, Dean and Calliope head to where the girl had pointed out to them, and they see the boy that they had met in the attic seated in the corner, "Why'd you do that? Why did you send my mommy away?" the ghost boy cries out.

"Uhh maybe because of the high and tight she gave you, huh?" Dean says to the ghost, "How about some thanks" he goes on to say, and both Calliope and Sam clear their throat getting Dean's attention. "I'm just saying a little gratitude might be nice one in a while" Dean says looking at both of them, before looking back at the boy.

"My mommy didn't do this to me" the ghost boy says to them.

"What?" Sam asks the ghost.

"Who did it to you then?" Calliope asks and the boy just disappears. As the three of them stand there trying to process what the boy said they hear a man screaming out in German. Running toward the noise the three of them discover the man that was dressed at the Hook Man, dead on the ground his head scalped.

The three of them head back downstairs, and Calliope and Sam enter the room that Chuck had been going more talking to the crowd of convention attendees. Sam then runs on stage, informing Chuck of what was going on, "What? Holy Crap!" Chuck shouts out, and Sam grabs the mic, covering it up as he explains that Chuck has to keep the crowd in this room, and keep them entertained while the three of them deal with the new problem. Sam then walks off the stage, and Chuck looks back at the audience, "Okay, so good news, I got much more to tell you, I guess. It's awesome" he says as Sam heads over toward Calliope. They see Dean getting the rest of the hotel employees to gather in the same room as the rest of the convention attendees. Once they know everyone is in the room, Sam, Calliope and Dean all pour salt by the doors. "Okay, new theory" Sam says looking at Calliope and Dean.

"The legends about Leticia are ass-backwards obviously" Dean says to him.

"So, how about we say the three orphan boys were playing cowboys and Indians" Calliope says to the men,

"LARPing as cowboys and Indians" Dean comments.

"Sure, they might have scalped Leticia's son and killed him. Leticia caught them, and went crazy, stabs them then kills herself" Calliope says.

"If that's true, it means we got three bloodthirsty brats in the building" Sam says to her.

"Yeah, Leticia was the only one keeping them under control" Dean says to them.

"Until we took her out" Sam comments.

"Yeah smooth move on our part" Dean says, "We got to get to the cemetery and torch the boys bones" he adds.

"How? We're trapped, we don't even have our guns" Sam says, "The ghosts are running this joint, and they're only scared of one thing" Sam adds.

"I'm not trapped, I can get out" Calliope says to them.

"No, I am not having you go after those bones on your own, you need back up and we aren't even sure you can take one of us out there with you" Dean says as he then thinks over what Sam had said to him, "I've got another idea though" he says, as he walks away.

Sam, Calliope and Dean walk up to the girl that they had been dressed as Letica, and Dean explains to her his plan to lure out the ghost boys. "You want me to do what?" the girl says to them.

"You're an actress, we just want you to act" Dean says to her.

"I work at Hooters in Toledo" she says to them, "No, you can forget it" she continues.

"You'll be safe, we promise. This is really important" Sam says to her.

Just then a hand is put on Dean's shoulder and turning around they see the guys that had come with them earlier, "We want to help" the one guy says to them.

"Just give her the puppy dog thing, okay? Guys, no" Dean says stepping forward with Calliope to the men.

"Why not?" the other asks.

"Because this isn't make-believe" Dean tells them.

"Look, we know, we're not nuts. We're freaking terrified" the one tells Dean.

"Yeah, but if all these people are seriously in trouble we gotta do something" the other tells him.

"Why?" Dean asks the men.

"Because...that's what Sam and Dean, and the new girl Calliope would do" the one says to him, and Dean knows that what they said is true.

Later the fake Letica enters one of the rooms, scared about what she was doing, "I don't wanna do this" she says to Calliope and Dean who were keeping watch on the other side of the doorway.

"I'm right here, sweetheart. I got your back" Dean whispers to her, and Calliope just rolls her eyes. "Trust me, this is gonna work" he says as he leans back and looks at Calliope.

"It better" she whispers to Dean as she holds the iron fire poker tighter.

"Boys" the girl in the room calls out. "Boys, come here this instant" she says and they wait for something to happen. "You come when I call you" she calls out after nothing happens, "Do you understand me?" she says and Calliope can hear the hint of fear in her voice.

"Miss Gore?" they then hear a boy say.

"You boys have been very naughty. Now you open the doors. Open the doors right now. Very naughty, you hear me? Naughty, Naughty, Naughty" the girl says to the ghost boys, when suddenly they hear a cell phone ringing.

"Damnit" Calliope says, as the ringing stops, and her and Dean enter the room.

"Run" Dean tells the girl and she takes off running, as Calliope and Dean stare down the ghost boys. As Dean and Calliope go to attack the boys, they use their ghost abilities and push the two hunters back into a wall, making their fire pokers skid across the room. Calliope looks at the poker closes to her and tries to use her abilities to get it back in hand. She does so and as she goes to swing it at one of the boys, Sam appears and picks up the one Dean had, and attacks the other two boys. Sam then helps Dean get up from the floor, "Thanks" Dean says to his brother, as Sam then goes flying across the room.

"Sam" Calliope and Dean shout.

"Calliope, go make sure the guys got there" Dean says to her, as he is then knocked down.

Calliope shuts her eyes, and reopening finds herself outside in the cemetery, where she sees the guys standing by a pile of bones.

"How come Dean can always light the stupid thing on the first freaking try?" the one guy says.

"It's cause your nervous" Calliope comes up to them saying, and they let out a yelp, "Sorry" she apologizes, as the guy continues to try getting the lighter to light up.

"Here" Calliope says as she takes the lighter from him, and gets it to light, before passing it back, letting him have the honors of tossing it onto the pile of bones. Once she sees them light up, she uses her powers to go back into the house, making sure Sam and Dean are okay. Arriving back inside, she sees Sam and Dean slowly getting up from the floor, "Thank God" she says as she runs up and hugs Sam and then hugs Dean, who seems a little surprised by this.

Calliope then lets him go, "You know, maybe that guy was right" Dean says as he picks up the one fire poker, "Maybe we should put these things on a bungee" he jokes with Sam and Calliope.

Later Dean and Calliope were walking outside the hotel with the guys that had been helping them, "You know I gotta hand it to you guys. You really saved our asses back there. So you know, thanks. Guys, I don't even know you names" Dean says to them.

"Oh, well I'm Barnes. This is Damian. What are yours?" Barnes asks the two of them.

"Dean, the real Dean. And she is Calliope the real Calliope" Dean tells them.

The men look at the two of them, not really understanding what Dean was telling them, as Barnes starts laughing, and so does Damian.

"Yeah, right, me too" Damian says to them.

"Get the hell out of here, Dean" Barnes jokes and Calliope and Dean just go along with it.

"Anyway, thanks again" Calliope tells them, as Dean and her start to walk away.

"You're wrong, you know" Damian says to them and they turn back to look at him.

"Sorry?" Dean asks.

"About Supernatural. No offense, but I'm not sure you get what the story's about" he tells them.

"Is that so?" Dean asks.

"All right, look. In real life, he sells stereo equipment, I fix copiers. Our lives suck. But to be Sam and Dean...to wake up every morning and save the world...to have a brother who would die for you...plus someone that is falling in love with you, well, who wouldn't want that?" Damien says to them.

"Maybe you got a point" Dean says to them, "You two don't make a bad team yourselves" Dean adds.

"How do you two really know one another anyway?" Calliope asks.

"Oh, well, we met online. Supernatural chat room" Barnes smiles at her.

"Oh, well it must be nice to get our of your parent's bedroom, make some friends" Dean says and Calliope nudges him at the comment.

"We're more than friends" Damian then says as he takes Barnes hand, "We're partners" and Calliope smiles at this.

"Oh" Dean says as Barnes leans against Damien, "Well, Ahem, Howdy, partners" Dean says trying to not feel awkward.

"Howdy" Barnes says back at Dean.

"Good for you guys" Calliope says as she follows Dean.

"Hey, do umm that wasn't awkward at all" Dean says to Calliope as they walk toward their cars.

"Well love is love, and you can find it anywhere I guess" she says to him.

"So, was what they said true, are you in love with Sam or me?" Dean then asks her.

"I'm not gonna answer that Dean" she says to him, "But they were right, I do scare you sometimes don't I" she smiles at him.

"More when we discovered your true birth father, cause I don't really want to cross him if you get hurt" Dean says to her.

"I wouldn't say he's my father Dean, he's never been there for me. Plus I think you could handle yourself against him" she nudges him with her elbow.

"You know I wouldn't hurt you Callie" she says looking at her.

"I know Dean, but right now a relationship just doesn't seem possible. We've got too much on our plate, we've got a Devil to hunt down" she tells him.

"Yeah, doesn't this mean we are going to kill your Uncle?" Dean then asks her.

"I guess so" she says.

"You okay with that?" he asks her.

"It's the Devil, Dean, he's evil I don't care if he is supposedly family. I never knew my real family because my real family were the people who raised me, Bobby is my family, you and Sam are my real family" she says this smiling at him.

"Yeah, you are family to us too" he says as he pulls her close, "although we wish we were more" he comments.

"Seriously Dean, you just had to say something" she says looking at him, a playful smile on his face.