《Salty Book Review》Review #8
Advertisement
Because I offered this service through Reddit, I won't charge you for this review. You'll also bypass the severity scale, so my tone will remain neutral yet constructive.
To Steal a Weeping Widow's title reminded me of a story I reviewed a while back, and I was eager to check it out. After watching The Haunting of Hill House and The Haunting of Bly Manor, books with similarly whimsical titles now draw my attention. But here's my issue with it: this title doesn't match the cover, and for a while, I didn't see the connection to the plot either. I think an art piece in black, gloved hands - or something similar - would better suit it and if you need help making a cover, let me know. Also, the rose is covering the title which doesn't help.
7.5/10
I really enjoyed how simple the summary is. You gave us just enough to draw our own conclusions about the plot, like who's the culprit and what stakes are being raised. Because you didn't spoil it, it'll make some people curious enough to read it. Though this is a good quality, your use of vague pronouns is confusing - if this was intentional, then bravo on adding another layer of suspense - and the excerpt feels like it was taken from a romance novel. Mixing genres is fine, everyone does it, but you've laid down enough groundwork for me to assume that this is a mystery novel and not a love story. If you feel that a quote is necessary, go for something like the MC in distress about being framed or someone verbally cornering her about the rumor that she's the art thief.
7/10
Since there are too many to keep track of, I'll focus on the main three.
Advertisement
(Geraldine) I hear about her so much but don't know anything about her aside from her being August's grandmother and the obvious art theft. I'm hoping that after reading further and more updates, I'll understand why she's idolized.
(Eleanor) Honestly, I forgot her name to the point that I questioned if she even had one. Try to throw her name in often instead of relying on pronouns. Whether 1st, 2nd, or 3rd person POV is used is irrelevant when it comes to this and I only stress this because if others forget her name and have to keep going back, they'll eventually stop reading.
(Augustus) I haven't read enough to understand his character, but I will say that I love the grandma/grandson relationship you created. I don't see this often. In fact, you're probably the first person I've met who chose that dynamic.
N/A
This reminds me of those murder mysteries I used to love as a kid and because this is maybe my first mystery series, you've set the bar pretty high.
Though I enjoyed this book, some things didn't make sense. For example, one of your characters drank a beverage which you described as scalding and they supposedly ignored it. I find it hard to believe that someone could not even wince or jerk back from the pain. My last small complaint would be that you introduced too many characters in the beginning but didn't describe them well enough for me to visualize them. I suggest going back and limiting that to no more than three a chapter, then slowly add more that are beneficial to the plot. I made notes as I was reading so I'll split each section into groups.
(White Room Syndrome) "White Room Syndrome refers to writing that lacks grounding in physical reality – lacks even basic description, in terms of setting." I was surprised to see that this is a common occurrence and I forgot that when I first started out, I did the same thing. You put more effort into Geraldine, almost making her seem like a deity. I can't visualize anything, not even the characters, and they're both very important parts of a good story. Some parts I enjoyed, like the metaphor about the sneeze. I found it unique and made me ignore the fact that I couldn't visualize the rest of the room in the prologue. I would explain less and try to avoid flowery writing because in the era this was supposed to be set in, it doesn't make sense.
Advertisement
(Unclear date) You mentioned when the art pieces were stolen but to my knowledge, there's never a point where you tell us what year the story is set so I assumed sometime after 1999. Some things should be left unanswered to give the audience a chance to create theories of their own. but things like this would be best explained, or at least, alluded to.
(Grammar/Structure) At some point, you wrote sike instead of psyche. If you'd like, I'll gladly go back and highlight it for you. You also spelled Grandma as Gramma and that could be excused if it remains in dialogue. It'll give the characters an accent which most writers don't like to do.
You do more telling than showing and here's an example to look out for: "When are your parents getting in?" I asked, leaning forward onto my elbows, and twiddling a pen between my fingers. This is wordy. I would change it to something like: Leaning on my elbows while twiddling a pen between my fingers, I ask, "When are your parents getting in?" or "When are your parents getting in," I asked while resting my weight forward on my elbows. I was twiddling a pen between my fingers as I waited for a response.
I love how you separated thoughts from everything else by writing it in italics. Not many writers do that. Also, at some point, I was going to complain about the mood being tense but that makes sense considering the plot.
5/10
Thank you for trusting me with your story, and if you liked your review, recommend me. If you have any questions, feel free to ask me either here or message me privately.
Advertisement
A Sheep Among Wolves
When Leah is gifted with an abusive mate, you'd think she would give up on werewolves altogether. But a new experience opens her mind and heart to pack life. Can she thrive as a human member of a wolf pack?Or will she be in constant danger?_____________________________"My experience with your people gives me absolutely no confidence in that statement." I say cheekily and I swear the corner of his lip almost quirks up. "Understandable. I just want to understand why you, a human, were locked in a cell on wolf pack lands." He says evenly and I cross my arms over my chest, averting my gaze. "Because Alpha Asshole was supposedly my mate." I say quietly and his brow quirks in surprise."I was not expecting that." He murmurs more to himself and I can't help but bark out a laugh."Yeah. Me either."Cover made by @ViaAlyssaNicole
8 213His Personal Secretary | ✓
Cali Wilson desperately needs money. She had her father's gigantic gambling debt and 4 months overdue rent to pay. When she saw a job opening that offered a place to stay and your choice of salary, she immediately applied. She expected her debt to be paid, but what she didn't expect was her life to be turned completely upside down.Meet Christian Wright, the only son and successor of Wright Corporations. Born with the brains, the looks, and the money- he was the total package. Except there was one problem: his personality. Not only was he rude, self-centered and arrogant, he also had an extremely short temper. Employees were fired for little things like being a minute late to a tiny typo in a report. Everyone in the company knew about his horrible personality and avoided him as if he was the devil himself. When his personal secretary is fired for the 3rd time that month and nobody wanted to be the replacement, the Human Resources department had no choice but to give an outrageous offer just to get someone on the job as soon as possible.What will happen when these two are brought together?#3 in Romance [05.03.16]**warning- this story was one of the first ones I've ever written on Wattpad so there is a lot of room for improvements
8 302A Lovesong of Rooks: Angels and Demons Aren’t Saving the World, So I Guess I Have To
The year is 1998, in a world that seems familiar, but is also strange and different. Demeter Serraffield is the heir of the aristocratic Serraffield family, who hold a seat in the Curia of Lords, the parliamentary body that rules the whole of the world. The day before her sixteenth birthday, she travels to Metropoly, the greatest city in the world, where she must reside by law, or give up her seat in the curia as well as her status as an aristocrat. At the Seat of Law, the home of the Curia of Lords, Demi expects to be squired to a man who has an alliance with her family, but there are hidden things unfolding out of sight, and as a result, Demi ends up being squired to one of the most powerful men in the world, Matthias Eisenreich, the Iron Duke. Demi must swiftly learn the rules of the aristocratic society she now inhabits. As if that wasn’t enough, she also has to enter school for the first time, and finds herself the new student council president on her first day as a high school student. She must also learn all that she needs to know to govern her own territory, and to act as a politician. Above all else, she must discover the terrible hidden truth of the world. The world is a terrible place, but there is hope. She will mend all that is broken. Where redemption never ends in death, and we can grow flowers even from salted earth. Illustrations by the author. Books. Books books books books books. This is a story about books. Hope you like books. Age Difference Romance/Active heroine/heroine pursues Kingdom/Coalition Building/Internal Management Aristocracy/Intrigue/Politician Heroine Ridiculously OP heroine School Antics Magic/Magical Girls/Alchemy Modern Urban Magic/Fairy Tales Difficult/Dark/Monstrous/Broken World Angels and Demons Slow burn, happy ending but a rough road to get there. Reincarnation Game/ game-like mechanics. Updates once a day until the end of Canto One, then updates once a week, on Friday. Book One is complete. Story is also posted at Syosetu and Archive of Our Own. If you really want to know what I’m all about, check the essays up in the Intro to the Gabiverse (non)fiction.
8 63Love with Danger in the Purple: Being Beloved by the Hardhearted Avenger
It never occurs to Ding Manman that she would be looted away on her wedding day and to be prisoned. The man named Zhong Shaoting takes away her virginity and treats her like a low creature. Yet she has no idea why he hates her so much. She wants to eacape, but can she?
8 437Last chances (bechole fanfic)
its Chloe's last year to be next to her one true love who's sadly dating a treble maker but it seems like that might be coming to a end and she's lost because she Dosent know if beca feels the same way as she does. What will happen this year will Chloe finally confess or will she forever hold her peace.
8 63#MaAn Short Stories
Some things that might never happen in the show, happens here.
8 204