《101 Writing Tips from an Exhausted Reviewer》Types of Reviewers
Advertisement
Before we actually proceed, we should probably introduce ourselves. As most people know, I () am a happy person who loves reading and writing almost as much as I love dogs. I've been reviewing for a few months, and I've been for Wattpad for a few years.
This story is co-written with - who is also a reviewer. I asked her to introduce herself a little, and this is what she had to say:
Call me Painite! I'm an exhausted reviewer with a slightly critical personality. But don't be afraid of me! Seriously! I'm not a fire-breathing dragon or anything. I like the darkness; it protects us from being seen by people who judge. I like the fridge, it's full of treasures, and I like books because aside from the fact that they don't damage the eyes, they pick up your old memories and store them inside their beautiful leafy pages. Hmm... I like burning people too. Nice to meet ya!
And now, onto the content of the chapter:
Now, in the reviewing world of Wattpad, there are many, many reviewers. Each reviewer is different, as to be expected - different people do write different reviews. However, most of them can be classified into certain 'types', and we thought it'd be fun to break down these types below.
For your convenience, we've sorted these into classes. Feel free to tag anyone who you think fits one of these categories perfectly, and feel free to comment any types of reviewers that you can think of!
And, now, without any further ado, the types of reviewers.
You can't help but wonder how this reviewer came to be a reviewer. You can't help but wonder why people are still requesting a review from this reviewer. Why?
In short: their reviews are a mess. Their review itself contains more grammatical errors than your entire story, they have more typos than correctly spelt words, their sentences are impossible to deconstruct, and you just read their review wondering whether they were even writing in English.
The best way to avoid this reviewer is to check out their stories and their previous reviews. If you can't read their stories, nor can you understand their reviews, they're probably part of this category.
There's nothing wrong with the sugar-coaters! I mean, yeah, they end up being totally unhelpful, but that's alright!! Yeah, they're a total waste of your time, but that's totally okay!!
No, but seriously. The sugar-coater, while great for your self-esteem, is not the most helpful reviewer in the long-term. If they do end up mentioning some flaws in your work, they'll probably gloss over it and reassure you that it's alright because all stories are flawed. However, a true reviewer should let you know that these flaws exist, and they should aim to give you tips and advice on how to improve. They're here to help you, not to give you rose-tinted glasses to wear.
Advertisement
One of the most frustrating reviewers to ever log into Wattpad. Why? Because they tell you your story is good. Or they tell you that it is bad. But they don't say why. They tell you that your grammar needs work, but they don't say what about your grammar needs work. They say that the story made them cry, but they don't say why it made them cry.
I can't speak for all reviewers, but I can say that they probably haven't even read much of the book. They're just bluffing their way through a review and, believe me, it's pretty freaking obvious.
This reviewer is desperate to prove that they can review. They are desperate to show that they know how to critique. But they can't find anything to critique. So, what do they say?
"Your character names are too hard to remember."
"You should try coming up with chapter titles instead of 'Chapter 1.'"
"Your cover should have a person on it because that'll make it more appealing."
All points that, while totally their opinion and should be respected, has little to do with actually improving the story.
Where art thou gone, dearest reviewer? Thou said that after nine months you shall be back. But what happened? 50 decades hath passed, and you're still not back!
To save yourself from this predicament, check the last time this reviewer was active. Then, see when their last review was posted. Has it been weeks? Months? Years? Centuries? If it's leaning towards the latter end of that list, then maybe you shouldn't even bother.
This one comes with a story, really. A story that most authors have probably experienced themselves.
You see a great review store, see a great reviewer, and check the list of genres they review. They review fantasy, and you write fantasy - fantastic! So, you go on ahead, fill in a form, and they accept! Woohoo! But then, two weeks later, you get the review, and you get this:
"Your story is good but I didn't really connect with it because I don't like fantasy stories. So I didn't end up reading past Chapter 2."
This is arguably one of the most frustrating feelings in the world. Why would they add 'fantasy' on their list if they don't like fantasy? It's a mystery. Truly.
This reviewer means well. They really do. They love your story so much that they can't help but detail every single character and every single plot point. Except, sometimes, this means that their reviews include spoilers - spoilers that you don't want other people reading!
Advertisement
If your reviewer does this and spoils a massive plot twist in their review, you should always try requesting that they take that particular section out of the review. You don't want to ruin the experience for the rest of the readers!
This reviewer also means well. They see flaws in your story, and they immediately think that the best thing to do is show you examples from their story and compare them together. Once in a while, this is fine. But, believe me, when a reviewer consistently does this... it can get a little exhausting. By the end of your review, they make it seem like their work is top-tier level while yours is a mere peasant.
Note to all reviewers: it's okay to use examples from your own work, but don't do it consistently.
Does this one even need an explanation?
This reviewer mainly focuses on the objectives rather than subjectives, but probably because most reviews are based via perceptive of a certain person. So this type focuses on grammar and the way you structure your paragraphs and the fundamentals, rather than the way your plot and characters clink and turn.
But, hey, we all have different tongues. The Grammar Nazi is incredibly important - especially to those whose first language is not English, and for those whose grammar needs a bit of polishing.
This type wants the feels! The plot, the description, the vulnerability of each precious, precious character and how they interact with one another. They mainly focus on the events that are happening around each person inside the story and how they react to each challenges.
Beware though, this type shows slightly pissed-off behaviours when faced with stories with plot-holes and two-dimensional characters. Especially when you're getting your villains wrong.
Some of you reviewers reading this are probably hybrids already. Reading tons of other reviewers' works made you realize that you need to improve here, maybe take out a few burn skills there, and you're probably telling yourself now to pay attention to the quirks you possess.
You're probably a Grammar Nazi with 25% Character-Driven instincts and 10% Soul Reaper abilities, or maybe you're half Sugar-Coater and half Self-Promoter.
Most experienced reviewers will probably be a hybrid (as strange as that may sound out-of-context).
This reviewer is a blessing upon the Earth and should be cherished and worshipped. Give this reviewer some love and cookies. Sing praises to them every Tuesday.
The Godsend is the reviewer who always watches over their own words and remains kind even though they are handling a certain story that would be more than enough to send other people smashing their heads against the nearest wall. They are very understanding and helpful, but this does not stop them from giving it to you honestly. They won't sugar-coat; they will tell you what is wrong, they will tell you how to improve it, but they will always remain polite and kind.
Before you submit a form to this reviewer, you should probably buy some armour. You're going to need it.
This reviewer is one insanely formidable opponent with a skill of consuming your entire passion for writing and crippling both your soul and your mind. They are harsh and blunt, with powerful blows intended to knock you down.
Yes, being honest can be really helpful, but it can also feel incredibly downgrading. That being said, this reviewer, deep inside, wants to see you get better. Secretly, they're cheering you on!
In other words, .
This reviewer isn't even slack. They keep pumping out review after review, sometimes even twice or three times a week! And, just as they think they can get some sleep and read for leisure again, their inbox pings. They open Wattpad, their heart in their throat, and feel the world around them come to a halt.
Someone else has requested a review.
Wait, no, not someone - 1923 other people have requested reviews.
This reviewer loves reviewing, and they are doing their very best! The only issue? They will never rest in peace.
And, finally, the last type:
These reviewers have just had so many requests and so many wild stories to read and review that... well, they wrote a book about it.
Any types we missed? Any types you love/hate? What is the longest waiting list that you've seen? Let us know in the comments!
Pick Your Poison - which reviewer should you request?
Advertisement
- In Serial2276 Chapters
Versatile Mage
He woke up in a familiar world that had vastly changed.His familiar school had become a mystical school that teaches magic, encouraging everyone to become a mighty magician.Outside the city...
8 179 - In Serial20 Chapters
Dungeon Devotee
Through all of Linaria, no dungeon holds such a grip on the dreams of men as the Eternal Depths. Hundreds throw themselves against its trials each day. Dozens survive, walking away with power and wealth beyond their wildest dreams… until they go back for more. One way or another, they all eventually feed the Depths. Edmund Montgomery Ahab has sworn to destroy it. Underleveled, undertrained, and underprepared, Edmund steps into the maw of the world’s greatest predator, a sword in his hand and vengeance on his mind. At first his task seems impossible, but with every level he earns, every piece of loot that drops, every secret he uncovers, and especially every bit of power he can squeeze from his mysterious connection to the Aspect of Madness, Edmund crawls closer to accomplishing that insurmountable feat. With nothing else to lose, Edmund has already given the Depths his life. All that remains to be seen is whether he takes the dungeon’s right back. Dungeon Devotee is an episodic serial. It will never be taken down for KU. Each chapter details a single floor of Edmund’s journey through the vast Eternal Depths, with all the levels and loot and lack of cliffhangers that entails. New chapters come out on the first of each month.
8 109 - In Serial147 Chapters
Eternal Rest
The novel follows the chronicles of a soul mage and his utmost desire not to die. In his most desperate time, nearing the end, his attempt to evade the inevitable went awry and he found himself in quite the peculiar situation. His wish, granted but at what cost? What path would he follow given a second chance? He didn’t know, nor did the author, but they would make sure to get the most out of it!
8 185 - In Serial11 Chapters
The Dragon’s Hoard
Five Hundred years ago, four great heroes defeated the Dragon Queen Calamity. Bringing about an age of prosperity for mankind. Now, in a time where Swords and Sorcery are coming to an end. An egg in a uncovered land hatches, and with it’s birth, brings the new Dragon King. This is the story of Ruin, his journey to rule the world, and grow his dragon hoard. __ My high fantasy passion project. Will be updated in batches of chapters, each batch release bringing one chapter every Tues/Thurs. Current: Batch 2, Adventure.(COMPLETED) Working on: Batch 3, Betrayal. (4/9 chapters complete)
8 209 - In Serial19 Chapters
So What If I'm Trash? Who Needs Cultivation?!
Qing Shan Long. They say he isn't human. An escaped experiment from some government facility, a reincarnation of a saint, a freakish superhuman. Whatever he was one thing was clear. Be it Music, Martial Arts, Science, whatever he does he excels. He was a whimsical man. A great man. A man who craving for knowledge and excitement knows no bounds, whose collection of books and personal library would even make Alexander the Great green with envy. He donated to all manners of charities and funded many projects for helping the poor and disabled. A self made man who single handedly founded one of the largest corporations in the world, Wen Qu Technologies, whose influences reach from vast fields of expertise. From objects of war such as the newest aircrafts, droids, and body armor; to life saving medicine and vaccines; to even the mundane such as video games and the fast food industry. A legendary example of determination and hard work. He was in his car being driven to a business meeting to disclose a deal that would help ensure the country could have access to clean energy and help reduce the pollution that has been plaguing his homeland for the past millenia when he was assassinated and woke up in a strange new world. How will Qing Shan deal with his new environment where the strong suppresses the weak? From the top of the world he suddenly finds himself free falling to rock bottom. Unable to cultivate, a weak body, and all but disowned by his family. (For those who read comics and watch cartoons, imagine him as being Tony Stark, Richard Reeds, Jimmy Neutron, etc level of 'Genius'. ) My own spin on some familar tropes. Another reincarnation into another world story. The MC will take over the body of someone with a trash body that can't cultivate and will be hated and neglected by his family. Pretty typical so far right? Except there won't be some amazing miracle to heal our MC, there isn't some magical grandpa to teach him some OP thing which only his trash body can use, there isn't a hidden op bloodline, and he is not from a super amazing assassin clan or genius doctor. He isn't the chosen one, he's just a guy trying his best to make something with a crap situation. First attempt at a wuxia type story! I like playing with common tropes, maybe adding a twist, to playing it straight as a classic. I have absolutely no idea where this is going to take me but please do give your input and I'll do my best so that everyone has a say in where our journey will go. I'll admit the only knowledge I have of chinese history and ancient society is from reading light novels translated to english and some old dramas, so if I make some social passe just take it as because this is another world, not exactly an AU where magic and stuff actually exist. I'm also not actually Chinese and will basically using google to help me with names and other such, if I make a mistake please let me know! (Even if you don't like the story or couldn't bare to get past chapter 1 please leave a comment so I can find out where to improve, thank you!)
8 92 - In Serial32 Chapters
Fractured
𝐟𝐫𝐚𝐜𝐭𝐮𝐫𝐞𝐝/ˈ𝐟𝐫𝐚𝐤𝐂𝐇ə𝐫𝐝/ 𝐛𝐫𝐨𝐤𝐞𝐧; 𝐜𝐫𝐚𝐜𝐤𝐞𝐝.
8 215

