《Ancient's Smashing Reviews》Ingrid - @EireenDonegal
Advertisement
Ancient with another smashing review!
Finished Ingrid by @EireenDonegal
TLDR; A well written fiction biography with a unique, fun style.
First off, let me say the story is not for me. I don't like it. I do not like narrative styles, nor incredibly sappy romances, nor a lot of things. Whether you like styles and genres have no bearing on talent or writing skill, and I hope my overall review reflects that. I am honest about that. I don't have to like a story to acknowledge its strengths within that style.
Characterization: Nonexistant - This is immediately where we come into what makes the story different. It is not good nor bad, but extremely different for the simple fact there is nothing I would call a character. The entire story is like someone is reflecting back and telling you a story they lived in, like a biography. The entire story is a giant narrative. This is shown to great effect by the 4th wall breaking such as "I feel like I've been talking too much about this... lets move on. Back in the days when I was six..."
World Building: Painful. - This is a problem with pure narrative style and non-existant characters. You have to do world building in a purely tell not show, because there are no characters to show it. You only have narrative to tell you. This is style of world building is the only effective way a pure narrative has, and it is painful. Is there world building? Yes. Is the world building effective? Also yes. The method of giving me the information is painful. This is not because of how effective the writer is (He writes well.) but it is simply a consequence of the style chosen.
Plot: Solid - This is where the story shines. As with any style, there are strengths and weaknesses. The plot is given with tell-not-show, but you, at the same time, feel like someone is really sitting down with you and remembering events in their life. This feels like a look into someone's life, like reading a diary, or having a giant conversation. This is effective and well done within the narrative style. It is so good, and so focused on a narrative style, you could literally read the story outloud to someone else and it would work perfectly. That is not as easy in other styles, because this style is a written form of verbal story telling.
Advertisement
Grammar: Slightly below average - Mostly the issues are what one would typicall see. There is a few bonus things you typicaly do not see. Like the constant usage of numbers. Saying 2 instead of two. Overall it is one would expect from a pure narrative style, and so the grammar at some points, despite being poor, cannot be changed without distorting the narrative's dialogue and voice and the effectiveness of the narrative style. People do not talk with perfect grammar and the writer's grammar reflects that. I also get the impression that English is not the writers first language, so you know what? Kudos to him. He writes well.
Word Usage: intelligent but also wordy, like a real person - This is another strong strength of the narrative style and is why it works in this case. A real person is very wordy when they talk. They correct themselves constantly. They are also reflective and either use words from much higher than a fifth grader or much lower. It is different and @EireenDonegal uses exactly the kind of words and phrases one would expect from a real person who is reflecting back on past events in a narrative.
The one and only real problem I can find besides normal grammar things is that a normal person wouldn't remember exactly how many days, weeks, or months pass from one event to the next. They also cannot remember every single detail. Example: "Exactly two weeks later, on a Sunday, at 9 A.M, I picked up my pink backpack with one broken strap, met up with my friends, and went camping to Inari, Finland close to the borders of Norway. There were 17 people, 3 stoplights, etc etc." Just too many specific details people would never remember in their own life. People do not track how many days, hours, or minutes pass from one thing in their life to the next.That is impossible. A normal person would say "A few weeks later, I met up with my friends and we went camping to Inari, Finland. Inari is near the borders of Norway. Didn't see many people that I recall."
Advertisement
Overall I would rate it 3 smashing out of 5.
If you do not mind narrative styles, then the story is good, but I don't see the potential for 4 of 5. Even if the grammar is fixed, i think the narrative style is incredibly confining.
I'm out with a smashing!
If you are interested in learning to write, mastering the craft, want some really good reads, or just to chat and hang out with a mature group of adults, feel free to hit me up for a smashing discord book club that has lasted years.
Advertisement
- In Serial76 Chapters
The Purple Jade Palace: The Hummingbird's Plan
When Teal helps an injured soldier by hand-delivering a scroll to the Emperor, he is offered a place in the Emperor's harem for his courage and efforts. Teal is of Lombock descent however, a cannibalistic race of beings who were believed to have died out. Having grown up on the outskirts of the Empire, Teal finds adjusting to life as the Emperor's concubine difficult and as he begins to learn about his origins, he also stumbles on old dark secrets lurking in the palace. Traitorous spies, unfinished disputes, and old enemies from neighboring kingdoms hide in plain sight within the palace walls, all threatening to ignite Teal's true identity and with it, cause the return of a race of beings who once controlled the world with horrific consequences. The only way out? A possible alliance with a defiant and strong-willed princess and a group of magical assassins who wish to control the world as they see fit. Please don't be shy. Feel free to comment if you enjoy the story. Feedback is always welcome! Artwork for cover purchased from Canstock: by 'AtelierSommerland' I'm currently working on Book Two. I won't post book two until I have a decent amount written. Current word count on book two is 43,000 so you know I am working on it (19/5/22)
8 157 - In Serial10 Chapters
Bon Week-end
He runs the underground. She’s made it her playground. Their time together--the stuff of pulp fiction. When a corrupt corporate conspiracy threatens to tear them apart, they blast back with their offbeat brand of crime and chaos. This story is just one from the pulps. Film critic Roger Ebert once described them as ‘cheap, disposable entertainment that you could take to work with you, and roll up and stick in your back pocket.’ So do just that--and read it on the weekend. Bon Week-end is a novel written in the tradition of Jean-Patrick Manchette’s neo-polar, existing now as what shall be known as the neo-serial. This is Nippoten’s second serial following the superhero epic Entirely Presenting You. This novel will have a rather unique release schedule compared to others. To stay up to date, check out the main site and more specifically the chapters page.
8 114 - In Serial9 Chapters
The Lost Legacy
From the North a darkness comes. Struggle is all Galacor can do with no help and drowned in the murky web of human politics. It is up to a young boy to become a king and lead its armies to make one final stand.
8 75 - In Serial28 Chapters
Rise of the Cheat Potion Maker, a Cultivation LitRPG saga #1
In a blink, I found myself in an unknown land, greeted by the textbox of an unfriendly system. It wanted me to become a great hero, save the world, win the love of the people and all that crap. But this new world already had a hero. Why should I bust my ass, deal with dragons and the unknown, for people I didn't know? Let him deal with that. It's his job! So instead of being tempted by the system's nonsense, I chose a simple class. Potion maker. I wasn't interested in cultivating mana and defying the heavens, courting death, none of that crap. Unfortunately, the town I spawned near was suffering crippling inflation, merchants and people were leaving, and they themselves lacked high-demand businesses. The town would soon be going under.Not if I have anything to say about it. But will it be that easy to escape fate...? Novel contains: Strong MC in a slice of life environment, dungeon diving, boss battles, cultivation and elements, mana/magic, mc exclusive system but it doesn't do the work for him, treasures, adventurers, slow world building, build-up, features that will not be introduced all at once (upgrades so on), actual good loot at the end of very powerful bosses, romance(no harem). As characters develop throughout the series, issues and emotions and even the mc may find himself in a corner or two. A story of an upcoming potion shopkeeper and his apprentices. Building an S-ranked Potion Shop is easier said than done... Current schedule:3-6 times a week- Mon, Wed, Fri.Daily chapter on Patreon. [All chapters are 3k words or more. As of this update 8/11/22, book 1 has been professionally edited by my editor and is now available on Amazon:https://mybook.to/PotionMaker. 103k words. Book 2 is in progress and chapters are uploaded daily Patreon.] The final version of the cover will be an anime cover, but will not be uploaded to RR. You may see it on my facebook/twitter page. Volume 1: https://mybook.to/PotionMaker [Audiobook is currently searching for narrator as of 8/12/2022.]
8 162 - In Serial27 Chapters
Acrabha Stone: Blessing and Curse (#1)
Raised by a cursed man called Hyrestl, Rylen will do anything to find the family he’s never met. But fate has other plans. Desperate enemies plot to steal a treasure he doesn’t know he has and no obstacle will stand in the way of their greed. All the while, Hyrestl struggles to find answers. Unable to go home, there’s only one thing clearer than the edge of his blade: whatever cursed him will meet his unbridled wrath. They’ll soon find themselves thrust into a deadly tangle involving priestesses, thieves, kings, lords and a mysterious stone.
8 82 - In Serial25 Chapters
A Ghoul's Legend
There are stories of people slaying demons, of those who rise up against evil and those who save the world in a time of peril. They are legends, beings who have left their mark in history and admired by the masses. This is the story of a corporate businessman who awakens as a ghoul in an unfamiliar world, surrounded by magic and technology. Watch as he claws his way up and stand atop the world.
8 126