《Ancient's Smashing Reviews》Matthew and the Chimney Sweeps - @matthewchimneysweeps
Advertisement
Ancient with another smashing review!
Finished Matthew and the Chimney Sweeps by @matthewchimneysweeps.
TLDR; If you liked the Book Thief, The Adventures of Tom Sawyer or Huckleberry Finn, this is for you. Very good, fun, and thrilling from start to finish.
Characterization: All the right notes - This story is an ambitious one. It seeks to recreate the innocence of youth while having a more adult-like plot. The foundation of this requires, demands, that the characters be portrayed as children, act like children, have the emotional capacity of children, and most of all the emotional understanding of children. There is tragedy, there is pain, there is joy, there is fun, there is adventure, and all of it requires a certain tone only children have. To that, it lands solidly on its feet so everything else follows with a foundation to work from.
Side characters: Its a zoo! - Holy freaking crap theres a lot. I don't just mean a lot. I mean, A LOT! The fact that I was able to keep track of most of them, the way they act, their roles in the plot, and basically be able to tell the difference between Amanda and Chloe is amazing. This is partially due to the rich characterization most have. (Most, not all.) It almost gave me a headache keeping track of them all as you only grew in characters every chapter, but I made it. Whew.!
World Building: Dynamic, perfect - At first you don't know much about the world. You know pretty much nothing. Yet this doesn't hurt the story because you start off where the main characters entire world really is just a small confined space. Yet as the story grows, his world grows, and the world building grows with it. So at first you only have one room, but by the end you have a full city as freedom, mind, social circle, and life all expands. This is perfect for the plot. Rather than give us information on the entire city when the only relevance was a single room for 2-3 chapters, and rather than give us no information when his life and plot expands, it is dynamic and lets us expand WITH the character. In fact, half the fun was exploring the world with him, going on an adventure!
Advertisement
Grammar: slightly Below Average - The story feels like a first draft for the most part. Its not so bad that you can't easily tell what is going on, but the grammar may bug some. It is better early but the grammar seems less polished the further you go. Half sentences, no punctuation or capitalization, the basic things you typically see. I can understand this would get steadily harder to maintain when you do 10+ chapters and you are still pumping more out, but now that it is a completed story it no longer has that excuse and feels unpolished.
Word Usage: fitting - The word usage fits the character. With the character being a child, the word usage is largely simple.
Plot: Despite the strong characterization and dynamic world building, the plot doesn't suffer for it at all, but provides adventure for the world building, provides drama and conflict for the characters to grow in, and makes a world feel alive. I didn't expect to find myself going from a Huckleberry Finn and tragedy tale into child-level politics and gangs and a Lord of the Flies feel around racing while having family and a hint of Merry Poppins, but it takes you all kinds of places without losing you once. I found myself sitting up in my chair, leaning forward on my elbows, and almost falling off my chair reading the monitor, twice. You never lose focus on the larger story amidst the smaller arcs, and it ends on a massive cliff hanger nicely tieing together every arc together and promising another exciting adventure.It also is a bonus to me that the story is long enough to actually feel like there is a plot with character development, growth, and time to explore everything the world and characters has to offer.
Advertisement
Overall I would rate it 3 smashing out of five.
With polish, it would easily be 4/5. I had an absolute blast. You love to hate the villains, and you are on an adventure with the main character the whole way through as he gets a family of sorts that you want to adopt into your own. One guy feels like a big brother and I cheered for him in the end chapter.
I'm out with a smashing!!
If you are interested in learning to write, mastering the craft, want some really good reads, or just to chat and hang out with a mature group of adults, feel free to hit me up for a smashing discord book club that has lasted years.
Advertisement
- In Serial82 Chapters
Skyclad
Morgan Mackenzie had a very bad day. First at work, then at home, and then her bathtub fell through a portal to another world, with her in it. Now she's stuck thousands of miles from any sort of civilization with nothing but the bathtub and a lace puffball scrubby. But she learned magic, so that's sorta nice. Now if only she could find some clothes... Cover art by SourMonkey and Tox DISCLAIMER: This story has multiple characters and different points of view. Morgan is the main protagonist but she does not move through an empty world. This is a bigger story than just one main character fighting the monster of the week.
8 152 - In Serial36 Chapters
Worlds' Gatekeeper
*Rewrite of World Gate Online* Lucas Lauwers, a newly graduated college student, finally got the first ever Virtual Dive Device, [Portal], after asking his parents for money. He enters the new world of [World Gate Online] in hopes of earning money, finding a girlfriend, and living an adventurer's life in a fantasy world!...Well, his wish has taken a turn in a weird direction when he was then suddenly transported to a completely different world! Using the [World Key], he is able to travel between worlds! Is this his good luck? Or his bad luck? Anyway, if anything wrong hapens, let's blame RNG-sama!
8 185 - In Serial27 Chapters
His Will Thrice Reborn
Truth is fractured. What urges a person is the small fragment they carry of it, believing it is whole. My family disowned me, and I - the genius cultivator of a generation - was banished from the Falling Star Sect. Make no mistake. No one but I was to blame for the plight I brought upon myself. After being cast out, there was nowhere left for me to go. I applied for a license from the Guild of Independent Cultivators, but I was rejected every time I tried. It seemed the world had no need for a person like me. I thought it was the end. Until I met Mei. The runaway girl in whom I sought refuge - an escape from the past. She was a crutch that kept me going, but our journey together was one far too short. The girl left behind a legacy, although she'd never intended for it. Her life shaped the course of the world more than any emperor could ever dream of, in ways the immortal could never fathom. In the shadow of her history was I. A boy without a cause. Lost, save for that one vow he swore to himself when he stood at the abyss of his life. This is the story of where that vow has led me, and how it first came to be. It begins the day before I met her. *** - An epic xianxia story with lofty ambitions. - Updates twice a week. - Chapters average out on 2k+ words, sometimes varying in length.
8 113 - In Serial10 Chapters
[HIATUS] Re:Turn, The Legend of the 4 Swords
Hiatus Note: Currently on planned hiatus while I finish planning the next section of the story to make sure I know where it's going. Chapter 10 will release soon, and 11 and beyond are ""Part 2"" of the story. In the meantime, check out "Clockwork" my other slice of life LN that I will update regularly. Cryo is an average 18 year old, just graduated high school and is transitioning into college. One notable factor about him is he is incredibly unlucky. Over the summer gets extremely invested in a gacha game known as “Ultima Online” and plays it every single day with his real life friends Gig, Yuso, and Shigeto. Cryo becomes a well-known member of the community because he uploads videos online and livestreams and is especially well-known because he almost never pulls good units from the gacha due to his terrible luck, which makes his anger fun to watch. One day, Admin (Administrators/Developers of the gacha game) send him an email inviting him to their facilities to tour them as a thank-you for making content for the game. On his way to the facilities Cryo stops at a gas station to get some snacks and the gas station is stuck-up by a robber. The robber takes a cute girl hostage and threatens to kill her, so Cryo steps in and bodyslams the robber, causing the robber to aimlessly shoot a bullet which bounces off a rubber tire, just when Cryo thinks he saved the day, the bullet hits him in the head with a lot of force, but not enough to kill him, putting him into a coma. Cryo is then transported to purgatory where a cute goddess decides his fate to be transported to a realm that needed help, promising Cryo if he found 4 legendary swords in this world he would gain re-admittance to the life he once lived. Before being transported to the world that needed assistance the goddess tells him that he can maximize any of his traits, procuring thought into whether Cryo should choose looks, strength, or another trait. After being reminded of his terrible luck in which a flashback to his family dying in a house fire is shown, he decides maximizing his luck trait should be the best choice. He is then transported into this new world, which turns out to be the world of his gacha game, Ultima Online. He meets friends and foes and is tasked with collecting 4 swords that appear as lolis to Cryo. Using the gacha system, he creates a party of strong allies to aid him on his quest to return.
8 89 - In Serial7 Chapters
Wyrm's Den
Quest Objective: Enter the Sorrowborn Caverns and find the terrible Wyrm of Azern, a feral draconic creature that was summoned by a band of crazed cultists. Difficulty: Insanity With the hardest quest in the game, Dragon Kings of the New World, only available to complete one night of the year, Sivlander and his friends get ready for one hell of a rough night.... Release Schedule *NEW CHAPTER EVERY WEEK!* Chapter Two — 21st August 2017 Chapter Three — 28th August 2017 Chapter Four — 4th September 2017 Chapter Five — 11th September 2017 Chapter Six — 18th September Chapter Seven — 25th September * Want FREE LitRPG? Get a 100,000+ word dragon fantasy LitRPG today—http://www.subscribepage.com/r3o0o5!
8 179 - In Serial8 Chapters
Mobius
Far in the future, humans have thoroughly colonized space through the use of floating colonies and artificially replicating the Earth whenever possible. Most of these endeavors have gone well, with humanity spreading across the universe like the seeds of plants floating in the wind. Yet still there lurks the great mistake, the endless station of Mobius, a megastructure which hasn't ceased its building in over a century. Dante, a man living in this megastructure, is tasked with the recording of stories told by criminals, particularly those who travel between strata. One day, a prisoner is captured claiming to be Captain Pluto, an infamous criminal thought to be fictitious by most scholars. Even more curious, he claims to hail all the way from Stratum 56, a location so far away from Dante's Stratum 999 that it would take lifetimes to traverse such a distance. Dante must discern whether or not the story is false or true, and the longer he lets Captain Pluto speak, the more difficult his task becomes. *****Average chapter length will be 10k words give or take. This isn't a very serious story for me. I'm writing this to blow off steam. Updates will happen infrequently because of this, and it will most likely be unpolished unless I begin to take it more seriously.
8 174