Marko x Male! Reader x Paul

Warning : Marijuana mention

_________________________________________

⠀

⠀

⠀

⠀

⠀

⠀

⠀

⠀

⠀hours before sunrise when the group of vampires and one little human misfit decided to play a game of truth or dare. Paul, the long haired blonde that resembled a band member of twisted sister, had came up with the idea after getting pretty stoned off of a few joints. He was bored, only for the thought to pop into his hazy brain, which led to the others hearing it and Marko voicing Paul's thought out loud. You agreed to it, so the others males did as well.

By the time you all had gathered into a circle, suggested by Paul himself - just so he could sit next to you -, David already had his signature smirk plastered upon his lips with a dare, and truth, ready at hand for the specific blonde that came up with the idea. You could tell by the look on his face that it was going to cause some trouble, so you prepared yourself mentally, and physically, for what was to come.

“ Paul, ” The bleach blonde tilted his head to the side, while a chuckle of interest tumbled from the mentioned males' lips. “ Truth or Dare? ” A hint of mischief lingered in David's tone. By the way he glanced at you, eyes lingering a moment too long, while the corners of his lips twitched, you knew he was going to involve you in this. Not just by a feeling you had, but the look he gave - it just told you David wanted to have his own fun for the night.

“ Dare, ” Paul snorted out, taking a hit from the joint he had placed at his lips. After pulling the butt of it away from his mouth and exhaling, he lazily grinned “ I'm no pussy, man. Give me something to look forward to. ”

He was doomed either way, but ‘ dare ’ had to be the worst choice to pick. Not only did danger flash in the eyes of the devil himself, but the smirk on his face only seemed to grow until pointed canines poked out tauntingly. You knew David was gonna fuck him over - you were only a part to play in his little game. This could end very badly, like Mr. Asshole himself plans for it to, or it could end, hopefully, with a smile placed on both of your faces.

You hoped for the latter.

“ I dare you... ” David's icy orbs rolled slowly upwards, while he licked his lips, almost as if he were thinking. You all knew too well that he already had made up a dare for the pothead. “ ..kiss (Y/N). ” He finally spoke out, eyes shooting to look right at you. Both yours and Paul's eyes widened in disbelief. “ You love him, don't you, Paul? ” Evil specs net shocked ones. “ That's why your always thinking about him, right? Or are you just that hungry that you can't help but think about your food? ”

Paul had feelings for you? Loved you?

Your eyes darted over to meet his, but he was too busy speechlessly gaping at David. Irises blown wide, lips parted in pure disbelief. Either he actually just outted him, or Paul didn't love you, and David was just making a scene to hurt you. That was his goal, after all, to hurt people emotionally. He could be so cold that sometimes, he didn't even mind if it was his own family that he hurt in the process.

“ Go on, Paul - tell him. ” David narrowed his eyes, not even in a threatening manner, more like saying ‘ tell him before it's too late ’. That'd be a shocker though, to see David showing his caring side for once.

Paul stared at the icy eyed leader for what seemed like forever, sharing one of their head-in-head conversations, before slowly dragging his ocean blue eyes onto the confused male that quietly sat next to him. ( brown/blue/green/etc ) eyes met Paul's own, but neither of them knew what to say right away. Usually, Paul didn't have trouble speaking his mind ; he could always get words out with no problem. But this situation was different - he actually felt tongue tied.

“ I love you, Y/N. ” The long haired, unkempt blonde finally sighed out. “ I've loved since I first laid eyes on you. I know that sounds unreal, but... It's true - you're my mate. ” His eyes flickered to the ground to avoid the rejection he knew was to come, for the mere fact he knew that you weren't into men. You've used the f-bomb multiple times before, but oh, only if he knew why.

“ Well... I wasn't expecting that... ” You mumbled, scratching the side of your neck nervously ; brows lifted in surprise. “ I guess this is a good time to break the news, since we're confessing... I'm gay. ” You blurted, not even hesitating. All four vampires' eyes widened at the truth that came out. It was a big surprise for them all, because none of them could ever get into your head, considering you always had a wall up. Not to mention, you never showed any ‘ signs ’, is how they put it. They were oblivious to knowing that you didn't necessarily need to show that you were part of the lgbq+ community to be apart of it.

“ .. I uh, ” Marko spoke up, nervously chewing on the thumb of his leather glove. All eyes were on him now, including yours, which made him hesitant to actually say what he wanted to say. “ I actually have feelings for you, too. ” His face softened, as his specs found Paul's. “ Paulie already knew this. We agreed to both tell you at some point... I guess now was a good time. ”

You inhaled sharply as you took in this information. Not only did you have two guys, two of your friends that had feelings for you, but you had two mates. You were human, they were vampires - this was a lot. Even if you returned the feelings, what would become of this? What would people say? Surely, they'd judge you all, if the three of you were to date. You personally wouldn't care, but you didn't want Marko and Paul having an even worse reputation than they already have.

“ Boy, we don't care about that! ” Paul barked a laugh, while slapping your shoulder roughly. Right, they could read minds. “ If anyone has anything to say, they can answer to us! ” His orbs flickered to meet Marko's once again. “ Right, Marky? ”

Marko scrunched his nose up at the nickname. “ Don't call me that, ” huffing, he moved his gaze onto you ; a single, leather-clad hand lifting to grab at your own. He intertwined your fingers with his, while a small grin overtook his lips. “ but Paul's right. If anyone has some shit to say, just leave them to me - I'll rip 'em to shreds. ”

With an angelic face like Marko's, you'd never expect to hear such a thing leave his mouth. But here he was, reassuring you that he'd murder anyone in his wake that dare tries to dome between you three. Your heart practically skipped a beat at that, and you couldn't help but wonder, did they hear it?

“ I'm okay with this if you guys are.. ” You bit your lower lip in anticipation, while looking between the two blonde's for approval. You weren't sure how keen they were with sharing, so of course you had to ask.

“ You already know I'm down, sweetheart. ” Paul winked, sending you a genuine smile. He didn't show it, but he actually was quite surprised that you seemed to return not only his, but Marko's feelings, and were actually willing to try a relationship with both of them.

Your questioning gaze shifted onto Marko, who seemed to be staring at you intensely, in thought. “ How about it, Marko? ” To say you were sweating bullets was an understatement. You were beyond nervous, nearly falling apart at the seems, afraid of what the curly haired blonde would say. Unlike the four boys, you couldn't read minds, so the wait of an answer almost made you bounce in your seat.

“ Of course I'm okay with this. ” He calmly replied, after seconds of staring in complete silence. His famous, cheshire grin broke out onto his lips. “ On one condition though. ”

You squinted suspiciously, raising a brow as him and Paul shared a mutual look of mischief. “ And that is? ”

“ Threesome. They want a threesome. ” David sighed, rolling his eyes at the immature idiots. He seriously couldn't believe he had to deal with them.

You blankly looked between the two. “ That's it? ” Their faces morphed into looks that showed confusion, which made you smirk. “ I'm not afraid of a threesome, boys. Count me in. ”

“ Hell yeah! ”

The night carried on from there, with lots of loud laughter, groans of annoyance, and plenty of drinking. You and Marko made out at some point, followed by Paul getting jealous and pulling you into his lap. David was annoyed that the two got a mate before him, and Dwayne? He ended up leaving at some point due to you, Marko and Paul being complete idiots that were all over each other.

To say the least, it was all fun and games - right until Max walked into the cave and caught Marko with his hand down your pants.

All fun things have to come to an end at some point, right?