《Cartoon Theories》Carl Fredricksen was Dead All Along | Up theory
Advertisement
We all remember Up, the only movie I can think of that makes you cry in the first 10 minutes! In the beginning, we see a young lad, Carl, go to the movies to see a movie about a great adventurer, Charles Muntz, who is goes on a journey to South America to find a Snipe. On his way home he meets a little girl named Ellie who also likes Charles Muntz and adventures. She tells him that she wants to live in Paradise Falls (that's where Charles went to find the Snipe). The two end up getting married and continuously save up to go to South America but life keeps getting in the way and they must spend the money they have been saving up. They go through the ages with each other and it isn't until they get to their 70s that Carl finally got tickets to South America and plans to surprise Ellie BUT she gets sick and soon dies. Yea, all that happens in the beginning of the film.
So, here is where the theory comes into play. After Carl tells the construction worker he could have the house "When I'm dead" he goes inside and watches some tv. He ends up having a heart attack and that's when he meets Russell, his guardian angel. He asks Carl if he needs help crossing the street. He tells him no because he isn't ready to die yet. Russell tells him "Well, I gotta help you cross something." . Carl refuses but Russell doesn't let him off that easy. He shows Carl all of his badges and that he is missing one. He has to help an elder cross the street. Russell is like Clarence Odbody from "It's a Wonderful Life", he doesn't have his wings yet. He has to meet certain requirements before he can get them. His badges are the ones he has already finished, and the last badge is helping an elderly cross over to Heaven. Carl tricks the young angel/Boy Scout by sending him on a snipe hunt.
Advertisement
A snipe hunt is a type of practical joke or fool's errand, in existence in North America as early as the 1840s, in which an unsuspecting newcomer is duped into trying to catch a nonexistent animal called a snipe. Although snipe are an actual family of birds, a snipe hunt is a quest for an imaginary creature whose description varies.
Carl does recover from the heart attack and manages to avoid going to the other side. Like the movie, he hits the construction worker, goes to court, and is told he will be evicted from his house in the morning. He goes to pack up his things, finds Ellie's journal and reminisces. When he goes to bed he has another heart attack. His house floating into the sky represents Carl dying but still doesn't cross over into the afterlife but he is well on his way. Paradise Falls is Carl's heaven and Russell continues to help him cross over.
Why is Russell a child? Well, he is a young angel and he was assigned to help Carl pass over because it would be easier for Russell and Carl. Carl and Ellie wanted to have kids, but couldn't, so by sending a younger angel it hit a soft spot in Carl and helped him eventually pass over.
Kevin (the bird) represents a Higher Calling — a Muse, perhaps, or maybe even God himself. Something that Carl can aspire to that's beyond his own desires and wishes. Russell would be fully aware of what Kevin is. At first Carl couldn't care less about Kevin and wants to leave it behind, but Russell eventually shows Carl some of the better aspects of Kevin. Kevin's love of chocolate is a metaphor for the small rewards that are earned along the way of pursuing a higher calling. The fact that Kevin is rarely around when Carl needs him and often around when Carl doesn't want him to be is also indicative of a higher calling. A Muse-like inspiration rarely strikes when we want it to. By the end of the movie Carl has come to accept and protect Kevin, and thereby accepting his own higher purpose in life (and afterwards) even if he doesn't fully understand it.
Advertisement
Dug (the Golden Retriever) represents a metaphor for transition, the change from one state to another. Dug was Muntz's dog but switched over to Carl/Russel's side, he was the worst of Muntz's dogs but became the alpha, and with the translation collar he bridges the gap between humans and animals in the same way that he is helping Carl to bridge the gap between life and the afterlife. There is even a scene in the movie where he tells Carl to "Go towards the light" and Carl does so with the help of Kevin and Russell.
Charles Muntz is Satan, Alpha and the rest of his dogs are the Hounds of Hell. He wants to capture Kevin for his own glory and personal satisfaction, the same way that Lucifer wants to get rid of all that is good. Carl's soul is the prize here; if Muntz destroys the Higher Calling then Carl falls into despair, and Muntz wins.
Carl's house represents his attachment to the physical world and earthly things. Paradise Falls represents Heaven and when Carl finally go his house to Paradise Falls, that's when he finally moved on to the afterlife.... Well, that's what the theory states (the one I read). I don't actually believe that Paradise Falls is Heaven, I think it was a test for Carl. If he went to Paradise Falls and decides to stay there instead of going with Russell to help Kevin, then Carl failed to let go of his materialistic life and chose not to help the good side and ended up going to Hell (Charles' dogs find Carl, bring him to Muntz, he eventually tells him about his crazy adventure with Russell, then Muntz kills Carl). But Carl figures out that it's just a house and that he need to let go. When Russell tells him he is sorry that he lost his house, Carl says "You know, it's just a house." With a smile on his face. They get on Muntz's old blimp and Carl, Russell, Dug, and the rest of the dogs (well all dogs do go to Heaven) head back to North America. The moment that Carl finally got to Heaven is when they landed in "North America" and he saw Russell finally get his wings.
What a sad theory.... but at least it has a happy ending! I really enjoyed this theory and it is probably one of my favorites in this book! I hope you all enjoyed as well! If you aren't following already, why don't you just go on over to my profile and maybe follow? I'd really appreciate it!!!
Advertisement
Night Crow Master
The youth who was fighting in the virtual game, with the game profession “Crow Mage”, are reborn in another world. The familiar Middle Ages, the unfamiliar Middle Ages, the extraordinary Middle Ages. The Night Crow Master took a step forward.
8 528I Became A God Of A Microscopic World
As the world began to recover, mysterious energy appeared along with it.
8 848BREAKING POINT AWAKENING
After discovering his ability in the real world. He fought hard to protect someone resulting in his death. With the mix of regret and satisfaction. He has been reincarnated in another world that magic existed. Possessing the power of the goddesses themselves different from the magic of the world have. He faced countless hardships before meeting a Legendary weapon and conquering the ability he possessed. To protect those innocent people and his friends. Even that he can't kill anyone.
8 193Dark Winter
It is always darkest before the dawn. After the divorce, Katie Fox was forced to live with her mother in New York after the judge ruled that her father, a former Army Ranger, wasn’t stable enough. They called him ‘that crazy bunker guy’ or ‘that paranoid freak.’ Whatever they called him, Christopher Fox was a Prepper. He taught those willing to listen how to survive in a catastrophe and how to prepare for the end of the world. More than that though, he was her father and she would rather spend her life in his underground bunker than another minute in that New York highrise. So, she ran away. The date is November 28th, Black Friday and hell has been unleashed on the world. A freak storm mixes with a deadly virus that turns its victims into mindless hunters of flesh. Katie will have to use everything her father taught her to survive and reach the safety of his underground bunker. Note from the author: Thanks for stopping by! The plan is to upload a chapter every Saturday or Sunday (as my schedule allows). Hope you enjoy the story!
8 163Daughter of the Lost
Behold the Wood, darkened and deep. Behold the Ice, sepulchral and steep. Behold the Plain, scarred and vast. Behold the Desert, untouched and sun-blast. Behold and be Welcome, Araya at Last. A young woman takes her first steps down a long and winding road.
8 232Liana in between Worlds
17 year old Liana is not as surprised as most people would be when she meets Inaya, coming from another world searching for a mysterious danger that could be disastrous for both worlds. She's always seen things others could not see, and she often finds it easier to befriend strange creatures from dreamworlds than her classmates. But now she's involved in a possible plot to eradicate our whole species, which makes her travel through a dead alien city and the oak wood of the Nummerfa who believe that our species are dangerous demons from hell, and other places in several different worlds. All she actually wanted was read her Tolkien book, or sit and watch the stars without being bothered by the existential problems of the Flying Spaghetti Monster. And how is she going to even explain her absence at school? 'Liana in Between Words' is a weird genre-defying mix of portal fantasy and scifi in a tale of friendship, loneliness, and the role of humans in the multiverse. This one contains absolutely no romance and no serious trigger warnings for sex, excessive violence, bad words or heavily traumatising content if you can handle the idea that there are people somewhere who think -maybe not completely without reason- that our species are destructive demons that should be eradicated.
8 188