《Essie's Critiques》Just Listen | MathosinsukaDelight
Advertisement
What happens when a mother abandons her child in order to focus on her dreams? When she decides to lock away her emotions and be fixed on her goals, she builds up anything she touches...but crumbles down on family orientation. Will she ever learn how to slow down in life?
Kamilah Paisley Maeve, an 18-year-old girl juggling high school. Her father raised her and he was the only family she knew of. However, fate decides to play a little game with her when she finds out that the person she looked up to the most, her role model, Uncanny Valley, was her mother.
°°°
We sat back to back, hands on either side of us. Fingertips almost touching. 'Yes, maybe not today or tomorrow. But someday soon, we will be okay.'
Your cover itself seems to be separate from the title. From looking at it, it feels like the image used and the words used are two separate things, when they should be artistically put together to seem as one. While the image used has a connection to the theme of your story, it's vague enough that it could pass as a cover for another story. It's hard to tell the genre or the story from the cover, so it doesn't seem suited for your story. I suggest finding a new cover. There are many fabulous cover shops featured in my reading list for you to check out!
The title has a loose connection to your story. However, I feel that you played it safe while choosing this title. There are other stories on Wattpad with the same title of varying genres, from Kpop fanfics to romances to horror/thriller stories. This title doesn't do a great job at representing your genre or your story. I suggest searching for a title unique to only your story. How can you come up with a creative, original title? If you're struggling with finding something to base it off of, it could be a specific person, location, object, or repetitive phrase used throughout your story.
I found no grammar errors in your blurb, and I got a good grasp on the concept of your story from your blurb. The excerpt used at the bottom has a nice note of finality to close the blurb, and there was no excess of information (or lack of information) presented. However, I feel that you could improve on the structure of your blurb. Your writing is advanced enough that you can experiment with how to make a certain impact on a potential reader or to use interesting diction to pull someone in. You can also shorten/combine sentences to shorten the blurb while keeping the same information. This is optional, of course, but by incorporating writing techniques as mentioned above, you can have a better first impression on your audience.
Right from the start, I found several grammatical errors in your writing, and certain places where a new paragraph should have been started. Additionally, the hook had no great impression on me. It was a lukewarm start at best and invoked no strong feelings or interest within me. You were rather abrupt with your transitions, and you could expand on certain dialogues or actions. For example, Kamilah's dad becomes severe when she mentions Uncanny Valley. Instead of describing her feeling sad, elaborate more. She could be feeling confused, and maybe she remembered past incidents where her father reacted in a similar way. You included the very minimum in your hook, and by incorporating stronger diction, expanding more on your descriptions, and setting the mood for your story, your hook has the potential to leave good impressions on your readers.
Advertisement
You struggled with your punctuation and capitalization with dialogues. If your dialogue is accompanied with a dialogue tag (he said, she yelled, they shouted, describing the way someone says something), the dialogue tag is a continuation of the dialogue sentence. For example, it doesn't make sense for the clause, "She said," to be a sentence by itself. Therefore, it's part of the dialogue sentence. The dialogue should end in a comma to indicate that the sentence isn't complete, and the start of a dialogue tag is not capitalized, as it's not the start of a new sentence. The opposite goes for action tags. If your dialogue is accompanied by an action tag (she grinned/he sighed/they walked away, basically an action), the action should not be part of the dialogue sentence. The dialogue doesn't help the action tag make sense; the action tag should be a sentence by itself. Therefore, the dialogue should end in a period to signify the end of the sentence, and the start of the action tag should always be capitalized, as it's the start of a new sentence. Of course, the punctuation may vary. Exclamation marks and question marks can end a dialogue regardless of the tag accompanying it, as long as if it's a dialogue tag, the dialogue never ends in a period, and for an action tag, it never ends in a comma.
Example of dialogue + dialogue tag: "'I'm okay,' she said." OR "She said, 'I'm okay.'"
Example of dialogue + action tag: "'I'm okay.' She forced a smile." OR "She forced a smile. 'I'm okay.'"
You had a lot of comma mistakes. Keep in mind that commas are used to separate different clauses within a sentence, whether they're independent or dependent. An independent clause has a subject (who/what is doing the action) and a predicate (the action being done by the subject). Oftentimes, a sentence has two independent clauses, joined together with a conjunction. In the sentence, "I cried then Billy ran away," there are two independent clauses here. One is, "I cried," and the other is, "Billy ran away." Both have a subject and a predicate, and they're joined together by the conjunction, "then." Because of this, the two clauses still need to be separated with a comma, the correction being: "I cried, then Billy ran away."
Dependent clauses are just like independent clauses: they also have a subject and a predicate. However, dependent clauses are exactly like what they sound like; they're dependent on another clause. They don't make sense by themselves. For example, the clause, "I decided not to," has both a subject and a predicate, but it needs more context to make sense. There should be another clause attached or a sentence before it that it depends on making sense. When joined to another clause with a conjunction, the dependent clause should still be separated with a comma as well.
Commas are also used to separate an introductory phrase or word before the main clause. In the sentence, "Today I went to work," the independent clause is "I went to work," where the subject is "I," and the predicate/action is "went to work." The word "today" is not included in the clause, and therefore should be separated with a comma. The correction would be: "Today, I went to work." This is a lot of information to take in, but try to keep these rules in mind for the next time you're writing.
I noticed the amount of comma splices used as well. A comma splice is joining two different independent clauses together, and separating them with a comma, but not a conjunction. An example of this is: "I went to work, I drove in my car." These are two different independent clauses, "I went to work" and "I drove in my car." They both have predicates and subjects, and are separated with a comma. However, you must separate them with a conjunction as well. Without a conjunction, this turns into a comma splice. You have two options in this case. You can either replace the comma with a period and turn it into two different sentences, or add in a conjunction. In this case, the correction can be, "I went to work, and I drove in my car," or "I went to work. I drove in my car." You have many cases of comma splices in your writing, which I've pointed out for you. There were many that I haven't pointed out, so make sure to do that.
Advertisement
You often slipped up in your tense. Whether your story is set in past or present tense, you need to pick one and stay in it. If you're in past tense, you should use words such as "didn't" and "wanted." If you're writing in present tense, you should use, "don't" and "want." I've shown a few examples where you slipped up your tense below, so keep this rule in mind for future writing. I noticed that you had unnecessary capitalization, or you were missing capitalization in certain places. The beginning of a new sentence, a certain person, place, or thing, must always be capitalized. The next time you capitalize (or don't capitalize), keep this rule in mind. Titles should always be capitalized unless there is a possessive pronoun in front of them. For example, "Mom" is capitalized when used alone. However, when you say, "my mom," it doesn't have to be capitalized. You were confused with this rule throughout your writing, and you also capitalized unnecessary words, which I've pointed down below.
You also seem to be confused with how to separate paragraphs. Whenever someone new begins to speak, a new paragraph should be started. If Sarah and Johnny are having a conversation, and Sarah says, "hey, how are you?" when Johnny responds with, "I'm great!" That should be a new paragraph. That way, your readers aren't confused with who is still talking and who isn't.
I found several instances where you had misspellings or spelling typos. You also confused several diction choices and definitions. I've pointed out some examples below in your chapter reviews, so keep those in mind when editing your work. You also used repetitive diction and simple vocabulary, so I suggest strengthening your vocabulary. This can help make your story come to life and keep the readers engaged. In the future, if you're confused about a word, make sure to look it up instead of guessing its use. You can also use an online thesaurus to find interesting synonyms for a word.
You had many filler scenes and your story pacing was inconsistent. If I hadn't read the blurb, it would've been hard to understand what the conflict was. As your narration wasn't direct, this muddled your plot. I suggest removing any filler scenes or dialogues that don't contribute to the plot. Expanding upon your descriptions and reflections can further strengthen your plot as well. Showing and not telling is pretty important, but you didn't help the readers understand an action or decision, which further contributed to the uneven story pacing. As you jumped around a lot in the story, it was difficult to understand the purpose of a specific scene or character introduced. I suggest keeping the story pacing specific and consistent. Sometimes, it felt as though you were summarizing events from the past, while in other scenes, you were more specific. If a scene is unimportant, there's no need to summarize it. I've pointed out some redundant scenes and dialogues from the chapter reviews below. By removing these, you have a more clear, concise plot with an obvious conflict.
I didn't get many descriptions from your characters. All I got were their names before you moved on. I felt that you were trying to show who they were through the scenes following the character introductions, but those scenes were redundant. You should expand upon who they are through important moments. Their decisions and actions in important times can build up their characters and help your audience understand them. It helps to establish personality traits, habits, hobbies, reactions, etc.
you had a simplistic writing voice, which made your chapters easy to read. However, this kind of writing style is pretty common, and I've encountered many writing styles similar to this throughout my critiquing career. If you want to add more personality and show yourself through your writing, you can do more reflection in your writing. This helps your readers understand your reasoning and your influence behind your characters. You can also include writing techniques, such as similes/metaphors, figurative language, sensory details, etc. Your writing style included the bare minimum, and a lot of people on Wattpad only include the bare minimum. By adding on these accessories, you can strengthen your writing voice and many readers will stay for the writing, if not the plot/characters.
As I've mentioned earlier, you hopped all over the place in your narration. Your pacing was inconsistent, and you often summarized events instead of going more into depth. This made the story feel fast in some parts and slow in others. You also had awkward transitions and unnecessary dialogues clogging your scenes, which further dragged the pace. I've included a few examples of redundant sentences/scenes in your chapter reviews, but in the future, when writing, I suggest focusing on slowing down and thinking, Is this necessary to include? Or, Is this unnecessary to the plot? By removing unnecessary information, you can balance out the story flow and remove awkward transitions or scenes that are out of place.
In paragraph 3, "daddy" should be capitalized, as Kamilah is referring to a specific person. If there was a possessive adjective in front, then it wouldn't need capitalization. This suggestion applies to paragraph 4 as well. Additionally, when someone new is speaking, a new paragraph should start. When Kamilah responds to her father, saying "But Daddy," a new paragraph should be started. And when he cuts her off, that's a new paragraph as well.
"She has a complexion, smooth and more or less caramel-like." (p.5). I don't understand the relevance this has to the context of this paragraph. You could elaborate more. Why is it that her sandy complexion is a drawback to Ms Valley being Kamilah's role model? Additionally, why is "sandy" capitalized? Unless it's specific to your plot or story, I advise against bolding it. If you want to stay professional, you could, instead, italicize it.
"I wonder what was the problem. I mean Uncanny is the most successful woman in Brewsfort, who wouldn't adore her?" (p.7). I suggest replacing "the" with "his." Additionally, you're missing some commas and you have tense slip-ups. You also have a comma splice. As a reminder, a comma splice is joining two or more clauses together with a comma, but without a conjunction. To correct this, you can either add a conjunction or replace the comma with a period. I typically suggest the latter, as shorter sentences have clearer readability for your readers. Correction: "I wondered what his problem was. I mean, Uncanny was the most successful woman in Brewsfort. Who wouldn't adore her?" Notice how I restructured the first sentence to flow more smoothly as well. This is optional, but recommended.
"It was as if she was crying out for help, but I mean like come on-who on earth, that has succeeded in life have issues?" (p.10). You have misplaced commas here and unnecessary filler words. Correction: "It was as if she was crying out for help, but, I mean, come on—who on earth that has succeeded in life has issues?"
"'Kami, how's you doing this fine morning?' He asked one morning in class." (p.11). The dialogue tag is part of your sentence, and the capitalization should reflect that. As it's not the beginning of a new sentence, the beginning of your dialogue tag should not be capitalized. Correction: "'Kami, how's you doing this fine morning?' he asked one morning in class." Additionally, the dialogue is grammatically inaccurate. I'd love to know if this is intentional or not. This also seems to be filler dialogue—how does this contribute to the plot? When Kamilah responds with "okay, I guess," that should be a new paragraph as well.
"Everyone around me had either rosey cheeks, fair, tan or pale faces." (p.12). You need a comma here. When making a "list" of "items," all items (except the last) should have commas after them, especially the second-to-last item. This is known as the Oxford Comma. Correction: "Everyone around me had either rosy cheeks, fair, tan, or pale faces." I also corrected the spelling of "rosy."
"'Same old story.' I replied. 'You and your scandals.' He retorted, 'You love me anyways.' I joked." (p.13). You have incorrect capitalization and punctuation regarding your dialogue and action tags. Correction: "'Same old story,' I replied. 'You and your scandals,' he retorted. 'You love me anyway,' I joked." Notice how I removed the 's' in "anyways." Additionally, when someone new speaks up, a new paragraph should begin.
"Why don't you stand up to yourself Gelo? Be a man." (p.15). I suggest replacing "to" with "for." Additionally, the phrase "be a man" is problematic. It essentially says that men are strong and women are weak, and in a time of crisis, one should act as a man to pull through. I suggest omitting this phrase entirely in this paragraph.
"'What is it that you want?' He asked seemingly disinterested." (p.17). You're missing commas here, and this should be one sentence. The beginning of the dialogue tag shouldn't be capitalized, as it's not the beginning of a new story. Correction: "'What is it that you want?' he asked, seemingly disinterested."
"that day, our friendship took on a different toll and with that, I also lost my best friend." (p.24). You need a comma, and the beginning of this sentence should be capitalized. Correction: "That day, our friendship took on a different toll and with that, I also lost my best friend."
"'Coming dad!' I screeched throwing my backpack over my shoulder and running downstairs." (p.1). You're missing several commas here, and "dad" should be capitalized, as she's referring to a specific person. Correction: "'Coming, Dad!' I screeched, throwing my backpack over my shoulder and running downstairs."
"Excited to start my year as a junior student." (p.2). In paragraph one, you wrote, "Excited for my first day as a junior." This is essentially the same as this sentence from paragraph 2, so I suggest removing the repetition.
"He took my backpack and carried it himself along with his. We walked hand in hand to class. We sat on our table and took out our phones while we waited for the teacher to arrive. I sat back and rested my head on his chest, pulling my phone towards us." (p.7). It should be "we sat at our table," not "we sat on our table." Additionally, you have a repetition of starting the sentence with "we" for two sentences in a row. Not only that, you have a repetition of starting a sentence with a proper pronoun for four sentences in a row. I suggest experimenting with your sentence structure to avoid this repetition.
Advertisement
- In Serial9 Chapters
A Titan's Crusade
Erik Thayne spent most of his life being brutally ridiculed and tormented for his weight and physical appearance, among other things. A social pariah and diagnosed with an eating disorder no one has an explanation or treatment for, Erik spent years trying to overcome his issues with his personal image and escape the ridicule and vicious torment of his peers. After years of dedicated effort, and a fresh start in a town away from his childhood and adolescent tormentors, he had finally begun to truly realize what he'd been striving for all along. Only, fate apparently has other plans because in the blink of an eye, Erik found himself snatched from Earth and taken to another universe, another world, where he is offered the chance to be more than he'd ever imagined. Now, he has to fight to restore the Balance between Chaos and Order on a world of swords and magic, in a universe governed by the System's laws, which resemble those of RPGs from Earth. Erik learned to embrace the things about himself that others taught him to hate, using them to reforge his physical identity into something more removed from his old self-loathing. But can he learn to embrace the darkest parts of his mind just as he did the reviled aspects of his body and become who he needs to be to succeed in the task set before him? It might just prove easier to stalk in the dark as a monster than to walk in the light as a man... *This is my first time publishing anything I've written to a public audience. Due to formatting issues, I forwent traditional stat-screens for something a little less problematic, delineating stat screens by separating them from regular text with horizontal lines in a lighter-grey coloration. Let me know if you like them or not. Criticism is entirely welcome, but please don't hate on my work after only reading 1 chapter. This is a writing project I intend to complete but I have committment problems so we'll see how long this goes on. Also, fair warning, as the description implies, the main protagonist is intended to be someone who has been treated cruelly, developed antisocial tendencies, and ultimately has to question his own humanity--or lack thereof. This story is not intended to be brutally dark but I will definitely be trying to follow a darker theme. It is intended to be violent and some scenes later in the story might be...alarming. There will likely also be some light, non-graphic (think more implied with crude jokes and conversation than actual details, there will be no full-blown sex scenes)relationship scenes planned later and if you're opposed to either a bisexual or gay main character, stay away. I haven't yet decided which way he's going to swing but the odds on him being straight are relatively miniscule, and I've always wanted to write a story about a gay man who basically looks like a lumberjack because who doesn't like giving conventional stereo-types the middle finger? This will NOT be a harem story, and I have no intention to focus on romance over action--it's a consequence of character development where I'm concerned, not the be-all-end-all of the story. The cover-art does not, in any way, belong to me. It was an image titled the Druid King (by duskanmarkovic according to the file name) which I found on Google Images. Until I can get something commissioned, this is the best stand-in image I could find.
8 106 - In Serial9 Chapters
Immortal Peace
After the sudden arrival of Rhea into the throne room, Olympus is thrown a spiral as they are given the ultimatum of a marriage for peace, or war. What will they choose, who will it involve, and why oh why, does Apollo have to lie.I don't own the pictures for the cover, they were taken from RickRiordan Wiki
8 195 - In Serial8 Chapters
Historical Hamgelica
Angelica Schuyler has always known her fate. She was to marry a rich man that would reflect well on the family. Her father would never let her forget it. She was getting no choice in who she marries.But then something happened. Someone new appeared in her life. And she can't stop thinking about the man. But there's no way her father would ever approve.Okayyyy hey so this is my first fic, and obviously it's historical Hamgelica (cause my OTP needs more rep...lowkey Angelica just needs more rep. She's the most underrated Schuyler sister but she's my favorite so fight me).Anyways hope you guys like it.Also I did have to change some historical stuff to make it fit better. For instance I made John Church kinda a jerk but her father like him and want her to marry him dispite it being about the opposite in history.
8 187 - In Serial12 Chapters
A Filtered Conflict
Harry Trust awakened one day to find that his unit was needed for an urgent missions, insurgents raiding a train of Nevexico, the nation who’s service he was in. Donning his standard issue mask he leaves the safe confines of Foba City, one of the many pressurized cities dotting the now ruined United States. The mission would set off a chain of events forever changing the political scape of the continent… This is going on hiatus, unfortunately, until I can figure out where the plot can go from here.
8 186 - In Serial12 Chapters
The Owl House: Wolfwalkers on the Boiling Isles
Takes place after Young Blood, Old Souls; Luz suddenly has gain the power of a Wolfwalker. A being that posseses the power to talk to wolves, and turn into one when they sleep. Now, with this new power, she must learn how to be a wolf, and keep this power a secret from her friends, including Amity. If she can be able to keep it a secret...
8 188 - In Serial26 Chapters
Unexpectedly You ✔️
"Not very smart, are you?" I say, because I can't stop my tongue from spewing that out. But disrespect much? "I'll give you a piece of free advice..." I keep going because it's nearly interview time, and I don't want to get caught arguing with another interviewee the second before I nail this thing. "If you want a job, don't make an ass of yourself right before you interview."Now he's smiling up to his ears, and I look at my watch again because I want it to move faster.Meet Brooke, Smart, Efficient and Hard working lady of the century. Brooke isn't the type to think before she voices her opinions. On the day of her interview she insults the boss's son. Nathaniel aka Nate, an average, down to earth and handsome as the devil himself. Things take a wild turn at a wedding and with just a compliment, cuppid was told to make a run for his love
8 126

