《Essie's Critiques》It's Coming to an End | _Becca_Boo_
Advertisement
'It's Coming to an End' is a short story intentionally enveloping the reader in the exact moment that we all fear. When promises of 'forever' have now been realized to be lies; that there is no promised future together. That it's the end.
'She knew it was coming to an end when they didn't know what else to say. Embarking the inevitable finality of 'us' was the unaccustomed tension, silence, complaisance.'
The cover was neat, organized, and creative. I enjoyed how the title incorporated the colors of the image, and the image used represented your story and hinted at the potential surroundings of your characters. The author's name is hardly there, however, so I suggest making it bolder or placing it somewhere easier to see.
The title definitely hints at your story genre and plot. It's unique, interesting, and pulls me in. Your blurb referenced it, and it feels like the right fit for your story. Well done!
While I appreciate the conciseness and shortness of your blurb, I would have liked a direct description of your story. From your characters, the setting, and the overarching question, these all could have hinted at what your story was directly about. Instead of directly addressing the potential readers, talk about your character and the plot idea instead. A blurb is basically opening a small window to the contents of your story, and you only have a small space to hook in new readers.
From the first sentence, I was able to detect your writing capabilities and feel myself in your character's surroundings. You did more of listing descriptions rather than linking them all together and described the same thing several times. For readers simply looking for something to enjoy consuming, this can push them away. How can you spice up your hook more? How can you dramatize the moment without listing descriptions for the same things? Try to lend that same courtesy to other things in the character's surroundings.
You struggled with your punctuation and capitalization with dialogues. If your dialogue is accompanied with a dialogue tag (he said, she yelled, they shouted, describing the way someone says something), the dialogue tag is a continuation of the dialogue sentence. For example, it makes little sense for the clause, "She said," to be a sentence by itself. Therefore, it's part of the dialogue sentence. The dialogue should end in a comma to show that the sentence isn't complete, and the start of a dialogue tag is not capitalized, as it's not the start of a new sentence. The opposite goes for action tags. If your dialogue is accompanied by an action tag (she grinned/he sighed/they walked away, basically an action), the action should not be part of the dialogue sentence. The dialogue doesn't help the action tag make sense; the action tag should be a sentence by itself. Therefore, the dialogue should end in a period to signify the end of the sentence, and the start of the action tag should always be capitalized, as it's the start of a new sentence. Of course, the punctuation may vary. Exclamation marks and question marks can end a dialogue regardless of the tag accompanying it, as long as if it's a dialogue tag, the dialogue never ends in a period, and for an action tag, it never ends in a comma.
Advertisement
Example of dialogue + dialogue tag: "'I'm okay,' she said." OR "She said, 'I'm okay.'"
Example of dialogue + action tag: "'I'm okay.' She forced a smile." OR "She forced a smile. 'I'm okay.'"
I also found one or two tense slip-ups. Whether your story is set in past or present tense, you need to pick one and stay in it. If you're in past tense, use words such as "didn't" and "wanted." If you're writing in present tense, use, "don't" and "want." I've shown a few examples where you slipped up your tense below, so keep this rule in mind for future writing.
I was impressed by the cleanliness of your writing! You had no typos or awkward filler words cluttering your writing. Your vocabulary was impressed, and I was continuously fascinated with your diction choices.
I got the sense that your story had less to do with what was going on, more with the idea that something was over. There was contemplative thinking, and this short story got me thinking about the concepts you've incorporated. It was less of a story from beginning to end; more of a story starting from the beginning of an end. It was stimulating, compelling, and interesting. I did get the sense that you focused more on the rigid structure of your writing rather than the artistic side, so the emotions you tried to portray came out forced and didn't invoke feelings within me as a reader. I suggest focusing on those areas. Forget about being grammatically accurate or your writing structures. Write from the heart, and you can edit it all later. Your readers will know when you're being genuine and really interacting with your own writing.
I got a very hazy sense of your characters, as though they were blurry silhouettes with no names or descriptions. I feel that this fit very well with your story, and a theory that I had while reading this was that this could be because these two people could be anybody; they were everybody and nobody at the same time. No matter the reason, I appreciated the mysterious yet authentic aura I received from them. Well done!
Advertisement
Your writing style is very distinct and had me reading with awe. You have advanced writing skills, and I was thrilled with the quality I received. I found that there was some purple prose here and there, but not overly obnoxious enough to be a problem. They added to your storytelling and added to the intrigue of your story.
The way you wrote had me feeling like there was no time in your story, and this, to me, was a good thing. The limited time they spent together felt endless to me as the reader, and there was not a moment where I felt that transitions dragged on. Not to mention that this story is only one scene, so it's hard to mess up the story flow for that in the first place. Well done!
"Under that shedding tree, they stood in silence." (p.2). You have repetition here. In the first paragraph, you wrote, "Under the incandescent altar, they stood. Silently." This is almost the same thing, not to mention the similar sentence structure. I suggest avoiding this repetition.
"... a reference to each flowing vein splayed out on the decrepit leaves surface." (p.2). You need an apostrophe here, as "leaves" is possessive. Correction: "... a reference to each flowing vein splayed out on the decrepit leaves' surface."
"Just Silence." (p.3). You capitalized "silence" here where it shouldn't be capitalized. Unless it was intentional; I'd love to know!
"Still, he says nothing." (p.4). For the first half of this story, you wrote in past tense. However, you slipped up and wrote in present tense here. Correction: "Still, he said nothing."
"'Well?' She attempted in hopes of comforting the nausea ensuing in her stomach." (p.6). Here, you unnecessarily capitalized the word "she." It isn't the start of a new sentence, as this is a dialogue tag accompanying the dialogue. You also need a comma here. Correction: "'Well?' she attempted, in hopes of comforting the nausea ensuing in her stomach."
"'I don't know.' He mustered up pathetically." (p.9). This should be one whole sentence. Since the dialogue tag is an accompaniment to the dialogue, the dialogue should end in a comma (to signify that the sentence continues), and the beginning of the dialogue tag shouldn't be capitalized. Correction: "'I don't know,' he mustered up pathetically."
You have exceptional writing talent, and you tied up the ending to connect with the title. The ending in itself was beautiful and breathtaking; very satisfying to read! There were a few minor grammatical errors that I've pointed out, but otherwise, there was nothing for me to nitpick at!
Advertisement
- In Serial23 Chapters
Archaic Avalon
Set in a medieval fantasy setting. The story branches out, initially following Astor Jacobs on his journey throughout the newly established continent of Mayland. Growing up in the tragedy of war, Astor attempts to return to a normal life while discovering his true future. The purer concepts of magic are utilized by few with ancient knowledge scattered across the world. A world where hints of the ancient past is obscure and dispersed, but continues to be powerful and influential. With tribes of different magical races dispersed regionally across the globe. A story about rediscovery, culture, and the legacy left by past generations. [18+] A blend of Dark and light themes. Mature content will vary as close to realistically suitable for the time period. The first few chapters are heavily action orientated, but this is not the main focus.
8 186 - In Serial9 Chapters
Hidden World
Fantasy x RealityThey're polar opposites. And over the years , everyone prefers Fantasy. We all know why, so no need to explain. But what if, what if? Fantasy was part of Reality? Mindblowing right? I think not. We all know our earth can never have that. It's impossible, or do we really know our planet as much as we think we do?Enter the MC, your other victim of sweet old Reality. He has heavily lost to the world, but tries to live it off like any other person. Suddenly on a normal day of one his random jobs, beings that supposedly are Legends, comes to him for help, to prevent dark unknown history. Will he take it to help them out? Or will he take it to have his second round?English is not my first language, but I'll try my best. If possible, help me out with tags and notify my mistakes. I hope you like it.
8 144 - In Serial8 Chapters
Mindfulness
"Mindfulness? What do you mean Bradley?" I was speechless and I wasn't able to comprehend."You already know Stef, you can understand it by the way I look at you, I'm completely aware of what I feel, we have families and I have a daughter, but nothing will take me away from you. You are my Zweisamkeit, you know what I mean?" I looked at him, he was smiling and it was the best smile in the entire world. and I started to laugh. "I don't speak German Bradley, you know." "This word describes the self-imposed isolation of a couple in love. Their togetherness creates a kind of loneliness around the two of them. And you, you are the only one who makes me feel like this. I can't let you go and I have to tell you, I love you Stefani, more than the word can say, more than anything, I'm in love with you from the first day I met you at your home, you were smiling with your blonde hair messed up, and when you started to sing, I saw heaven. I use this world, Mindfulness because I'm aware of my feeling from the first time." He started to get closer to me and...
8 154 - In Serial30 Chapters
Neglected ANBU
The Sage of the Six Paths, Asura (and Hashirama), Indra (and Madara) and Hamura have given Naruto a gift.After being disowned, Naruto: trains like crazy, joins the Uchiha clan, joins the ANBU, and is training under the Sannin!Minato, Kushina, and their spoiled children Menma and Mito have disowned Naruto. They recognise Naruto as a lowly and watch when Naruto is beaten up.When Naruto is given an SS-Rank mission, to guard the brats Menma and Mito, what will the blonde do? Will he listen to the Hokage? Or will he leave the village with his friends?
8 193 - In Serial61 Chapters
Midnight Lullabies
Perhaps someday these words will make up for the bloodshot eyes and sleepless nights. [H.R: #13 in Poetry] beautiful cover by: @-averagesky
8 211 - In Serial35 Chapters
Memento Mori
(a poetry book)Darling, are we foreign in time, or often overlooking the love we held for one another? the hush of the aftermath; sinks into your skin deeper than my staples, the chasm of my voice, that alerts the pool between your legs. lover of i, was i a lover of you, or a distant stranger? there is a devil on your shoulder, who doesn't understand, that we're alone together, in mori's playground. but this is the tragedy of love, when we end up beholding and withdrawing, and end up in a swift tune of memento mori.welcome, to the depth of every 'i hate you', and every suppressed 'i love you'. after all, we're wishing upon a fault star, my one.A book for the lost, for love, for the pain; for you.
8 347

