《Essie's Critiques》Six-Leaf Clover | ncallioa
Advertisement
In adjustment of every trouble being inevitable due to the Covid-19 pandemic, these two will strive to find comfort in the chaos.
-
Entering senior year of high school, Monique and Justin manage to record their consecutive three years status as subtle frenemies. Even the fact that they're required to work together on the school papers is capable of adding more fuel to the fire, if not for the help of three mutual friends. But when a global crisis cuts all access to their daily drug, changes are meant to be made. And with the return of an old friend, how will they face the following challenges if it all is just the start of a new normal?
I appreciate how the image accurately represents the title, and your cover is very minimalistic. The title could be larger so that it was easily the largest font, but otherwise, it's a very neat and organized cover. In terms of creativity, as a reader, it doesn't draw me into your story. It doesn't make me curious or interested. How can you make your cover stand out in its own way? How does it represent your story or genre? You can work on polishing the cover more, or find a cover designer on Wattpad to help you.
I'm sensing that your title has a very symbolic meaning in terms of it representing your story. It's definitely an intriguing title, and although it draws me in, it's hard to understand which genre it comes from, or what kind of story your story will be. Your title doesn't have to portray all of this, but it's definitely what your cover is for and should show, as I've mentioned above.
While your blurb is short, it's also cluttered. I had to read it several times to understand the concept fully. For example, in this sentence, "Even the fact that they're required to work together on the school papers is capable of adding more fuel to the fire..." it has too much going on. I suggest cutting back on the unnecessary information to convey this message as clearly as possible. For example, you could stay instead, "Even working together on the school papers is enough to add more fuel to the fire..." Along with that, many potential readers don't want to take the time to absorb all this information all at once, especially if it comes in one big sentence. Instead, I suggest separating this paragraph into several paragraphs to make it easier to comprehend everything.
You brought me straight into your character's mindset, the potential setting, and I was able to understand the level of your writing capabilities. However, just like your blurb, your hook is cluttered. I suggest trying to focus on how to make every sentence short and concise. That means fewer filler words, and experimentation on how to make a sentence the best it can be.
Advertisement
From reading your first chapter, I found some comma errors. Commas are used to separate different clauses. There are two types of clauses: Independent and dependent. They both have subjects (who/what is doing the action), and a predicate (the action being done). The difference between the two is that an independent clause can stand alone as its own sentence, while a dependent clause depends on another clause to make sense. If more than one clause is joined together, they should be separated with a comma. For example, this sentence, "I cried, then Billy ran away," there are two different independent clauses. One is "I cried," and the other is "Billy ran away." You'll notice that they're separated with a conjunction and a comma. You often misuse commas in this sense or forget to add them. Commas can also be used to separate an introductory phrase or word before the main clause. In the sentence, "Today I went to work," the independent clause is "I went to work," and you'll notice that it has a subject "I" and a predicate "went." The word "today" is excluded, and needs to be separated with a comma. The correction is: "Today, I went to work."
This wasn't an overwhelming mistake, but I still found a few comma splices. A comma splice is joining two different independent clauses together, and separating them with a comma, but not a conjunction. An example of this is: "I went to work, I drove in my car." These are two different independent clauses, "I went to work" and "I drove in my car." They both have predicates and subjects, and are separated with a comma. However, you must separate them with a conjunction as well. Without a conjunction, this turns into a comma splice. You have two options in this case. You can either replace the comma with a period and turn it into two different sentences, or add in a conjunction. In this case, the correction can be, "I went to work, and I drove in my car," or "I went to work. I drove in my car." You have many cases of comma splices in your writing, which I've pointed out for you. There were many that I haven't pointed out, so make sure to do that.
While you didn't have any typos, you often misused words. Whether confusing masculine and feminine words (typically hair colors) or a word being incorrectly used within the context of your writing, I found enough of these kinds of mistakes to have to point them out to you. In future writing, I suggest looking up the meaning of a word if you aren't 100% sure of its meaning.
I'm not completely sure of the plot yet, as I've only read the first chapter, but I was pleased with the pacing of your story so far. I could relate to the concepts that you brought together, and your story is headed in the right direction. There wasn't much that stood out to me, however. As a reader, I probably wouldn't have read past the first chapter. I would have appreciated more banter between the characters, and for you to flesh out the character in this POV more. It was all very hazy, and you focused more of the character's surroundings rather than their actual mindset.
Advertisement
As I've mentioned earlier, your characters didn't stand out to me. With the characters that you introduced, I only got generic descriptions, such as hair color. These aren't things that will help me remember your characters. Instead of writing a whole paragraph about a character's physical assets, I suggest writing about their physical flaws and quirks. They seem more relatable and memorable that way.
I got a very distinct writing style from you; one that I quite enjoyed. I did find, however, that you often poorly phrased your sentences. You seemed to be writing straight from the head and didn't go back to refine the details. In this case, I highly suggest proof-reading and editing your chapters before uploading on Wattpad. That way, you can spend more time focusing on the awkward phrasing, and teach yourself how to restructure sentences to be the best they can.
I didn't get any awkward transitions from you. There weren't any repetitive transitions, although I did find the occasional "well" several times in your chapter. For future writing, just keep in mind to avoid repetition, but otherwise, your story pacing is smooth and nothing for you to be worried about.
"Well everything started when Jack Winsdorf was elected as our new principal two years ago." (p.6). You need a comma here. The word "well" is an introductory word that is separated from the main clauses, and therefore should be separated with a comma. Correction: "Well, everything started when Jack Winsdorf was elected as our new principal two years ago."
"... whenever he talks, walks, even nods." (p.6). Without a conjunction accompanying the comma here, this turns into a comma splice. Correction: "... whenever he talks, walks, or even nods."
"Aside from the record of Mr. Winsdorf being an ex-military captain, everyone has grown really fond of him even though he rarely shows himself to the public's eye." (p.8). You need a comma here to separate clauses. Correction: "Aside from the record of Mr. Winsdorf being an ex-military captain, everyone has grown really fond of him, even though he rarely shows himself to the public's eye."
"... it'll be a big fat lie if I say that he's not the best oldman-next-door you'll ever meet." (p.10). Instead of using the contraction for "it will," I suggest using the contraction for "it would." In addition, "old man" is two words, and there should be another hyphen in between. Correction: "... it'd be a big fat lie if I say that he's not the best old-man-next-door you'll ever meet."
"I look up to search for the voice and find a dirty blonde head, waving up his short arms at me." (p.15). If you write "blonde" with an "e" at the end, it's a feminine word. However, since we're talking about a guy here, "blonde" should really be "blond" to be masculine (this applies to the other times you use this word). Additionally, this is poorly phrased. You could re-structure the second part of the sentence, and it sounds like someone's head was waving an arm at someone. Correction/Suggestion: "I look up to search for the voice and find a dirty-blond, waving his short arms at me." I also added a necessary hyphen.
"I wave him back..." (p.19). This is poorly phrased as well. It sounds like she's waving her arms to get him to stand back (unless that's intentional). Correction/Suggestion: "I wave back at him..."
"... making Luke spits his iced chocolate." (p.25). The word "spit" is unnecessarily pluralized, and you're missing filler words. Correction: "... making Luke spit out his iced chocolate."
"On the other hand, Luke is the handsome English brunette..." (p.31). Unless Luke is a girl, "brunette" shouldn't be used. It is the feminine form of the French word "brun." The masculine version, although rarely used, is "brunet." Correction: "On the other hand, Luke is the handsome English brunet..."
"... meanwhile I shake my head inaccurately..." (p.42). How does one shake their head the wrong way? You seemed to have misused this word, so I suggest replacing it with something that fits more with the context.
"... Dad was traumatized for me being underage and unsupervised." (p.56). This is poorly phrased. I suggest restructuring this sentence. Suggestion: "... Dad was traumatized that I was underaged and unsupervised."
"Lucky for her..." (p.61). The word "lucky" should be conjugated correctly into this sentence, being, "Luckily for her..."
I enjoyed the pace of the first chapter and your writing style! There were still some noticeable grammar mistakes that I've pointed out, so if you focus on polishing this first chapter and learn to rephrase your awkward sentence structures, your story will have a lot of potential.
Advertisement
- In Serial9 Chapters
A Fragmented Mind
"Hi there. My name is Richard Maddox, but my — admittedly nonexistent — friends call me Rick. I live in a world of superheroes and villains. A world filled with magic and physics-defying powers, and in this world, I'm just an ordinary, completely average 17-year-old boy. My imaginary friends, however, are as far from average as you get. You think you're good at deluding yourself? Well, stand back, because it's time for a master to show you his craft. Welcome to my life, the life of a madman." This story was originally inspired by the 'Legion' novella series written by Brandon Sanderson. If you've read those books and liked them, it might be worth giving this a read. The same goes if you haven't read them either, I guess. (Currently re-writing earlier chapters)
8 144 - In Serial15 Chapters
Destiny's Forge (Rewrite)
The next evolution of gaming has arrived...... A lonely old soldier, a mourning father and son, a bored middle-aged music teacher, and hundreds of millions of others leave behind their normal lives for existence in the first truly virtual world. Destiny's Forge will challenge their notions of freedom, friendship, right and wrong, and even love. Those with the right mixture of dedication, wit, charm, and ruthlessness will find a way to forge a new destiny for themselves.
8 69 - In Serial20 Chapters
To End All Wars
A world where war is righteous, and death in it glorious. Caspar Hahn is deemed sick by his father and is forced to join the army to 'correct' him. But contrary to his father's belief, Caspar thrived in the military. Join Caspar as he fights against the enemies that want to do him and his country harm, as he fights against his father and the public to gain recognition and acceptance, and most importantly fights against himself to discover who he really is. Also Posting this on Webnovel Cover photo by Austrian National Library on Unsplash
8 156 - In Serial70 Chapters
Another World: Scientist
This is the story of a scientist in another world filled with magic and everything else fantasy. We shall see how he survives, reacts and explores this world bit by bit for not everything... Shall go right.
8 151 - In Serial66 Chapters
the twins and there human mate
the twins are the sons off alpha kane and luna cassie. they are the next alphas in line to the bloodlust pack. they are intimidating and cold to those they don't like or those who disrespect them and there family. they are fiercely protective of there little sister skylar and even there brother keaton. however keaton moved to another pack with his mate so it's just the twins and skylar left. there best friend is jacob who is next in line for the beta position when they take over as alphas. the twins come across as cold and intimidating however they are soft when it comes to those they love. Xavier is the "nicer" twin. while he is cold and intimidating people would prefer him to have to talk to instead of his twin xander who is much more colder towards people. Xavier will have a laugh with you and will talk to you unless off course you upset him or his family. xander on the other hand barely talks and is a lot more intimidating. he is cold and what intimidates people more is he barely talks but can read people like a book. he is very straight forward and gets to the point. the only people he softened for is his family and maybe just maybe his mate. precious is a human. she is so kind hearted and very innocent. she is a shy girl and a lot of people love her. if only her parents would show that love. her parents don't abuse her but they barely even acknowledge her. she works in a cafe to be able to feed herself as her parents are barely home and never leave her any money to survive. she goes to xander and Xavier's school but she be the new girl. the new shy girl. what happens when the twins find out there mate is human? what happened when precious finds out they are werewolves? will she run and reject them? or will she stay and accept them?
8 269 - In Serial22 Chapters
Even fuller house
This is all of the kids from fuller house as adults with kids of their own.
8 158

