《Essie's Critiques》All I Ever Wanted | Emsy143
Advertisement
All she wants is to get away.
Away from the palace.
Away from her parents.
When the chance to leave forever and go somewhere no one would expect presents itself, will she take it?
Or will she regret everything?
I enjoyed the way you presented the font and how the photo used represents your story. This is one of those kinds of covers where it's hard to tell whether it's good or bad. You can definitely keep it as it is, but this wasn't an immediate "I love it" kind of cover. I suggest keeping your options open, and if you feel the need to, go to a cover designer on Wattpad.
Like your cover, your title isn't something I'm completely sure on. It looks like you found the title from your blurb or the concept of the story you're going with. I have found more stories with the same title on Wattpad, with many variations. It doesn't seem to reach the maximum potential to fully represent your story, almost in a generic way. Again, you can keep it as it is, but if you feel conflicted, open up yourself to the possibility of finding a better title.
One thing I like is how short and mysterious your blurb is. It hints at unhappiness and has some clue words, such as "palace." I didn't like how vague it was. There are many stories using this concept with different variations, and the point of the blurb is to show that your story is different. What aspects can you include that are unique and intriguing? What is the time period here, and where is the story placed? You didn't even mention her arranged marriage or the maid that helped her escape.
While I believe the hook to be a bit abrupt, you quickly engaged the audience with a thought/concept that your protagonist was worried about. It would have been better if you extended your analysis on marriage for your main character; to go more into depth on what it would mean for her. It seems like you only started the hook this way so you could find a way to let your audience know that your character was getting married. Try to let the reasoning go beyond that and don't forget to include imagery and in-depth descriptions to further hook in your audience.
I found that you have the same kinds of grammar mistakes as I've pointed out for your other stories. Keep in mind that commas are used to separate different clauses within a sentence. An independent clause is a phrase with a subject and predicate (an action). In the sentence, "I went home," the subject is "I," and the predicate would be that she "went home." If two independent clauses were used in the same sentence and joined with a conjunction, they should still be separated with a comma. In the sentence, "Bob went to the store then he went home," these are two independent clauses. One is "Bob went to the store," where the subject is "Bob," and the predicate is he "went to the store." In the second clause, the subject is "he," and the predicate is that he "went home." These two clauses are joined by the conjunction "then," so they should be separated with a comma. Correction: "Bob went to the store, then he went home." Commas can also be used for dependent clauses. A dependent clause is just like an independent clause, except that it is "dependent" on the main clause, meaning that it doesn't make sense as a sentence by itself. An example of this is when you add dialogue tags, such as "she said." This clause has a subject "she" and the predicate, which is that she "said." However, it doesn't make sense as a sentence by itself, as it's dependent on the dialogue.
Advertisement
This brings me to my next point. Since dialogue tags are part of the dialogue sentence, the dialogue sentence should end in a comma (to indicate that the sentence isn't over), and the start of the dialogue tag should never be capitalized (as it's not the start of a new sentence). The opposite goes for action tags, which are separate clauses. They aren't dependent on the dialogue, so when used, the dialogue should end in a period (as it's the end of the sentence), and the start of the action tag should be capitalized as it's the start of a new sentence. This rule may fluctuate depending on the structure of the dialogue sentences and the placements of the tags, and the type of punctuation doesn't matter, as long as the dialogue never ends in a comma for action tags, and never ends in a period for dialogue tags. This rule is extremely important, and while most readers probably won't take notice of these mistakes, there's a minority group of readers who may be turned away from this.
A dialogue with a dialogue tag: "'I'm okay,' she said." OR "She said, 'I'm okay.'"
A dialogue with an action tag: "'I'm okay.' She smiled." OR "She smiled. 'I'm okay."
Along with that, I've found some capitalization errors in your writing. If there is no possessive pronoun in front of words such as "father" and "mother," then they should be capitalized. For example, it's okay to not capitalize in the phrase, "my mother." However, just by saying "mother," you're referencing to a specific person, so capitalization is needed. I've pointed out a few examples in your chapter review.
There were plenty of spots where you had tense slip-ups as well. Make sure to stay in the tense you start with. I've mentioned these below as well.
I found that I'm repeating most of my suggestions for each new story you apply to be reviewed. I suggest focusing on reading the grammar section carefully and take note of my advice. Rather than continuing to make the same mistakes and just fixing the mistakes I've pointed out, try to understand the reasoning behind the corrections, and please ask for help if you don't understand! I'm not seeing improvements in your writing despite the amount of times you applied for a review. I would rather give you criticism for something else rather than what I've already pointed out before. I don't mind repeating my advice to help you, so if you need more help, please reach out to me!
Despite the cleanness of your writing, I still caught a few spelling errors here and there. I've pointed one out in your chapter review, but the rest are up to you to find. I also suggest writing out numbers and writing out full words. For example, write "okay" rather than "ok."
To be honest, I've seen many stories on Wattpad with the exact same plot. I liked that you twisted two different concepts together, but royalty and arranged marriages often come together hand in hand. Your main character seemed to be just like every other protagonist in stories like these. How is your plot different from others, and if it isn't, how can you make it so? Along with that, I only got brief descriptions throughout the story, so I've barely scratched the surface of your character's world. Make sure to focus on world building and describing the differences between this world and our world.
As I've stated above, I didn't get enough information about your characters. Your descriptions were very vague and brief. If Dove looks beautiful, can you explain how she looks beautiful? And is it the beauty on the outside, or the inside? Along with that, Dove may be kind to extend her generosity to those in stations lower than her, but keep in mind that she was probably raised by people who consider themselves to be above others. What aspect of her mindset helped her become aware of those below her, or kinder to them? Was there someone who helped her learn to be this way? It's too often that I find morally perfect characters on Wattpad with little regard to their history and background.
Advertisement
As always, I enjoyed the simple writing style you have going on! However, there were things lacking in your narration. Your descriptions were vague and brief, as though you couldn't wait to get this chapter finished. Even if it wasn't so, that's the feeling I get when I read through your chapters. Slow down and think about the scenery. Imagine yourself in your character's shoes. Think about her clothes, her hair, and her parents. Imagine the towering shelves of the grand library and the humble clothes from the servant. You didn't describe any of these, so I was hardly immersed in your story. To draw in your readers, you must experiment with your writing. How can you make your writing prosper and find its maximum potential?
Although your transitions were smooth, they were rather quick. Most times, you transitioned with a boring sentence. It's like you struggled to find a good way to move the scene along. For example, when writing about the transition from the library to her room, you simply wrote that she walked to her room. This is plain and uninteresting. Stop to describe the transfer of her thoughts, and the change of scenery. Your chapter was very fast-paced, and I felt as though you were in a race to the finish. Give your readers time to breathe, soak in this information, and admire the work you put into this.
"Three weeks from now I will no longer be Dove, Princess of Casidine." (p.4). Here, you have the main clause, "I will no longer be Dove..." A clause is a phrase containing a subject and predicate (an action in the sentence). The subject in this clause is "I" and the predicate is "will no longer be." That means the phrase, "Three weeks from now," is not part of the main clause and is an introductory phrase, and shouldn't be included. It should be separated from the main clause with a comma. Correction: "Three weeks from now, I will no longer be Dove, Princess of Casidine."
"Stupid right?" (p.7). You need a comma here. Correction: "Stupid, right?"
"I yelled to my mother..." (p.10). You started with present tense, but now you're writing in past tense. Make sure to correct this error and keep your tense consistent when writing. This suggestion applies to the rest of your chapter, as you're frequently switching back and forth.
"'...I will not go forward with this marriage.' I said calmly." (p.14). Since "I said calmly," is a dialogue tag, it should be part of the sentence. That means the dialogue should end with a comma and not a period to indicate that the sentence continues. Correction: "'...I will not go forward with this marriage,' I said calmly."
"...father said..." (p.17). Since there is no possessive pronoun (my/your/his/her/our/their) in front of "father," this word should be capitalized. Correction: "...Father said..."
"'Rules are meant to be broken.' I yelled." (p.20). Again, if you think about it, it doesn't make sense to have "I yelled" as a sentence by itself. It's a dependent clause, meaning that while it has a topic and an action, it should be included with the main clause. Correction: "'Rules are meant to be broken,' I yelled."
In paragraph 22, "father" should be capitalized, as there's no possessive pronoun in front of it. This is a repetitive mistake, so keep this rule in your head for future writing.
"The walk to my room was short but walking was the only freedom I had, so I enjoyed it." (p.28). You're missing a comma here. Correction: "The walk to my room was short, but walking was the only freedom I had, so I enjoyed it." I also feel like this sentence is a filler sentence. I can tell you're struggling with how to transition the scenes, and this sentence is boring, to be blunt. Rather than stating that she walked to her room, describe Dove's surroundings. Describe her internal turmoil. Do more with this sentence.
"When I opened the door there was a dress on my bed and one of the maids setting up stuff for my hair." (p.29). You're missing another comma here, as these are two different clauses needing to be separated. Correction: "When I opened the door, there was a dress on my bed and one of the maids setting up stuff for my hair."
In paragraph 38, I suggest you write out the number "twenty." Along with that, don't write down what happens simply for the sake of getting it down. Have more fun with it and don't be afraid to describe the ache of Dove's head as the maid tugs on her hair and the pain of the pins holding her hair in place. You want to visually describe this scene for your readers, so it's more enjoyable.
"Granted I have a palace..." (p.40). Another missing comma. Correction: "Granted, I have a palace..."
"'Olivia,' she smiled." (p.44). Since "she smiled" is an action tag, it is not a continuation of the dialogue sentence. That means the start of the action tag should be capitalized (as it's the start of a new sentence), and the dialogue should end in a period to signify the end of the sentence. Correction: "'Olivia.' She smiled."
"'Call me Dove.' I said." (p.47). You have the wrong punctuation at the end of this dialogue, since it's accompanied with a dialogue tag. Correction: "'Call me Dove,' I said." This suggestion also applies to paragraph 49.
"I loked at her..." (p.58). You have a typo here.
"'I'm so sorry Dove.' Olivia cried." (p.64). Again, you have the wrong punctuation at the end of this sentence. You're also missing a comma. Correction: "'I'm so sorry, Dove,' Olivia cried."
"Hey Olivia?" (p.69). You need a comma here.
In paragraph 76, I suggest writing out the full word "okay" rather than "ok."
It looks like you're still struggling with the same grammar problems here as your other stories, so I highly suggest taking the time to focus on improving these first, then come to me after with a polished draft. That way, I can help you, rather than repeating the same things in each review. As always, I enjoyed your simplistic writing, although I would have liked to see more descriptions here. This was a lovely first chapter!
Advertisement
- In Serial301 Chapters
Tales From the Terran Republic
We tried, you know… We really did. We tried so hard to be… better… We actually were better once. No, seriously. We were enlightened, generous, peaceful… Stop laughing! We were! We were peaceful, dammit! No, I’m not “tugging your winglets.” It’s true! Look, if you’re going to be like that, I’ll just push the launch button right now. See ya, don’t wanna be… Oh, you ARE interested after all? Ok. Hey, I just got word that your captain will be ok. We were able to get him into a med pod quick enough… Of course, we tried to save him. Just what sort of people do you think we are?... Now that was harsh… completely accurate, mind you… but harsh. Anyway, like I was saying, we were a prosperous, peaceful people, and war had been nothing but a distant memory for over five hundred years before it happened... Before Yellowstone happened! You don’t mean to tell me that you didn’t know about that… massive supervolcano? Blew the Hell out of our planet? Two years where nothing grew?… Anyway, that’s what started it, the Sol Wars… Oh, you have heard about those, huh? Well, needless to say, all that enlightened, generous, and peaceful didn’t exactly make it through the two years of complete famine and the wars that followed… Maybe it’s more accurate to say the enlightened, generous, and peaceful among us didn’t survive… (laughs)… You’re right. It does explain a lot, doesn’t it? Probably for the best, though. “Enlightened” and “peaceful” aren’t really all that useful out here in the galaxy at large, are they? That reminds me; thanks for the ship. You guys did a great job with this one. Oh, don’t be like that. At least it was us what got you and not one of the really messed groups like the Harlequin or the Black Angels. We’re just going to take your shit. It could be worse… trust me... Well, anyway, we loaded the life pods down with some good food, and you guys can drink alcohol, right? We put in a couple of fifths in there, too. It’s about forty percent ethanol, so be warned. Most species will want to dilute that. We’ll drop your wounded off somewhere safe once they are stable. Your fleet patrols this area fairly regularly, and we’ll drop the distress beacon right before we jump… Well, It’s been fun and no hard feelings, right?… Oh, you want to know some more? Sure. I got time to kill… Let me tell you about this one pirate and her crew. They’re Terran scum, but they are still… Why do we hate the Terrans? Hoo Boy… How much time you got? *** It’s the thirty-second century, and humanity is now part of a galactic civilization comprised of hundreds of worlds. Humanity has been savaged by natural disaster and war and has been fractured into several separate populations, all of which loathe each other (some things never change). This is a gritty drama-driven rambling tale that swings between action, drama, horror, and plenty of very, very dark comedy. Warning: contains adult situations, absolutely horrible language, bathroom humor, implied ultra-violence, actual ultra-violence, drugs, alcohol, pirates, mercs, xeno prostitutes, moral ambiguity, deranged AI's with identity issues, giant commie space slugs, and a poor little frog girl who just wants to sell coffee. Updates twice weekly on Tuesday and Friday. *** Note: This story can get rough. Those warning tags? They aren't for show. I recently received a review and as a result I want to make one thing clear. Portraying something is NOT endorsing it! Many "heavy" topics are touched upon and just because a character says or does something does not imply that the author feels the same way. I selected the "Anti-Hero Lead" and "Villainous Lead" tags for a reason. Rule number one of this story is "no good guys". A good description of the story is, "bad people doing bad things to worse people". There are a few good characters, here and there, but they are the exception to the rule. If you want a hard-hitting, exciting, gritty sci-fi story that doesn't pull any punches, or shies away from "difficult" concepts, welcome! If you are set on a pure and noble knight that runs around and slays conveniently evil monsters and rescues totally innocent princesses... or your sensibilities are easily offended... You're not going to be happy with this one.
8 682 - In Serial10 Chapters
Returning to a New Era
“You first caught my attention when you stole the Giant’s Sovereignty. “I took note of your ability when you slew the King of Monsters. “And I found myself in awe after seeing you—” “Can you spare me the monologue? Just get me home, you tentacle porn bastard.” “…Okay.” When one leaves, one must also return; but what if the world you left was different from when you left? This is the story of a Returner’s Return to a New Era. It was Earth, but it seemed more foreign than the otherworld he returned from. I do not own the art on the cover. Schedule for upload: Wednesday and Sunday [Days still not specified]
8 188 - In Serial15 Chapters
The Adventures of Tommy Johnny: Stuck In the Void
Tommy Johnny is stuck is the Void. That is it. He just twiddles his thumbs as he floats in the void. (something to do while COVID is going around) (Something everybody is experiencing maybe idk) This story is VERY reader interactive the comments make the story interesting like provide basic essentials
8 151 - In Serial7 Chapters
Silver Imperium
The boundaries of one man's mind are tested when he finds himself falling through the immaterium. Join Silver on his crusade across Warhammer 40,000. See him fight a variety of Xeno foes while shoulder to shoulder with the forces of the Imperium.
8 171 - In Serial169 Chapters
Overlord in Cultivation
The doomsday fell upon the earth when a dragon coffin sealed under a snow mountain for ages shifted, and the civilization of gods and devils began. The whole universe turned into a fantastic new world where everyone could rise to the top through cultivation. A lucky young boy seized the opportunity, and started his journey to be an overlord in cultivation. It is a heart-thrilling and good-writhing fantasy novel full of twists and turns!
8 322 - In Serial51 Chapters
The Errant Otherworlder Watanabe
“In this world nothing can be said to be certain, except death, taxes and trucks whom transport men to other worlds.” Meet our titular protagonist Haruto Watanabe, a man who has all the markings of a good protagonist for a generic portal fantasy story. As an overworked office worker, to escape from the grips of crippling capitalist alienation, he had taken up to reading many stories where young men like him were transported to other worlds and enjoyed their lives at a most leisurely pace. Armed with genre-awareness and (what he believes to be) a marketable personality which would make him an easy audience self-insert, he longed for the day the isekai express would take him to his long-awaited adventure to another world. When the fateful day came, where the fair yet harsh mistress that is the fabled truck took Watanabe on one last date to the other side, he was most ready to escape his previous life, ready to embark on an errant so great he’d be most overpowered, his heroics so exceptional and his harem so vast that they would barely fit ten or twenty volumes of an overly long novel made by a desperate author looking for quick cash. Lo and behold however, Watanabe instead found himself in a low fantasy world which lacked severely in the department of any game-like systems, cheat skills or easily charmed damsels in distress. In a setting so antithetical to his established genre savviness or any attempts at power fantasy, how will a man like Watanabe, lacking in strength, wits and courage, manage to survive in a land most foreign to him? This is my first time trying to share to the wider world what I’ve written, and I hope you’ll enjoy reading the errantry of Watanabe as much as I enjoy writing about them. I'll be posting one chapter per week on Sundays, along with extra chapters whenever I get the chance to write more than usual.
8 160

