《Wattpad 101: Your guide to the world of Wattpad》Help! Help! I'm Being Infringed!
Advertisement
The act of simply creating something is enough to claim copyright on it, and other than that, everything else is merely there to facilitate the process. If you select copyright when publishing something on Wattpad (it's default selection when posting a chapter), you are asserting it is your intellectual property, and thus, if someone copies it, you have a right to do something about it.
That said, proving you created this intellectual property (rather than stole it), is the only real important thing when it comes to copyright. If you're posting online, your post has a timestamp, and thus the proof has already been established as long as you can trust Wattpad not to implode. Emailing yourself is another way to establish a timestamp. Before the internet era, some people would mail themselves their own manuscripts in order to ensure it's been timestamped and thus prove their own intellectual property.
So, if copyright is a given, what is the point of a copyright page? The point is simple. It's providing the information behind your copyright. Specifically, you're giving people information on how to contact you should they want to use your intellectual property. A copyright page doesn't give your copyright, it's just a statement establishing that you believe you own copyright and how to contact you should someone want to argue it. If anything, a copyright page doesn't protect you from copyright infringement, it makes it easier to contact (and sue!) you if they believe your work infringes on their copyright!
Previously, I suggested true copyright is obtained by filing with your local government. While I certainly think getting an official ISBN number goes a long way toward legitimizing your work, it isn't necessary for copyright. Copyright is... for all intent and purposes, a right. You have a right to your work. However, filing it with the government makes protecting your right to own it much, much easier.
However, I didn't start this chapter to correct some of my own misconception delivered in my last copyright chapter. Rather, I wanted to answer the next logical question. What do you do if your intellectual property is being infringed?
Everyone has this idea where they'll sue the guilty party and everything will magically fall into place and suddenly they make a million dollars. The truth is rarely so simple. So, here's my advice on what you should do if you do find someone infringing your work.
I've already brought up the idea in this chapter, but you don't own ideas. You own the exact image you drew or the exact words you wrote, but if someone writes a story "like" your story, it quickly turns into a grey area where it's difficult to tell whether copyright was violated. If I wrote a story called Harry Pooter about a magical wizard who went to school with two friends and fought Volzemort at Hagworts... well, you can quickly start to see that I'm starting to infringe on intellectual rights, and the more similarities, the more likely JK Rowlings going to send her army of British lawyers who will sue me politely for all I'm worth. However, if I wrote the story for the sake of satire or parody, that actually can be defended by copyright law.
If law was easy, we wouldn't need to hire professionals to help us understand it. And even with the professionals, there wouldn't need to be judges and juries if the ultimate conclusion was easy and set in stone. So, the most important thing when trying to see if someone infringed your work is by approaching it with an open mind. I know your emotions are probably running high, but you need to consider whether "both our main characters have the same job, have a name that starts with the same letter of the alphabet, and go on the same hero's journey" is a valid case for infringement. This might even involve getting a third party to help (not a friend or family member), asking someone to view your work and theirs and decide impartially whether they think it constitutes theft.
Advertisement
You probably aren't as unique as you think you are, and your ideas have been thought of before. And what if someone saw your work? What if they loved it, and now they are trying to emulate it. Find one author on this site who hasn't tried to emulate their favorite author at some point in their career. Imitation is the first step in learning. So, why grow angry if someone likes your work enough to emulate it? Shouldn't you be flattered?
I could also say there is some grey area if they give you credit. If you're not making money off of something, and so I take that something you did, give you full credit, and continue to not make money off it... well, it's not a great feeling to have your work lifted, but is it really something where you want to call it infringement? If anything, they're getting your work out there and helping spread your name.
That said, there are times where infringement is clearly infringement. Someone lifted your art from deviantart to make their cover without asking permission, or they lifted your exact article and are now toting it as their own. So, what do you do in that situation?
You really need to contact them. Send them a pm and/or post on their wall. You need to make some attempt to reach out to the person. State clearly that you're the creator of that art work, and you'd like them to take it down. Make sure to keep a record of this conversation just in case.
Now, there are two points I need to make here. First, if you don't care that they took your artwork and you just wanted them to ask first, don't bother. There is little point in being a butthead. You aren't the internet's lesson provider, and it's silly to antagonize someone who acted rudely just to fulfill your own sense of pride. Unless they do something you genuinely want them to take down for whatever reason, avoid acting vindictively. Yes, they were rude to not ask. However, you are not the Batman, and you won't be unleashing justice on the wrong-doers of the internet.
The second part along the same vein is that you shouldn't go into this seeking to punish them. Yes, they did a thing. In school, you're taught copyright infringement is a bad bad thing. You read disclaimers with scary capital letters, you hear teachers telling you you'll get disciplined, receive an automatic F, and maybe even kicked out of school should you violate the infringement rules. That makes it seem like these infringement bastards are barely better than Nazi Kitten Punchers.
However, you're not going to be the one to unleash justice on them. You're not the Punisher either. Let's all just agree you're not a superhero. You're not fighting crime. You're just wanting a piece you put online to be in your control. It should go without saying, but you shouldn't chase after people when the work isn't yours either. You can let the intellectual property owner know, but you shouldn't be trying to pull down copyright infringers when the work they're infringing isn't your own.
So, just ask them to bring it down. Be polite. Be nice. I know it might not be easy for you, but if you come at them tongue blazing or with the desire to humiliate, threaten, or demean them... you're probably not going to get the response you want. You can even exacerbate the issue, resulting in them deliberately putting their foot down, stealing more of your work, or acting vindictive themselves. Because there is a fundamental and harsh truth with all this... while you can eventually put a troll down if you work hard enough, you'll have to put more time and money putting that troll down then they ever spent taking your work or responding to you. That's the very nature of a troll. You've already lost.
Advertisement
However, even if the guy who stole your work is a genuine wanker, they aren't actually the person hosting your work online. They aren't the one actually violating your copyright. Unless they own the domain, they aren't directly responsible for the content. So who is?
Well, in the case of stuff uploaded on Wattpad, Wattpad is. Wattpad owns the domain name. They control the servers. They pay the bills. The information on their website is ultimately their responsibility. When you claim copyright on something you put up on Wattpad, you're claiming that you have the intellectual rights to it. So, if that turns out not to be true, you're throwing Wattpad under the bus and violating their account policy.
So, if you see something on Wattpad that shouldn't be, you can contact Wattpad. Wattpad will likely take accusations of copyright infringement seriously. They may ask you for some proof first, and if you can prove the work is yours (hopefully through a timestamp of upload), then you can show you have rights to the property in question.
Wattpad will respond by taking the work down, and possibly, limiting the account. At this point, you are no longer involved. Wattpad was asked to take down the copyright violation it was hosting. It responded by doing so. Congratulations. You are no longer being copyright violated.
Once again, don't meet this with the idea of wanting to "punish" the other person. You're not the Batman. You're not Judge Dredd. Any "punishment" will take place between Wattpad and the owner of the account. The owner violated Wattpad's policy, and Wattpad is liable to do anything up to and including the deletion of the account... but that's not on you.
As far as how long you should wait between contacting Wattpad and contacting the person? I'd say 24-48 hours. State clearly in your PM that you will contact Wattpad if the person themselves doesn't remove it (try to be polite) and then give it 24-48 hours. If they haven't responded or complied, contact Wattpad.
Also note that while I speak of this as Wattpad, this same matter consists for any hosting site. If they post your work on the likes of Wordpress, you could try your luck trying to contact Wordpress. Booksie, Scribophile, DeviantArt whatever, they all should have policies around copyrighted content. And if the person is hosting this on their own website, you can always track down who the domain host is and contact one&one or hostgator or whoever keeps the website afloat.
However, I'd give Wattpad no more than a week to get their crap together. They should respond, and if they haven't, you can send a second email reminder, but in the event that Wattpad doesn't have their crap together and for some reason refuse to remove the copyright violation... that's when things can get taken to the next level.
If you can't afford legal aid, you can work harder to get the hosting sites attention. For example, reaching out to their social media platforms can be harder for them to ignore without eliciting bad press. A comment on their facebook wall or twitter page might get a response. If they are part of the BBB, you can file a BBB complaint, thus forcing their higher ups at corporate to at least look at the case.
However, if all other communication fails, that leaves getting a lawyer. It's going to cost you money. If you're Disney with lawyers literally on your payroll, it's very easy to order cease and desists and make everyone succumb to your copyright strikes. If you're some guy who writes free content on Wattpad, this avenue is almost certainly not worth it.
Even getting the personal information of the person involved will be a difficult process behind the anonymity of the internet. You're also assuming they even live in the same country as you. Trust me, you're not going to convince their government to extradite them to your government so you can do the equivalent of slapping them on the wrist.
I cannot stress enough to you how frivolous this lawsuit would be. Unless you're making a LOT of money off this IP, and they, in turn, are stealing money you could be earning from this IP, it is NOT worth pursuing. A mega-corporation protecting the image of Mickey Mouse can afford to sue a company for making a mouse-like mascot. You... you cannot.
So, unless your book IS making you thousands on the side, or you just happen to be rich and like wasting money, drop all notion of legal recourse. If you get your book published, your million-dollar publisher has the resources to make sure no one infringes on your book. However, as a self-publisher through Wattpad, all you have is the power of asking politely, and when that fails, making a request to Wattpad or whoever else is hosting and hope their desire to be seen as reputable publicly outweighs their capacity to not give a crap.
You have all my sympathies if you are the victim of intellectual property theft, but regrettably, those are the apples. Good Luck and Happy Writing!
Advertisement
- In Serial13 Chapters
Advent: Red Mage
Book 1 and 2 of the Redmage series are being published on Amazon Kindle Unlimited. Due to the exclusivity clause, I have been forced to take down the vast majority of the book. You can read book one here. Book two here.Drew Michalik was working in a top-secret facility in Washington, D.C. when the Advent began. As all electronics in the world simply ceased to work, blue screens filled with information appeared before him. Drew gained access to a mana interface and a limited number of reality-altering crystals called Xatherite. Following the instructions on his vision-impairing screens, he ‘slotted’ his Xatherite and changed his fate: he gained the ability to cast spells. Now alone in the dark, he must battle through the government bunker-turned-dungeon in a desperate bid for survival. Escape is only the beginning; the first of his many problems in the changed world. Drew will be tasked to not only survive… but to guide the rest of humanity safely through the anarchy. Light LitRPG elements, no harem. Updates on Monday.
8 209 - In Serial96 Chapters
No More Respawns
Synopsis: The first time Allen died, he was forced back into a living hell where death is temporary, and power is all that matters. With evil and depravity as the rule, tragedy becomes comedy and life becomes an act. Only a deal with a shady god can get him back to his old life, but what happens if there’s nothing left to save? Maybe hell isn’t so bad if you have infinite lives… until you don’t. Needless to say, it’s all fun and games until there’s no more respawns. Foreword: This story is meant primarily as an action adventure and secondarily as a dark and nihilistic comedy. It may not be readily apparent in the beginning, but that's what I have planned (I feel the need to emphasize the dark; don’t rage at me if it gets too ‘traumatizing’ or something). I’m going to take my time with this, so it won’t immediately inundate you with doom and gloom. This is also a comedy, remember? On that note, if for some cursed reason you just can't handle either the references or the jokes, I am willing to battle in the comments. Anyway, I still put a significant amount of effort into the system, so I hope you enjoy that part. It is a little bulky, I'll admit to that, but I wanted to try something new and its more fun when there's more depth to it. Regardless, I still have a lot of fun doing math in the middle of writing a fictional story (/s). I also want to see if I can keep from messing up the pacing. Many times, I end up going too fast because I'm afraid of the story getting boring, which tends to ironically have the opposite effect. I'm still learning I suppose; we'll see how things go. Lastly, please leave reviews and comments, they really mean a lot to me and (usually) help me improve considerably. I'll be asking for feedback in the polls and I do still check the old ones from time to time. Notes: The story takes a bit of time to develop; give it time if you're here for drama, grimdark, or antihero. The system is all blue boxes and I'm not half-assing the numbers. Chapters will be between 1k and 2k words usually. I always use the oxford coma, fight me. Might drop if rating falls below 4 stars, idk. It depends on how my life is going. Cover drawn by yours truly in MS paint. (I have skill, I know)
8 183 - In Serial32 Chapters
300 Moons Till Disconnect (Gamelit)
Luck is a speedrunner who’s been transported into the world of Briarwood Rebirth, an MMORPG he’s been playing for 17 years. Yet things are not as they seem. The world feels like it's missing pieces, and NPCs do not behave like they should. There are 30 others like him who've been dubbed Chosen Ones, and they're just as clueless as he is. And what is the 300 day countdown to this so called "Disconnect"? Is this a dream? Or something else? (Rewrite of Bad Luck) (Updates every Monday and Friday)
8 524 - In Serial24 Chapters
My Town's Been Infiltrated By Monsters
"Another great day!" Kristoffer stretched under the rising sun and breathed in the breeze of the sea in front of him. But at his back was a town where shadows unveiled screams of horror, creepy mumbles, a strange marketplace, a syndicate that's feared even by the King, and a monster secretly acting as mayor. Follow Kristoffer and his neighbors as they discovered what it truly meant to be a resident of the peculiar town of Arkbay.
8 207 - In Serial11 Chapters
Tamer Untamed
What will you do if your world faced an unparalleled threat? One that'll just keep coming back. No matter how hard you try to get rid of it? Be prepared for the story of Bishop Riley, a modern day teenager who faces such a threat. His whole life turns upside down and inside out when a mysterious brochure appears in his bathroom. Together with the beasts he tames, this unlucky teen will stop the unstoppable force. That is if his terrible luck doesn't kill him first or the beasts don't eat him or anything else that could go wrong......
8 186 - In Serial38 Chapters
Where Emus Dare
Emperor Marcus II is dead and the Empire is now ruled by the High Council, a fractious alliance of noble Lords and upstart Guildmasters, held together though sheer force of will by the common born Lord George, the Emperor's grieving lover. It is not an alliance anyone expects to last long. To save the Empire from another tiresome civil war, Sir Brand, the Duke of Orston, Dragon Slayer, all round hero and terrible poet, travels to the far away city of Sealmu Alu in an attempt to find his father, the infamous Butcher of Bergraz and persuade him to return home from his self imposed exile and take the throne. As the Empire lurches from crisis to crisis like a drunk on a ice covered road, Lady Anna, aristocratic heir to one of the noblest houses in the Empire and her companion, the eccentric Earth born Lady Kate acquire evidence that suggest the young Emperor's death may not have been the tragic accident it appeared to be. Meanwhile the two people many regard as responsible for the whole recent crisis have disappeared without trace. The beautiful Druid Healer Natalie, the only person who can open the ancient alien Gateways to Earth and her Earth born lover, Xavier are on a quest to destroy the evil Iron Brotherhood, their quest taking them to strange places of legend, Flor Ida, Amarillo and beyond. And if all this wasn't enough, the Dragons are not only back, they've taken over the internet and now seem to regard themselves as the dominant species of the planet.
8 171

