《Wattpad 101: Your guide to the world of Wattpad》Accepting Criticism: Take 2
Advertisement
I have already written a chapter on accepting criticism, but one thing I noticed I failed to do in that chapter was actually explain how someone can accept criticism. In fact, most of the chapter was dedicated to providing a story that could help authors identify when they aren't accepting criticism. The final verdict seemed to be that in the face of criticism, just accept it (Plus, there was a discussion about how accepting criticism isn't the same as using criticism).
However, that's considerably easier said than done, because criticism is hard. It digs deep into your psychy, makes you feel worse, and doesn't seem to let go. It's nice just to say that you need to have more self-confidence, but self-confidence doesn't grow on trees, so it's kind of silly to say this. You don't have self-confidence. If you did, then you wouldn't need to be worrying about accepting criticism. You'd already be unabashedly putting your work out there, naked, with a sombrero on your head. No? Just me? Okay then.
My naked sombrero needs aside, accepting criticism requires putting aside your pride, swallowing your self-doubts, and working towards improving your work. To achieve this goal, and in typical fashion with my other chapters, here is another list on five techniques you can use to receive and handle the criticism thrown at you.
This is my first and biggest piece of advice. I originally had thought to base an entire chapter on this subject alone, but took a step back and decided to try to offer a little more. Most critiques you deal with don't know who you are. This is a fact of life. They don't know your personality. So, when they provide criticism, that criticism is focused on the thing they know. The only thing they know is the work you put out. Ergo, the only thing they are criticizing is the work you put out.
This should go without saying that when someone puts a comment on your work, that they are talking only about your work. But let's say they do make an insult aimed at you. They likely don't know you. They are responding to your material with a personal attack, but ultimately, it's the material they have a problem with. So even then, they are criticizing the work, not you. This does not mean I'm suggesting it's okay to attack people personally, but when you are attacked on a personal level, well... don't take it personally.
I think this is a lesson that even accomplished actors, politicians, and directors need to understand. Even famous names like Steven Spielberg is a person who 99.9% of the ones consuming his work do not know him on any personal level. I don't know what he's like. I don't know his kids. I don't even know how he is as a director. All I know is the end product that I consumed.
Now, people will attack Spielberg when he makes a bad movie. But how quickly does the audience change its tune when he makes a good movie? A better example perhaps would be M. Night Shyamalan. He created the Sixth Sense, and it lead people to having very high expectations for him as a director. He made an okay film with Unbreakable, and then his films slowly went to crap.
People were enraged, how could this "great" director make all these not great films. People started to notice his trends. His angle uses. His tendency to always have a twist. He was attacked relentlessly. So relentlessly he even created a film where his would-be film critics act pompously and are the only character to die in the end. But, now he's making good films again. The last few on his list, The Visit... Split... they've been considered decent movies.
Advertisement
And none of that speaks to who M. Night Shyamalan is as a person. He might be a great father. Is he even a father? He might be a fun director. A funny guy. None of this is known. The only thing we know about him is the content he's created. Thus, when someone criticizes him, the only thing they are criticizing is a small aspect of his personality.
Think of the time you spend actually writing. An hour a day? Two hours? How long did that chapter take to write. Ten hours? Twenty? How much of your life was spent making it? The point I'm trying to make is that any given work you put on display only took a relatively very small portion of your life to produce. Even a book only took a few months to a year to write, which is insignificant over the entirety of your lifetime.
Point being, don't let your criticism rule your life. The criticism is part of such a small aspect of your life. In the end, that criticism need only be applied to your writing skill. Perhaps you can feel disappointed when your writing skill isn't what you expected, but this kind of thing changes from writing to writing. The writer of the Sixth Sense then went on to write *shivers* The Last Airbender. Even a GOOD writer is bound to write crap now and then. That doesn't make him stop being a good writer, it just means that some things he wrote worked, and some things didn't.
To you, this means that you need to understand that your work isn't you. You are a person, well rounded and everything. Your writing is something you spend a small portion of your time creating. Sometimes it works. Sometimes it doesn't work. Listen to the criticism of that thing, but that thing doesn't reflect you. It doesn't even necessarily reflect your skill. We all have good days and bad days. We all have stories that worked, and stories that sort of just flopped around like fish struggling for breath, desperately waiting for someone to smash it with a hammer to put it out of its misery. Accept that, and you'll find that the criticism goes down a little smoother.
However, even if you can make that distinction, criticism is still criticism, and pride will come in the way when you see your work being slammed by someone. Just because the total work doesn't equal more than a fraction of your life, that doesn't mean you didn't work hard and really try, so criticism can still sting.
That's why you need to take criticism in small bites. In the past, I'd sometimes ask five-six critics in a row to criticize my work. You'd always get a few fluffer nutters who had nothing helpful to say, but then you'd get the guys who would add criticisms. And suddenly, I didn't feel like writing as much because people only want to whine and complain about it.
Sometimes, they'd just post 10-20 comments, picking apart the writing one line at a time (because Wattpad unfortunately (fortunately?) lets you comment on each line. Other times they'd create a bullet point list, snapping at any and every little thing. Half the things don't even make sense, are flat out wrong, or are easily answered if the person just read one more chapter.
But none of that matters, because it feels less like criticism, and more like flaying yourself alive. Each criticism feels like another lash. Maybe the first 2-3 are fine, but the more you get, the sorer it is. Soon, what felt completely tolerable initially becomes unbearable. Every additional comment amplifies the power of all the previous comments. Now you're ready to start crying.
Advertisement
I get it. I get that feeling. I've put myself in that situation sometimes too. Yes, even a 30-year-old man can feel like crying after hearing people tear at his work chapter after chapter.
And so... limit yourself. Don't take all the criticism at once. If you feel like you can't fight the temptation to know what people say, then only ask for one chapter at a time. And if you have someone who is determined to flay you through ever chapter because they're just that helpful (Thanks guy... *whimpers*), do whatever you have to in order to tolerate it.
Read only one chapter a day. Take a break and spend a few days building yourself up. Read it with a friend and have the friend scoff at the critiquer and tell you how stupid he is. Whatever it takes. The point is that you should take your criticism in the amount you can handle. There is no obligation to take it all at once. There is no obligation to take it when you're feeling low. Don't do that to yourself. Take it on your time.
The best thing about the internet and taking criticism? You have the power. Use that power. This criticism is for you, it's for your use, and your benefit, so at the end of the day, when, how, and why you choose to accept it is under your control. Feel that control. Let it flow through you. Let it be apart of you. Feel the power of the force, Luke... *cough* I mean... take charge of your criticism. You're the boss.
I suppose there can be some contention here. Some people may feel criticism comes harsher from the people you know rather than the people you don't know. I think those rules apply more to the very close relatives. You know, the people you trust the most. However, for online friends, I think you can probably handle some criticism from them, even if you decide after they criticize you don't want to be friends with them anymore.
Although I'm not suggesting you make a bunch of friends, let them criticize you, then dump them... I'm just talking about getting to know your critics on a basic level. Share some back and forth. Read their work so you know where they are coming from. Find out, at a minimum, their demographical orientation (age, sex, country of origin) so that you can understand the criticism.
This is something I think everyone fails at when it comes to criticism. People are different, and a female Muslim from India might critique a work differently from a male Christian from France. It may not always be important, but knowing where your critic is coming from can go a long way to knowing why they critiqued in the way that they do.
If you find out your critic is big into romance stories, then you can probably understand why they keep obsessing over the little bit of romance your story has. If they're a scientist, maybe you can get why they get angry every time you get the science wrong. These sort of things matter.
And even putting all of that aside, simply getting to know someone and be able to talk with them in a friendly way can quickly teach you they aren't out to get you. A faceless critic in the crowd, some unknown, judgmental, shadowy figure can feel a lot more ominous when providing you negative criticism than someone who is friendly with you. Plus, when someone is willing to chat with you outside of the book, you can really grasp that the criticism ISN'T aimed at you, it's aimed at your work.
Now, I'm not saying you need to become chummy with every tom, dick, and penis who throw you a comment, but a few of the people whom you can get invested in whom comment and tell you about how they found your book might be worth becoming people you share and continue critiques with. It's all part of being in a community, and having the support of like-minded friends, rather than formless criticism.
So, you've finally settled down on a 2000-character comment and you start reading everything. It seems like your commenter spent 5 paragraphs telling you how crappy your writing is, and maybe a sentence telling you anything you did right. But did they really?
As the kind of critic who tends to do this, I'll simply spell it out. When I find things wrong with a writing, I'll point out when they are wrong, what was wrong, how I think they might be fix, etc... etc... When I find something done right, I simply say "I think this was done well." This has lead to authors in the past being convinced that all I did was criticize their work.
The worst of the bunch won't see me having said anything positive at all. They focus on the negative criticism, to the point that even though there is positive criticism, they don't see it.
This is why you need to do the hardest thing of all. You need to rewrite the point of their criticism. What are they actually telling you is wrong with your work. This includes the positive things along with the negatives things. Just because 5 of 6 paragraphs were dedicated to explaining all the things that bothers them, doesn't mean that you received 5 criticisms and only 1 positive.
It's pretty easy to load a lot of positive criticism into one or two sentences.
"I thought your story started out well. I enjoyed these characters. The plot could be fun at times."
That's three positives in three sentences. However, then I go on.
"But, I found the character of Brony the Pony Boner to be a little in your face. Like, he was such an unlikable character that I didn't even want to read about him. I mean seriously, all he did the entire time was bone ponies. It was pretty unlikable. Like that point when the protagonist was tied to the wall, and then he pulled out his 'toys'. Yeah, I didn't like that scene at all. I would totally rewrite his character. Like, maybe instead of Ponies, he could screw... I don't know, pandas."
That paragraph only held one criticism. But I focused on it a lot. So, it hits you with a greater emotional blow. Even though, when listed out, I said three positive things and one negative thing, if you didn't list it out, you would have convinced yourself that I spent the entire comment raging on your story.
This kind of thing can also show a repeat of criticisms. Perhaps a commenter criticized you messing up they're, their, and there... then later they criticize you using the word irregardless, then later they criticize you using effect instead of affect. Has he given you three different criticisms? Not really... he's complaining about your grammar, specifically your tendency to write the incorrect form of words, but that really can be summed up as one criticism.
And people like me tend to go on tirades. If I find something that annoys me, I could dedicate 2-3 paragraphs whining about it and giving it examples. However, at the end, it's only a single criticism. It's only one thing I'm saying you did wrong. It might be something that permeates the chapter, it might be something that is my pet peeve, but it's still a single thing that can potentially be fixed.
I think it's always good advice to write what the criticism actually is. Categorize it. And not just the criticism from one person, but the criticism from all of your critiques. Combine them. You may find every critique is really having the same criticism, even if they word it in different ways, and obsess about different parts of the story, it could all be the root cause. Maybe this scene set this guy off and that scene set that guy off, but if both have a problem with the antagonist... you can see the problem with the story was really just a poor written antagonist... who bones ponies.
Pride. It's a heck of thing. Just today, I went out to eat and the guy handling my bill refused to take a coupon for arbitrary reasons that wouldn't have bothered someone else. I was pissed, so I snapped at him. Cussed a few times in front of my kids just to make me look like the worst parent. About twenty minutes later, after I had eaten, I went back up to the poor guy and apologized.
Don't get me wrong, I still think I am in the right. I'm still a little pissed he wouldn't take my coupon. I was pissed all the way up to the point I apologized, but I did apologize, because I don't think anyone should be making anyone else's day just a little bit crappier when they have the good grace not to. I didn't control my emotions when my plans changed, but I could always go back when I cooled down a bit and show proper etiquette.
I wrote an entire chapter on Wattpad etiquette, and I made sure to mention that it's never a good idea to argue with your commenters. Now... I've defended my work, and I think every writer has a right to defend their work. The critic can learn just as much from the experience as the writer in these sorts of situations. So, responding, answering questions, and explaining your actions is NOT arguing, no matter how much some certain critiquers may think it is... I'm looking at you, Chad.
But arseholes like Chad aside, you typically don't want to make it a habit of getting into arguments with your critics. At no point should you sent them a post telling them you're quitting now, or how decimated their posts made you feel. Don't try to fight them, don't try to guilt them.
If emotions run high, sit on it for a couple of days, maybe even a week. They can wait. You don't have to respond to your criticism the day you read it. Waiting seven days to respond is way better than leaving heartfelt, passive aggressive angry comments about how you're totally trying and they were totally mean and unfair.
But in the end, if you don't need them to clarify their criticism, and you don't feel the need to clarify your work towards their criticism, then the only thing you should leave them is a polite thank you.
Mind you, I'm suggesting you should leave them something. Nothing isn't a good option. It's better than passive aggressive, but it's still kind of jerkish to leave them hanging. I've had people who I've left criticism for never make a single response to that criticism, and at the very least I considered it mildly annoying.
But if you honestly don't like their criticism, even if you're angry at it, swallow your own pride, suck it up, and tell them you appreciate their criticism, and you'll take a look at it. That's it.
This isn't just the polite thing to do, this is the adult thing to do. Teenagers, take extra note. You want to be seen as adult or adult-like... this is one of those steps. When you can put aside your grievances and shake the hand of someone you hate and be nice, just because it's the thing you need to do to move forward, that's a true sign of growing up. Why do you think all the competitions usually end in exchanging "good game" with your opponents. It's preparing you for this kind of thing. This ability to swallow your pride.
And after you do all that? After you pm them thanking them for their helpful critique? After you've read the critique, and jotted down both the positive and negative things the critique suggests you can improve on? After this person has torn you down, ravaged you soul, and obliterated your self-esteem?
Delete that crap.
Delete the comments/pm... and move on. Don't dwell on it. Criticism is, and always should be, a fleeting thing. What you do after you've accepted it? Well, that's up to you. I suggest removing your pants and reaching for your sombrero.
Advertisement
- In Serial264 Chapters
Delve
Summary – Level 1: Delve is an isekai litrpg that follows an average guy who just happened to wake up in a forest one day. He wasn’t summoned to defeat the demon lord or to save the world or anything like that, at least as far as he can tell. The only creature there to greet him was a regular old squirrel. Soon enough, he meets other people, only to discover that he can’t speak the language, and that not everybody immediately trusts random pajama-wearing strangers they met in the middle of the wilderness. Things generally go downhill from there, at least until the blue boxes start appearing. Delve is a story about finding your way in a new, strange, and dangerous world. It’s about avoiding death, figuring out what the heck is going on, and trying to make some friends along the way. It’s not about getting home, so much as finding a new one. Did I mention that there will be math? Summary – Level 2: Okay, but what are you in for, really? Well, this story is supposed to be realistic, or at least, as realistic as a fantasy litrpg can be. The main character doesn’t instantly become an all-powerful god and murder-hobo his way across the universe. Delve is, at its heart, a progression fantasy, but that progression is meant to feel earned. The numbers in this story actually mean something. Everything is calculated, and if you find a rounding error, I expect you to tell me about it. That said, if math isn’t your cup of tea, there is plenty more that the story has to offer. Characters are meant to feel real, and progression isn’t only about personal power; it’s also about allies, connections, and above all, knowledge. Figuring out how the system works is a significant theme. ... What, you want more details? Okay, fine, but this is going to get a bit spoiler-y. Are you sure? Yes! Really sure? I mean, this summary is practically half as long as the first chap– Now! Okay, okay! The main character becomes a magic user, but he takes a route that is not very popular in adventurer culture, namely that of a support. There is a full magic system with various spells, skills, and abilities, but our MC decides that aura magic is the way to go, and that the only stat worth investing in is mana regeneration. Most people at the Adventurer’s Guild think that this makes him a bit of a dumbass, but he’s playing the long game. We’ll see how that works out for him, won’t we? Because of his build, the MC levels up fast, at least compared to normal people. There are no cheats, though, and he is limited in other ways. There are some clear and pretty obvious downsides to his build. That’s what makes it fun, no? Morals? Our MC has them. Again, we’ll see how that works out for him. Realism, remember? Would you be okay with killing someone and looting their body? I sure hope not. POV? The focus is on the main character, but there will be occasional varying perspectives from people around him, or involved in the events related to the main plot. It isn’t going to jump all over the place. Tech is standard medieval stasis. No smartphones, but the MC does have a technical background. Computers and their programming might be involved. There might even be a bit of uplifting down the road, who knows? Anyway, it isn’t the focus. He isn’t going to invent the gun in chapter 1 and change the face of warfare. Romance is not a major focus. Friendships are more the name of the game, though there will be some characters in romantic relationships. There is exploration, though not as much of the geographical nature as you might expect. It is more about exploration of the system and the culture. The pace is slow and detailed, sometimes verging on slice-of-life. The action is meant to be realistic and grounded in the numbers, and it is intended to have meaning beyond simply punching things until they stop moving. The general tone of the story is grey, and some parts can get quite dark. People die. Sometimes, people with names, but not anywhere near GoT level. There is plenty of light, too, though, to balance the darkness. The world is dangerous, but overcoming that danger is why we’re all here, isn’t it? Anyway, if you’ve made it this far through the summary, you clearly like words. I hope you enjoy the story! Cover by Miha Brumec Summary Updated: 2020-06-14
8 822 - In Serial228 Chapters
The Outer Sphere
Garth Daniels is down on his luck, running from his life in a quiet little town in the middle of America when our universe is co-opted into a war between an unstoppable race of reality-hopping monsters that feeds on the flesh of living creatures, and a conglomeration of thousands of realities, nested inside each other like a matroska doll. We're the new layer. These monsters, the Kipling, can only be defeated in a reality with very specific physics, otherwise they are unstoppable, and so Earth's universe has been assimilated to give us a fighting chance. Garth must set aside everything that he knows, and think fast to adapt to the new laws of nature if he wants to survive. Cover by Asera, a cool, helpful dude, who doesn't get enough props. Go check him out!
8 142 - In Serial13 Chapters
The New World Beyond The Gate
Ares is a planet in the leviathan solar system and there exist 3 main continents which are conquered by the respective nations: The Imperial Republic in the northThe Confederation of Amazonia in the eastThe United Federation of Wilhelmshaven in the west Conflict looms in the background between the three respective nations and the Imperial Republic which has its natural resources running dry decided to focus its remaining resources on technological breakthroughs. Then at last they had broken through they were able to open up a gate towards a new world! Sir Edward is tasked to lead the expeditionary force and establish connections through the other side of the gate whether it be through war or diplomacy, he must be able to procure enough resources to fill up the drying banks of resources of their nation to be able to face the coming conflicts upon them. Read Now! To find out the fate of the Republic and the fate of the expeditionary force in the new world! ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- I will also be posting this novel at Webnovel please also follow me there too, thank youuu https://dynamic.webnovel.com/book/19721734305042605?utm_source=writerShare&utm_campaign=4316346076 Release rate will be on Tuesday and Thursday. Ps: Background Picture is not mine credits to its owner, just found it on a free site. The edit is mine
8 147 - In Serial6 Chapters
Contact First
2039 - Earth A narrow beam energy signal appeared aimed squarely at earth from the TRAPPIST system. The communication consisted of a layered set of repeating data over several thousand wavelengths. Over the next few months scientists discovered that the lower wavelengths carried an encoded numerical language which could then be used to interpret the more complicated messages carried on the higher wavelengths. After half a year of painstaking work the signal was fully decoded. It described a small satellite launched along a precise trajectory towards the fourth planet of our solar system. Included was a package of advanced research that humanity would need to have ready in order to receive the satellite and decelerate it safely. The alien data provided the kick that humanity needed to turn from petty squabbling and unite to explore the final frontier. Major government and corporate leaders worked together to create the framework for the United Federation of Sol. UFS spaceports went from scaffolding to daily launches in every major city around the globe. Ships floated like dandelion seeds, spreading on solar wind to grow into colonies. 2397 - Mars orbit, Egeria Station The command center was a hive of activity as checks were conducted and systems initialized. Scientists flitted by like mayflies as communicators beeped and holoscreens spat out green tinted readouts. Nervous energy was thick in the air as everyone anticipated the culmination of over three hundred years of work. Massive fusion reactors under the planet's surface thrummed with barely restrained power as energy fed into a gleaming metallic maze criss crossing the planet. Metal fingers reached up, overshadowing the mighty olympus mons and trying to grab the stars. All over the solar system, people quickly turned to look as gigantic energy lances shot from the dusty fourth planet. Two years later. The same people that clapped loudly at the successful activation of project Hermes now wait with baited breath. A silver capsule trailing bright photonic sails is captured by a net of grav beams and guided with care bordering on reverence into the station. Holoscreens across the headquarters project an image of the sleek craft settling in the bay. Data connections are established and the holoscreens blink to white. Slowly an image forms on the screen. Across the headquarters people stare in wonder as a wholly alien face stares back. "Contact established. Welcome to the universe."
8 155 - In Serial29 Chapters
Adventures in Magic
Kleo's a college freshman studying literature and living a simple life until his 18th birthday comes around and shakes things up a bit. Now, Kleo's just confused and has so many questions. His mother was a witch and so is he?? Why didn't he know this until now?? How did the girl who works in his mother's shop know he was witch before him?? How in heck is he supposed to tell his best friend any of this?? And since when can his cat talk??
8 189 - In Serial46 Chapters
Marauding Gods
To protect themselves from the threat known as "monsters" the only way humanity has found to survive was to construct a massive magical barrier that spans an entire continent: the human continent. On the Southeast part of the Human Continent, there is a place, remote to any man's dwelling called Rosetta Manor, where lived a young boy named Ronandt, a young nobleman who, despite his noble origins, has never met his parents. Follow the little Ronandt in a world of Gods and Dragons, where even as a noble, a human, is already a quite atypical one. Update rate: 1chapter/Day (Except Sunday) Disclaimer: This novel is clearly tagged gore, and this within reason, so please keep that in mind while reading. Though the early chapter suggest that this novel is slice of life one, especially in the first 40 chapters, it must be clarified that this novel is first and foremost a progression fantasy tagged gore and grimdark. Feel free to like it or hate it.
8 376

