《Your Book Sucks and Here's Why》My Dad's Jokes Are Better Than Your Arguments
Advertisement
The arguments/dialogue in your books are fucking dumb.
Your characters are saying a lot of words, and they sound angry, but none of it means anything. I've closed out of many Wattpad books without resonating with the characters because their arguments are silly and childish, and they're all over the same dumb stuff.
In the authors' defenses, getting characters to seem really angry over something that is important is hard. I think we can all agree that there is a significant difference between petty bickering and full-blown, explosive arguments. Who cares if Jane Doe doesn't like that John Smith bites his nails? No one, so don't try to turn it into drama.
Instead, write actual arguments. Why do yours suck? I'll tell you.
1. . As I've already mentioned, don't let them bicker. Stage full-fledged wars. If blood isn't drawn, I think I can speak for everyone when I say we won't be satiated. Not real blood, just metaphorical blood, as in wounding the character verbally. Anyways. Ask yourself, "Why is my character mad? Is this worth exploding over?" If not, raise the stakes. Maybe John Smith and Jane Doe are both anti-gun activists, until their house gets broken into.
Soon after, John recants his belief, buys a gun, and trains actively at shooting ranges, vowing to protect himself and Jane. Of course, Jane is appalled. This goes against everything she believes! Where is the John she fell in love with? And there you go; a real argument is already brewing.
2. Wait, but shouldn't there be a winner? Shouldn't one be right and the other be wrong? Yeah, if you want a shitty argument. In reality, generally speaking, most people are always a little bit right and a little bit wrong, even though they always think they're 100% right. So play around with this. Maybe John asserts that he wants it for safety, which is partially true, but he also wants to be able to boast about how manly he is and show off his new skill.
Advertisement
And maybe Jane is genuinely upset that John threw his beliefs out the window so quickly, and she truly does believe in putting an end to gun violence, but deep down, she's also just mad that he went out on a limb and bought the gun without even consulting with her first. Both sides of each of their arguments contain vices and virtues, and both sides with defend their positions and justify their anger, even when maybe they should be apologizing.
Don't let one character have a great argument and justification for their actions, and then portray the other floundering to come up with a witty response. Don't let us know who will "win" so easily.
3. If your leading lady is hot-headed and volatile when it comes to speaking her mind, don't portray her giving someone the cold shoulder and exuding glacial indifference. Keep your character's core personality in mind, and make sure their body language and overall tone in the argument are represented accurately.
4. Yes, following a plot structure is the best way to write an argument. It should go: inciting incident, rising action, climax, and falling action. The inciting incident is the unspoken discourse and building emotions that lead to the explosion, like Jane finding out that John bought a gun without consulting with her or asking how she'd feel about it first. The rising action is actually engaging in the argument, like Jane confronting John about the issue.
The climax is (obviously) the very peak of the intensity, where Jane and John are at each other's throats. Maybe what was supposed to be a nice, relaxing dinner at home has turned into a war zone, and Jane bites out, "You can't just do whatever you want!" And John slams his wine glass down onto the table so ferociously, it cracks, spitting back, "Looks like I just did." Then, the audience is left wondering what will happen. Will he storm out? Will she? The falling action is the aftermath, like the next day when Jane and John regard each other as though they're strangers, each feeling guilty but both too proud to admit it.
Advertisement
5. Don't have Jane meet John in chapter two and have them fighting like a married couple in chapter five. The reader won't care who wins or loses because they aren't invested in who they are yet. Build up the tension as you build up the relationship, until they will inevitably explode at each other and it's only a question of when.
6. . Please don't use too much dialogue. By this I mean:
"I hate you, John," Jane says. "You're immature and stupid."
"Not as stupid as this argument!" He responds, lip curling.
"Yes, you are!"
"Quit yelling at me! You're always yelling, and yelling, and getting on my nerves!" He yells.
"No!"
"Yes!"
"Make me!"
Obviously, this is exaggerated a bit, but you might be surprised how many arguments are comprised of this sort of content. And by content I mean lack thereof. Where's the body language, other than the one referencing to his lip curling? What are their bodies saying that their lips refuse to? In an argument, employ all five senses. The silence was deafening, and his ears rang with the magnitude of all of the unspoken words. He clenched his teeth so tightly together, he tased the metallic flavor of blood. The air reeked of the pungent odor of promises to love one another unconditionally rotting in the corner of the room.
Do you know what's worse than your dialogue?
You're writing too much and not enough.
Keep reading if you want to know what that means.
Advertisement
- In Serial113 Chapters
Forbidden Destiny
Two troubled teens, raised as siblings, try fighting their attraction to one another, while struggling to uncover the truly unexplainable and unimaginable reasons why their entire lives were a lie. Sky and Star were raised as brother and sister. As they got older they began to realize that there was much about them that was completely unexplainable and deliberately being hidden from them. Struggling with the feelings they were raised to believe they shouldn't have for one another, and all the pain that causes them, the two search desperately to uncover the truth about who... or what they really are. (This book is completed, so the plan was to post 1 chapter each day until the end) *This story does deal with difficult issues such as suicide, abuse and rape. Though I try to do so in the most realistic, sensitive and sympathetic way possible. So be advised that these themes are included in the book. And I hope you'll give it a chance nonetheless.* *Yet another disclaimer: Yes, there are teenagers involved in consensual sexual relationships with other teenagers in this book. Which is also a more than common occurence in hundreds of other books, shows and films, (not to mention a common occurence in real life, even though this is a fantasy story with characters who may or may not even be fully human), so if you have a problem with troubled teens behaving like troubled teens, then you probably shouldn't read this book.*
8 108 - In Serial20 Chapters
War of Redemption
The story of several elves journey through blinding rage and darkness. One trained to kill will hold many lives in her hands as her decision sets the end of a long struggle into motion. Participant in the Royal Road Writathon challenge With cover art provided by Jack0fheart as found in https://www.royalroad.com/profile/178717
8 129 - In Serial76 Chapters
Wonderland: Origin Arc [Script]
On a late night on the 15th of June 2018 in the middle of England, a teenage girl died in a hit-and-run. A few months later, her friends have started college. They plan to get over the loss and do something in her memory, but things end up going a bit haywire when guns are pointed at them and they are soon struck by lightning. They try to go home to forget the day but between the discovery of superpowers and the arrival of a serial killer, it appears to be a lot harder than it sounds... This is in a script format. If you read, please enjoy. All I ask.
8 177 - In Serial13 Chapters
Pact Chronicle: A Magician's Story
In the city of Magia, ordinary high school student Saitou Kazuma goes about his daily routine. That all changes when he suddenly encounters an amnesiac magician named Alice. He offers to help her, but unbeknownst to him, their interaction would be the catalyst that draws supernatural forces towards them. In order to battle against them, the two of them are left with no other choice but to form a contract, allowing Kazuma to attain magic known as “Change”. With this, he is able to harness the power of other magicians and fight to protect Alice while they exploit the sinister plots placed by forces outside of the city.This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents either are products of the author’s imagination or are used fictitiously. Any resemblance to actual events or locales or persons, living or dead, is entirely coincidental.(NOTE: The work is currently undergoing a remake. Thank you for understanding. 2/13)
8 234 - In Serial28 Chapters
Two siblings, one friend and a baby
Harrison, Tom and y/n are best friends. Harrison and y/n are also siblings. Do you think their friendship can last when y/n falls pregnant? Title based off the film Three men and a baby
8 80 - In Serial37 Chapters
Together we howl
A year after the battle of Hogwarts, things change drastically for Hermione Granger. Experiencing a terrible breakup, she changes from the rule following bookworm to a spontaneous and carefree woman. However, she feels the only way for her to be completely happy, is if she leaves Britain. Luckily for her, she has a best friend who's more than willing to follow. How will things change when Hermione Granger and Ginny Weasley move to Washington, living on the border of Forks and La Push?
8 113

