《Writing POC 101》Indian Characters - @wheresmybroomstick
Advertisement
I discovered the whole aspect of "online friendship" when I was in 4th grade. I remember making an account on i-dressup.com where basically one designs their own guest room and wardrobe and engages in conversations with their guests - in short a cool place to meet people from all over the world. I'd spend half of my time there talking to strangers, being the loser that I am. I also made a blog section in my guestroom where I'd talk about random stuff. What bothered me the most is that so many of the guests that'd read my blog would send me this question: "How do you know English so well being an Indian?" It was a backhanded compliment. I honestly didn't know how to respond to that question and sadly, I'd receive so many variations of those. I grew up discovering more websites like Youtube, 4chan, Omegle, and the like and realised that "not knowing english" was not the only stereotype Indians were associated with. I very vividly remember stumbling across a thread where everyone was stating their opinions on Indians and almost all of them were negative, for some reason - Indians are ugly looking, Indians smell, Indians are geeks, Indians are perverted, Indians are poor, Indians are close-minded and so on. I was so upset going through the responses, it made me feel ashamed of being Indian. I would then never disclose my nationality on the internet because I've had instances wherein people would just ignore or delete me once I told them I was from India. I, after a few years, realised how stupid I was. I stopped hiding my location and started distancing myself from people who would have a problem with me being Indian. I started taking about all the stereotypes that I came across. I'd really like to discuss a few of them here as I know that stereotypes won't go away soon - we, as humans, tend to prefer grouping everything to avoid unavoidable entropy and confusion. But we can certainly strive to stop stereotypes in literature by spreading awareness; so as to avoid polluting the knowledge of the readers. Because books are where we learn most of the things from, right?
Advertisement
So let's begin with debunking a few myths. For starters: Nope, I don't have curry for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Nope, I don't drink cow piss. Nope, I don't go to school riding an elephant. Nope, I don't wear a sari. Nope, I don't have a pet snake. Sorry to crush all your dreams.
Whenever I come across an Indian character in a book, I always notice the following things:
No, we don't. India is a big, diverse country. There's a different cuisine type in every state. Thumb Rule: Every 5000km: new cuisine, new dialect. Where there's naan, rotis, and paneer in one state, there is idli, dosa, and sambhar in another. Note, however, they're not mutually exclusive.
Again, every state and locality has a different accent. It all depends on the language spoken there.
In India, more than 415 languages have been documented (Source: SIL Ethnologue). Naturally, the accent would differ, depending on the language spoken there. It's kind of similar to the "British accent" stereotype. There's the thick Glaswegian accent and then there's the gentle West Country lilt. A Northerner and a Southerner sound very, very different. British accent is not even a thing as the media has made the English accent synonymous to British. But regardless, coming back to Indian
accents - no we all don't sound the same. And we do know English, thank you very much.
This is so sad as India is home to various religions: Hinduism, Islam, Christianity, Sikhism, Jainism,
Buddhism, Judaism and Zoroastrianism. Every Indian need not be a Hindu. Interesting fact: India has roughly the same number of Muslims as Pakistan (10.9% v/s 11% of total Muslim population), putting India third in the ranking of countries by Muslim populations (after Indonesia and Pakistan). (Source: 2010 Pew Research Report, Wiki: List of Countries by Muslim Population.)
Advertisement
Again, no. I'm from Mumbai and I rarely come across joint families or families with more than 3 children. Yes, the Indian population is humongous and the rural areas have big families which contribute to the population growth - but not every Indian household is like that.
Trust me, I'm an Indian and when I see a maths textbook - I want to scream and run for my life. I hate
that subject so much. And let's not get started with those useless maths textbooks which print a 3 page description of a bloody mathematician and then go about skipping steps while solving sums. THAT IS HONESTLY SO INFURIATED I FEEL LIKE GOING ON A MURDER SPREE. If the
publisher really wanted to save pages by avoiding all the steps, then why print the detailed birth history of a douchebag because of whom I'm suffering?! Anyway, enough with the rant. But yes, not all Indians like maths or are extremely smart enough to understand sums without explanations and properly solved sums.
Ugh, stop with that already! Seriously? Love marriages do happen in the country. Infact, quite a
lot. Yes, the concept of an arranged marriage is still somewhat prevalent but it's not how the media portrays it to be. The urban arranged marriage is basically a version of "dating service run by your families" wherein the parents set you up with a few guys, you date them and then you choose the best cherry.
You honestly can't stereotype an entire country to be narrow-minded now, can you? There are a few
ignorant people who couldn't care about anything but their set of beliefs and then there are a few well read people who are open to learning something new about different cultures.
Okay, that's just rude. Fuck off. I'm as pretty as a snowflake.
A lot of people here are non vegetarians, a lot of Hindus here consume pork and beef, and a lot of people are vegetarian or vegan for ethical/health reasons. Welcome to India, a foodie's delight!
Not true for the urban areas. The villages do have unfair laws and systems for the women, I agree. But the same does not hold true for the urban areas. Also, the states Meghalaya and Kerala have a matrilineal system. You'll find women take center-stage in every aspect of life there.
I'm sure there are waaay more stereotypes associated with Indian people but I've come across the above mentioned ones quite a few times and it's infuriating. PLEASE read up on Indian culture if you are planning to write a story including a brown character.
Advertisement
- In Serial37 Chapters
Force of Will
This is my attempt at blending a typical fantasy isekai of sword and sorcery with a xianxia cultivation style. Hopefully its a good attempt. I am a first time writer, so feel free to critique me! Comments, ratings, messages whatever! I'm taking it all as constructive feedback I promise! =========================================================================================================================== There was William a bright young lad who, through his father's rigorous training starting at a young age, managed to be accepted as a Page with a potential for knighthood with enough hard work. The kid was going to go places. There was also William, fresh out of college and just aimlessly working at local restaurants and bars just enjoying life and not doing anything with his degree. Pretty much just spending his life having a good time doing whatever he wants. Obviously these are two different Williams. Or are they? Join the second Will as he awakes in a new body and discovers exactly what this new experience entails for him.
8 193 - In Serial51 Chapters
The Sorceress of San Antonio
Your world isn't supposed to go completely sideways on your seventeenth birthday. Most girls are hoping for a car, Victoria is hoping her dad comes home from the hospital and maybe a date for the spring formal. What she gets is an offer she can't refuse a beautiful blue box swimming in front of her eyes. Happy 17th birthday! You have 24 hours to complete set up and registration, or the system will initialize with default settings. Again Happy birthday! Somedays you change the world and others it changes you.
8 176 - In Serial39 Chapters
Juryokine
For three months, Gravity Storms have been tearing Yasmik apart and neither the humans nor their winged neighbors, the Sorakines, are safe from them. One hotheaded young Sorakine named Zashiel is convinced that the Storms are being caused deliberately, but she's unable to find evidence to back up her claims. She chooses Toke, a budding inventor studying under the most brilliant mind in Yasmik, to act as her spy- whether he wants to or not. But the task she's set out for him can't be completed by a mere human. Toke must inherit the gravity altering powers of a Sorakine, and become something more than human: a Juryokine. Juryokine is featured on Web Fiction Guide and Novels Online! www.webfictionguide.com http://novelsonline.info/
8 195 - In Serial13 Chapters
Karma - The Game
Martin Cline is somehow an average man with an average life. Truth be told: He is bored to death until he finds a new purpose.Nothing excites him much but a new game called Karma. It is the first of its kind and has almost nothing to do with the """"old"""" games played on plain displays.Karma is a true virtual world Martin wants to explore and fulfill himself a tiny dream he had no chance to chase in his life so far.It is easier said than done. Karma might just be more than a fantasy world with mmorpg elements set up in a virtual reality.
8 193 - In Serial185 Chapters
Can a holy hero be born from such a person?
Its a story about a young man name Azumi with her master Princess Alfin living in a fantasy world, can they fight off againts the oppression from various noble, chruch and sometime even their supporters?
8 190 - In Serial12 Chapters
An Average American in A High-school Academy Anime
An American versed in narrative tropes and more than mildly acquainted with anime wakes up in a completely different bed than the one he went to bed in. Now he has to scramble to understand where he is, what's going on, and hope to God he isn't in a relationship drama. I don't expect this to be good or well-received, but I have plenty of time this quarantine, so I'll try to get a chapter of 4000-10000 words out every one or two weeks. (haha) Please let me know how it can be improved. I'm an avid reader of fiction, but I've never really fallen down a rabbit hole so hard that I can name all tropes and settings and such by heart. I'm not sure if this will be effective satire, so I preemptively apologize. Inspired by: "My Life is Not a Manga, or maybe..." by EO Tenkey and "The Simulacrum" by Eganthale. Check them out if you want probably better stories than this one.
8 146

