《Blazing Fire Awards | Open》Judging Criteria, Rules, and Judge Forms
Advertisement
This is where everything you need to know to become a judge lives. For this contest to run, we need people willing to judge each genre.
🔥There will be two judges for each genre/category
🔥Each Judge Will get 5 Books to Judge
🔥Each Book Needs a Minimum of 5 Chapters Read, and Voted On
🔥After Each Book is Read, the Judge will Grade the Book based on the Criteria Below
🔥Book Cover: {/10}
-How Eye Catching is the Cover? Does it fit the overall theme of the book?
🔥Title Selection: {/5}
Is it unique? Is it easy to remember? Does it give away too much of the book?
🔥Blurb: {/10}
-Does the blurb give too much of the plot away? Does it say too little? Does the content of the book match the blurb?
🔥Grammar and Punctuation: {/10}
-Self Explanatory
🔥Dialogue: {/10}
Does dialogue flow in story naturally? Does it follow proper grammar (i.e. each new person talking starts on their own line)?
🔥Text Harmony: {/10}
How well does the words of the story flow together? Does it flow seamlessly or is it hard to connect?
🔥Plot Development: {/10}
-Does the pacing of the story fit with the theme and overall feel of the story? Does the story go too fast or too slow?
🔥Character Development: {/10}
-Do the characters change drastically throughout the chapters? Do they stick to their personalities? Do they have a reason to change?
🔥Overall Enjoyment: {/10}
-How much did you enjoy the book overall?
🔥Chapter 1 {/10}
-The first chapter determines if people are going to read anymore of the book. Does the first chapter catch the audience's attention?
🔥Engagement {/5}
-How engaging do you find the story to be?
Total Score: [/100]
🔥BE FAIR. Do not accept bribes.
🔥Give a shout out announcement on your message board. This is to bring in more people and get the most coverage we can
Advertisement
🔥DO NOT GHOST, if you have to stop judging for any reason, please update us. Situations arise where they take priority and that's completely okay, just let us know that you're not able to judge anymore. You don't even have to tell us what happened.
🔥You must have discord. It's much easier to communicate there, and it builds community.
🔥You need to read a MINIMUM of 5 chapters of every book.
🔥You have to follow the judging rubric above. Also, you need to give a short review of every book you judge.
🔥You can be a judge for a max of two genres.
🔥You can enter your own books into the contest, just not in the genre/categories that you're judging.
Username -
Experience -
What Genres Would You Like to Judge? -
Are you fine with reading Mature or LGBTQ content? -
Do you have discord (Don't list it here, will get a dm asking for it)? -
Did you give a shoutout? -
Optional Tags -
Advertisement
- In Serial782 Chapters
Dear Spellbook (Rewrite)
Live. Study. Repeat. Tal never saw himself as an adventurer, but the call to adventure never much cared for his opinion. Despite his best efforts, his search for answers on the murder of his parents ever draws him into danger. Accompanied by a group of seasoned warriors, thus far Tal has gotten by on his own meager magical talents, but when one day he wakes up to find himself back in his bed of the night before, he is faced with a challenge he must conquer alone. What to expect: This story was born of an attempt to create in world lore reasons for many of the mechanics and tropes of D&D, but you do not need to know of them to enjoy the story. It's a single POV time loop story with slow paced progression fantasy elements. The story is not one of fast-paced power ups and non-stop action, but as it progresses, the action picks up. There is a lot of magic system exploration on a system built to unify the diverse magic of D&D into one cohesive magic system. The setting is an original world with familiar races and monsters but with new unique origins and motivations. The average chapter will be 2-5k words long, most being around 3k but there are a few less than 1k, due to the nature of the story telling device I used. Book 1 is complete. Posting is on hold until I finish book 2. Book 2 progress: The rough draft is done at 141656 words as of 7/9/2022. I need to reread and edit it but Im aiming for resuming chapters in September.
8 776 - In Serial6 Chapters
Aria - The Pulsar Chronicles
Pulsar is in crisis. Warlords vie for supremacy, waging their bloody battles at the cost of innocent lives. Aria, the young daughter of an influential warlord, is thrown head first into the brutal world outside her gilded cage. With the help of a pair of drifters bearing mysterious pasts, she must reclaim what is rightfully hers.
8 92 - In Serial38 Chapters
Forged From Flesh
When his body was destroyed His soul was pulled, A body was forged using fallen foes. Thus the greatest vessel ever existed was created to place that soul. Will he be able to reach the greatest height that he must reach? To find out about the mysteries of the universe that were kept hidden? A/N:The story originally only starts from chapter 20, skipping the early chapters wont make any difference.
8 141 - In Serial7 Chapters
Warlord of the Castle Defence
Betrayed by the government whom he had served all his life, and betrayed by the woman whom he had loved all his life, Randy met his tragic end. But as things normally have it around here, he opened his eyes in a world where he could operate a castle from a mobile game that he had been playing. Will Randy who was now known as Frederick Laywind, survive the harsh desolate plains ?
8 99 - In Serial197 Chapters
Shards of Old
Who would’ve thought that a disaster would shape the world for better? That’s what some people thought about the not-so-recent events that brought magic to our world once more. Too bad I did not have much time to appreciate it. Thanks to my stupidity and arrogance, I lost my friends, my job, and more importantly, brought yet another calamity onto the world. A story of one of the remnants of decimated civilization, tossed to some unfamiliar place, trying to understand the aftermath of his decisions.
8 280 - In Serial10 Chapters
Central cee imagines
Basically the title 👍😅
8 317

