Finney:

*he would start to whimper a little bit

*lays his head on your lap

*asks you to change it

*buries his face in your thighs

*"y/n...can we watch something else...and could we maybe keep my lamp on tonight.."

Robin:

*Robin Arellano would never admit that he is scared of a horror movie

*he was laying in between your legs

*just asked if you guys could go to bed

*"mi amor, I'm tired, can we turn this off and go to bed..no I'm not scared!!!"

Bruce:

*he didn't want to admit it

*thought you'd be mad at him

*sat through it, closing his eyes at scary points

*reluctantly agreed to let you turn it off

*"f-fine...you can turn it off..."

Vance:

*he will not say it

*thinks you'd think less of him and make fun of him

*sucks it up and tries to be a man

*extra cuddly that night

*"hmm? Nah it's not that scary."

Billy:

*he buried his face into your chest

*begged you to turn it off

*had a nightmare about it

*started to cry because he was scared

*"love...turn it off...please? Wait..can I call you love?"

Griffin:

*stiffened up a lot

*his eyes were glossy

*he really wanted to cry

*laid his head on your shoulder

*"I-I-I uh..."

Donna:

*politely asked if you could stop watching this

*buried her face in your chest

*whined a bit

*refuses to watch

*"flower..mind changing the movie? It is quite scary.."