requested by: anonymous 

Finney:

*would be confused

*starts crying

*tries to do anything he can for you

*relieved when you tell him you were joking

Robin:

*So confused

*"What? Why? Is this about Moose?"

*very hurt 

*pissed when you told him you were joking

Bruce:

*tries to apologize

*stays calm

*tears slowly drip from his eyes 

*when you tell him, he says he doesn't find it funny and asks you not to do it again

Vance:

*mad asf 

*you two get in an argument

*so pissed off oml

*SO MAD AT YOU especially when he finds out its a joke

Billy:

*starts violently sobbing

*begs you not to leave him

*broken boy

*cries into your chest when he finds out its a joke

Griffin:

*starts crying

*thinks nobody will ever love him again

*begs you to try and make it work

*silent treatment when he finds out it was all a joke