《Blazing Fire Awards | Open》Judging Criteria, Rules, and Judge Forms
Advertisement
This is where everything you need to know to become a judge lives. For this contest to run, we need people willing to judge each genre.
🔥There will be two judges for each genre/category
🔥Each Judge Will get 5 Books to Judge
🔥Each Book Needs a Minimum of 5 Chapters Read, and Voted On
🔥After Each Book is Read, the Judge will Grade the Book based on the Criteria Below
🔥Book Cover: {/10}
-How Eye Catching is the Cover? Does it fit the overall theme of the book?
🔥Title Selection: {/5}
Is it unique? Is it easy to remember? Does it give away too much of the book?
🔥Blurb: {/10}
-Does the blurb give too much of the plot away? Does it say too little? Does the content of the book match the blurb?
🔥Grammar and Punctuation: {/10}
-Self Explanatory
🔥Dialogue: {/10}
Does dialogue flow in story naturally? Does it follow proper grammar (i.e. each new person talking starts on their own line)?
🔥Text Harmony: {/10}
How well does the words of the story flow together? Does it flow seamlessly or is it hard to connect?
🔥Plot Development: {/10}
-Does the pacing of the story fit with the theme and overall feel of the story? Does the story go too fast or too slow?
🔥Character Development: {/10}
-Do the characters change drastically throughout the chapters? Do they stick to their personalities? Do they have a reason to change?
🔥Overall Enjoyment: {/10}
-How much did you enjoy the book overall?
🔥Chapter 1 {/10}
-The first chapter determines if people are going to read anymore of the book. Does the first chapter catch the audience's attention?
🔥Engagement {/5}
-How engaging do you find the story to be?
Total Score: [/100]
🔥BE FAIR. Do not accept bribes.
🔥Give a shout out announcement on your message board. This is to bring in more people and get the most coverage we can
Advertisement
🔥DO NOT GHOST, if you have to stop judging for any reason, please update us. Situations arise where they take priority and that's completely okay, just let us know that you're not able to judge anymore. You don't even have to tell us what happened.
🔥You must have discord. It's much easier to communicate there, and it builds community.
🔥You need to read a MINIMUM of 5 chapters of every book.
🔥You have to follow the judging rubric above. Also, you need to give a short review of every book you judge.
🔥You can be a judge for a max of two genres.
🔥You can enter your own books into the contest, just not in the genre/categories that you're judging.
Username -
Experience -
What Genres Would You Like to Judge? -
Are you fine with reading Mature or LGBTQ content? -
Do you have discord (Don't list it here, will get a dm asking for it)? -
Did you give a shoutout? -
Optional Tags -
Advertisement
- In Serial30 Chapters
The Madec Legacy
The dawn of Emotion Based A.I.s is here, John is the fifth test subject to have an AI implemented in his brain, and so far the first one to survive. Blinded by the dream of immortality, the researchers push the tests to inhumane standards. John is obligated to take part in sessions of torture designed to test the limits of the AI influence over the physical and mental health. What was supposed to be a new beginning in life turns into living hell. An (un)lucky twist ends his life. John then reincarnates with his AI in a new world where a System influences the interaction between Magic and Matter. With seemingly limitless potential and a game-like system influencing the world, the hero sets on his journey. --AUTHOR NOTE, PLEASE READ-- I will state here my promises to you, potential reader: 1. No harem! I don't trust myself to make a harem feel natural or healthy, I never met any person who has a personality that can adapt and live in a harem for reasons that are not monetary, so I can't draw inspiration from real life. Sorry!; 2. The enemies will not be bland and illogically mean. Some may feel like that at first, but I will take great care in fleshing them out, trust me. You may end up hating some, but you won't be able to deny that they had their reasons for what they did; 3. I am using a paid (and expensive) automated editor tool, and I take longer to write because I take my time in editing the stuff. I am aiming to improve and I will not shy away from constructive criticism, nor take offense for no reason; 4. Characters will die and will suffer, some will get over the tragedies and improve, others will not be as resilient. 5. This novel has a lot of ground to cover, it is neither a short story, a manual on crafting, or the script of some action scene. There will be both time skips and oversimplifications of some actions for the sake of moving the story forward. Time skips will be more prominent in the first 30 chapters. I will describe crafting processes and fights with more detail if they are essential for the chapter; 6. If I took my time describing something, it's because it is important. I hate novels that waste time describing useless stuff. If you skim over something, the chances are that something in the future will not make sense. I am an adept of "Chekhov's gun" principle; 7. I already have 31k words on my auxiliary documents, I have a plan for the story, and I will not be making changes even if someone ends up noticing some foreshadowing and figures out what will happen. The story comes first. 8. I have a wife, a job that demands 9h every day and courses related to my job (lawyer) three days of the week, it's unlikely that I will be able to do mass releases at all. I will have a healthy amount of chapters to be able to post at least 1 chapter every day continually. Don't worry. 9. I will read all the comments. I will listen to all you have to say and will try my best to accommodate demands as long as they do not hamper the path I prepared. 10. There is an arc that spans the entire novel. Each volume will be an arc in itself while progressing a little bit of the main arc. Every arc will have one or more main antagonists. I think that's it! Thank you for reading it all. Have an awesome time reading my first novel!!
8 98 - In Serial8 Chapters
The Cube - Discontinued
In the universal prison, reserved for the greatest criminals among the most powerful beings - The Gods - join our protagonist, Zed, as he searches for his escape and ultimately his revenge!
8 145 - In Serial6 Chapters
These Dreams Between Us
Diana Reynolds closed her eyes for what should have been the last time and woke to find herself transported into the world of her favorite novel, Virtue of the Sun, and trapped within the body of its main villainess: Princess Adelaide Absenwilde. In order to prevent her impending demise and prevent the destruction of the Rathewin Empire, she must rehabilitate the princess' reputation by gaining new friends, forging strong alliances, and even discovering love as she finds new inner and outer strength. But what about her old life and her old body? What will happen if she succeeds, and what will happen if she doesn't?
8 134 - In Serial23 Chapters
The False Warlock
The universe consists of two known planes of existence. The Demon plane and the Mortal plane. The Demon plane is the home to seven races of demons, while the Mortal plane is home to the Human race and their bizarre mutations and magical skills.The Mortal plane is a plane where countless humans live in densely populated cities. The complete opposite to the sparse populations of the Demon plane. Just as much as the Demons have powers, there are some mortals who have powers too. Mutations that create powerful Humans called Vigors as well as magic users who can cast spells or traverse the two planes.The Demon plane is ruled over by seven Demon lords and a king, while the other, less powerful demons fall into line behind these Demon lords. These Demon lords grant powers to their subjects, creating the seven demon races. All Demons can move between the two planes, but most choose not to due to their hatred of the Human race, but some do for a single thing. To have children, for Demons can only be male. At least- they should.Elmira is the first female demon and due to her unique circumstance and the demon's hatred of Humans, they wish to make her their queen with which they can have 'pure' children with. Elmira and her brother, Lucifer have other ideas. As a plan hidden from her other brothers and Satan, her Father, Lucifer sends her off to the Mortal plane in an effort to hide her amongst the Humans. However, it takes time to get used to the Mortal plane and the people within who have their own ideas as to what she should do.Warning: Tagged 17+ for gore, strong language and violence.
8 189 - In Serial99 Chapters
My Secret Boyfriend
In which (Y/n) Weasley, the twin sister of Ron Weasley, falls for her family's enemy. (draco malfoy x weasley!reader) you will be described as having red hair. if you don't like, don't read. lolzhighest rankings: 1- dracomalfoy1- dracolovestory1- ronweasley1- hogwarts1- hufflepuff 1- weasley1- fredweasley1- hogwarts2- slytherin1- dracoxreader|prisoner of azkaban- deathly hallows|(all rights to j.k. rowling for her characters and plot.)
8 183 - In Serial14 Chapters
Bear trap (statehumans CalTex)
(This book has nothing to do with furries, otherkins, or irl therianthropes. Both by their own definitions and my own, we have nothing to do with each other. Keep being your weird selves just don't pretend I'm a part of those groups because I wrote this book with animal/human hybrids in it. Any comments trying to talk about furries or otherkins will be deleted because it makes me physically uncomfortable. Therians are ok tho because it's basically the fancy way to say people who have spirit animals)There are two races in this world, humans and therianthropes, which are humans with animal qualities, that can shapeshift into their animal counterpart. The therianthropes, once divided by predator and prey, joined together in hiding after the humans began to hunt therianthropes for sport. California, a young grizzly bear therianthrope, was always curious to see the world beyond the forest he and his people lived within. Texas, a young farmhand, always wanted to catch a therianthrope, believing it would make him the hero of his village after violent massacres and thefts had been performed on it, supposedly by therianthropes.But when these two young men's paths collide, secrets, strange new feelings, and a magical adventure turns everything they thought they knew about the others race upside down.Warnings:- statehumans- countryhumans - the country and statehumans are all kinda just mixed together. There is no obvious separation between state and country, they're all just people - guns- and ships- hunting - idk, vegans?- gay stuff- not super gory, but people do get hurt - maybe death
8 250
Prev Chap
Next Chap
Chap List
Boy
Girl
