《Blazing Fire Awards | Open》Judging Criteria, Rules, and Judge Forms
Advertisement
This is where everything you need to know to become a judge lives. For this contest to run, we need people willing to judge each genre.
🔥There will be two judges for each genre/category
🔥Each Judge Will get 5 Books to Judge
🔥Each Book Needs a Minimum of 5 Chapters Read, and Voted On
🔥After Each Book is Read, the Judge will Grade the Book based on the Criteria Below
🔥Book Cover: {/10}
-How Eye Catching is the Cover? Does it fit the overall theme of the book?
🔥Title Selection: {/5}
Is it unique? Is it easy to remember? Does it give away too much of the book?
🔥Blurb: {/10}
-Does the blurb give too much of the plot away? Does it say too little? Does the content of the book match the blurb?
🔥Grammar and Punctuation: {/10}
-Self Explanatory
🔥Dialogue: {/10}
Does dialogue flow in story naturally? Does it follow proper grammar (i.e. each new person talking starts on their own line)?
🔥Text Harmony: {/10}
How well does the words of the story flow together? Does it flow seamlessly or is it hard to connect?
🔥Plot Development: {/10}
-Does the pacing of the story fit with the theme and overall feel of the story? Does the story go too fast or too slow?
🔥Character Development: {/10}
-Do the characters change drastically throughout the chapters? Do they stick to their personalities? Do they have a reason to change?
🔥Overall Enjoyment: {/10}
-How much did you enjoy the book overall?
🔥Chapter 1 {/10}
-The first chapter determines if people are going to read anymore of the book. Does the first chapter catch the audience's attention?
🔥Engagement {/5}
-How engaging do you find the story to be?
Total Score: [/100]
🔥BE FAIR. Do not accept bribes.
🔥Give a shout out announcement on your message board. This is to bring in more people and get the most coverage we can
Advertisement
🔥DO NOT GHOST, if you have to stop judging for any reason, please update us. Situations arise where they take priority and that's completely okay, just let us know that you're not able to judge anymore. You don't even have to tell us what happened.
🔥You must have discord. It's much easier to communicate there, and it builds community.
🔥You need to read a MINIMUM of 5 chapters of every book.
🔥You have to follow the judging rubric above. Also, you need to give a short review of every book you judge.
🔥You can be a judge for a max of two genres.
🔥You can enter your own books into the contest, just not in the genre/categories that you're judging.
Username -
Experience -
What Genres Would You Like to Judge? -
Are you fine with reading Mature or LGBTQ content? -
Do you have discord (Don't list it here, will get a dm asking for it)? -
Did you give a shoutout? -
Optional Tags -
Advertisement
Super Minion
Fortress City has Super Villains, who have evil lairs, and in them they make super weapons. But when a bioweapon is granted super powers of its own, will Fortress City be able to handle the Super Minion?
8 115Supervillainy and Other Poor Career Choices
When a down on his luck machine shop owner ends up coming into possession of a rundown suit of power-armor, he sees an opportunity to make some quick cash. Unfortunately for him, the world of Capes is not one that you may enter and leave at will. What should have been a quick sale to pay off his debts quickly grows into an ongoing series of events that serve only to drag him deeper and deeper into the criminal underbelly of the city he calls home...
8 244Schwarzesmarken '86
3 years after the dramatic conclusion of the Stasi coup attempt, Theodor Eberbach, who had made a new life for himself in the United Kingdom, returns to mainland Europe following rumors of the survival of Katia Waldheim as humanity is pushed back to a few strongholds by the BETA. Originally written for Muv Luv threads on a certain imageboard, I'm posting it here so I don't lose it. Don't expect me to finish this as it has been around 2 years since I worked on it and I am working on an original writing project, but some feedback would be appreciated.
8 79There's a Smartphone in my Dantian
Guy gets stabbed in the abdomen, they do emergency surgery on him but the doctor's smartphone falls into the cavity during the surgery and no one notices. Naturally the surgery is successful but the patient dies. MC wakes up in another world woken by a ringtone from his abdomen. Guess what, it's the god of the isekai world!!
8 101Gato Lana: Part 1 [Start of The End]
(This story is based of: https://gato-lana.fandom.com/wiki/Gato_Lana_Wiki. Reading Dialogues/character pages is recommended. You don't have to read them to understand this story, though.)In the world of Arcave, humanity is fighting against the "Longers", monsters with different shapes and unknown purposes. The human race only survives with difficulty against them while the "Longers" fight relentlessly to exterminate humanity once and for all. Arcave is a world where light pierces the darkness and darkness engulfs the light. A world where the balance between hope and despair is a thin line that threatens to break every time the bright star in the sky rises. A world where every day is a fierce battle for the survival of the species.Even if the human species is the dominant one, it is not the only one on the world of Arcave. The "Kemonos" are humans with animal attributes, considered other than human. The "Morris" are less like humans and are mistreated, because they are the ones who would have allowed the Longers to become so powerful...
8 72one night stand | spencer reid
A one night stand with Spencer Reid leads to so much more. i do not own spencer reid, emily prentiss, aaron hotchner, jennifer jareau, derek morgan, penelope garcia, david rossi, or any of the cases from the show Criminal Minds. i do, however, own Stella Keller, and some of the cases are created by me.spencer reid x oc#1- analysts#15- spencerreid#1- cbs#1- shemarmoore#1- davidrossi#1- thomasgibson#1- mgg#1- derekmorgan
8 64