RR reminder: DO NOT comment "rr" or anything else that can be a spoiler. Everyone's reading experience should be the same, don't ruin this for someone else just because you read it already. Thank you.

Elora

My breathing was heavy with anticipation as Eugene approached with a black silk piece of cloth. He stopped in front of me and smirked, eyeing me slowly. Damn this outfit, I shifted uncomfortably.

He looked all to pleased as he reached up, covering my eyes with the blindfold. I gasped, but my mouth was immediately occupied by his lips as they crashed into mine. He kissed me harshly, devouring my mouth.

I moaned into his mouth, feeling his hand between my legs. I pulled against the rope, desperate to touch him. Being restrained and blindfolded makes it hard to focus on anything but his hands on me.

He pulled away, leaving me gasping for air. His fingers were slowly stroking my slit. I shivered, wishing I could see him. He chuckled lowly, "You're so fucking wet. You're so pathetic, love, aren't you?" He rasped.

Another pair of hands were suddenly cupping my breasts, squeezing them and pinching my nipples. I whimpered, "Theo," I gasped out, feeling him standing behind me.

I squirmed, feeling Eugene's finger slide into me. He pushed his finger into me several times, not being gentle about it. "Say it," Eugene ordered. "Say you're a pathetic little slut."

I bit my lip, blushing. He added another finger, picking up his pace, roughly fucking into me. I moaned, trying to close my legs, but the bar at my ankles wouldn't allow it. I don't want to say that... it's embarrassing.

One of Theo's hands left my breast. I felt his hand cup my ass cheek before he moved lower, accessing my entrance from behind. I whimpered, feeling his finger join Eugene's fingers inside of me. Theo gently kissed behind my ear, "Say it, or I'll add another finger," he threatened. "What do you think Eugene? How many fingers can her pussy take?" He teased.

I froze, both of them pushing into me making my eyes roll back. Holy shit...

Eugene chuckled, "As many as it takes for her to listen," he rasped.

Okay, time to be a good girl. Three fingers is enough. "I'm your pathetic slut," I moaned out, being sure to make that correction.

I heard Quin make a sound of approval somewhere in the room, and I knew I made the right choice.

Eugene hummed, pulling his fingers out of me. "Wait-" I gasped, suddenly feeling empty as Theo pulled out of me too. I didn't- they didn't- I didn't cum!

"You thought it'd be that easy, love? You're going to have to work for it if you want to cum," he explained, amusement in his cruel tone.

My girly parts throbbed, missing being filled.

Theo moved away from behind me, and I felt lost again, having no idea on where any of them are in the room.

I heard movement over my the wall across from me.

"Baby," Duke said gently. I relaxed, feeling his hand run down my side. "Do you have any idea of how worried we were last night?" He asked.

I nodded my head, guilt filling me, "I'm sorry," I said honestly.

He gripped my hip, "I know, baby," he said in a comforting voice. "You're going to show us just how sorry you are," he added, giving my lips a gentle kiss. He gave my ass a small slap, that I barely felt compared to Danes and Felix's. "So be my good girl and count them out for us."

Count what?

His hand left me, and his presence was replaced with a much more intense one. I tilted my head up, even though I couldn't see. "Felix?" I guessed.

A sudden smack stung my ass, and I gasped out. "Owie!" I pouted. "Daddy, that hurt," I cried.

He ran his big hand over where he hit me. It definitely wasn't a hand that hit my ass, I bet it was one of the torture devices on the wall. "Awe poor baby," he taunted, no sympathy in his tone at all. "You forgot to count. Now we have to start all over," he said lowly.

I whimpered, "But-"

"Lucifer, do you have anything to shut her up?" Felix asked.

I tensed. I already can't move, or see! I'd like to keep my mouth. "No no no, I'll be quiet." They're not playing around today.

"I do," Lucifer whispered in his low tone next to me. I flinched to the other side, not expecting him to be so close. I felt his thumb touch my lips, "Her jaw will be sore enough by the end of the day without a gag in her mouth," he chuckled. I felt his lips touch my ear, sending tickles down my spine, "So shut your fucking mouth," he said harshly.

Wetness flooded out of me, soaking my thighs. I nodded, immediately submitting to him. I wouldn't dare argue with him, or any of them, for that matter. Maybe Duke, but not today.

I felt his thumb leave my lips and swallowed hard.

I felt another harsh sting on my ass and cried out, "One!"

"Good girl," Quin commented, "If you're as sorry as you say you are, tell us," he ordered.

Felix hit my ass again and I flinched against the ropes, "Two," I winced, "I'm sorry, Quin," I started.

Another slap was heard in the room and I cried out, tears escaping onto the blindfold. "Th-three," I cried, "I'm sorry, daddy!"

"Which one?" Theo mumbled and I heard a slap in the room, but it wasn't on my ass, thank god. "My bad," Theo whispered, but I heard it.

Felix rubbed his hand over my ass cheek, soothing the burning sensation. "Only five more, baby," he cooed.

Five?! My booty hurts so bad already. I do really want to show them how sorry I am though... If this is what it takes, I can do it.

"I love you, Elora."

I raised my eyebrows, surprised and my heart swelling with love. I know he loves me, but I never thought I'd actually hear him say it- even if it was only in my head.

I cried out, as Felix swatted me again, "Four! I'm sorry Dane," I sobbed.

"Thank you angel," Dane said happily from across the room.

"Five," I panted, trying not to scream. It hurt horribly, but my pussy clenched every time the paddle, connected with my skin. "I'm sorry, Theo."

"Oh I'm not upset, princess. I'm here because it's fun," I could hear the smirk in his tone.

I couldn't even crack a smile at him, I was in so much pain. That's very on brand for him, and I adore him for it.

My body shook as Felix struck me again, "S-six," I let out a high pitched whimper, feeling Felix sooth my burning cheek with his hand again. "I'm so sorry, Eugene!" I called out with tears running down my face, escaping the blindfold.

For the last time, Felix used the paddle in his hand and struck my ass swiftly. This one was harder than the rest and I screamed, "Se-seven!" I grabbed the rope that's around my wrist, squeezing it as my body shook again. "I'm sorry, Duke," I cried, taking shaky breaths.

I'll never do anything bad again. This punishment isn't worth going against their direction. My booty hurts so bad, I'm scared to see how it looks.

I felt the ropes shift, and my arms were lowered. The blindfold was gently taken off my eyes and I blinked a few times, my vision slightly blurry from the tears.

Quin was untying my wrists, while Felix removed the evil bar of torture from my ankles. Felix frees my ankles quickly, and I closed my legs, wincing as the material of the bodysuit brushed against my ass.

Quin studied me, as if making sure I'm still okay. "You did wonderfully, doll," the corner of his mouth turned up in a proud smile. My shoulders relaxed and I gave him a small smile. "How are you feeling?" He asked as he finished freeing my wrists.

I glanced at Felix, "Very sorry. And in desperate need of an ice pack," I answered honestly.

Theo approached out of nowhere, now wearing nothing but boxers. "You can sit on my cold meat, princess," he smirked.

My mouth dropped open, astounded at his lack of a filter. I just got my ass beat, and he's making jokes. I admit, it's kind of funny, but still.

I heard all my other guys let out a quiet sigh at the same time. If it was just one of them, I wouldn't have heard it. But every single one of them shot Theo a warning look.

Theo just smirked, gently taking my hands out of Quins. He gave me his signature charming smile as he laid on the bed, skillfully placing me on top of him. "Glare all you want, you're the ones watching with hard-on's as I fuck her," he boasted.

Wait, he was serious? I know Lucifer said I'd get them all, but I thought the ass slapping punishment canceled that out. Nerves filled me, not exactly about having sex with them, I'm thrilled for that part. But I already feel warn out.

I looked down at Theo, still feeling small although I'm the one on top. He's a massive man, they all are. I bit my lip, not knowing what to do. Can his dick even bend this way? "Uh, what do I do?" I questioned.

Theo smiled, "Lift your hips, princess," he said gently. I hovered over him for a second as he pulled his dick out of his boxers. I raised my eyebrows, looking under me at him. He's the length of my freaking forearm! Are any of them going to go in easily, or are they all massive?

He grabbed the base of it, propping it up. With his free hand he moved my hips, positioning me right over it. "Sit," he raised his eyebrows at me.

I placed my hands on his firm chest, using him as leverage so I wouldn't fall off of him. I slowly lowered myself onto him. I gasped, the stretching sensation happening again. It took a few extra seconds, but I was finally back to sitting on him. Only now, his dick is buried inside me. It feels weird like this, it's a good weird, just new.

Theo sucked in a breath, looking down between us, and I felt him twitch inside me. Biting his lip between his teeth he gripped my hips. He blinked up at me, his expression turning back into a smile, "Good?" He asked.

I nodded. If he looks at me like that again, I'll cum.

He looked distracted, glancing between our connected bodies and my face. "Good girl, now just move however you'd like. Find what feels good, and ride me like there's no tomorrow," he grinned.

I bit my lip. I can do that, I'm very aware of everyone else just watching though, and being on top gives me stage fright.

Noticing my hesitation, Theo grabbed my hips again, slowly lifting me off him and pulling me back down. I moaned quietly, feeling him deep inside me. I like this angle, he's so deep inside me, it feels amazing.

He still used my hips, pushing and pulling me on him. I arched my back, lifting my sore ass off of him and back down along with him. "That's my girl," he moaned.

I shifted slightly, finding a different angle that feels better. Theo kept his hands on my hips, but allowed me to move however I wanted. This is nice, they never let me have control.

The bed shifted, a heavy body suddenly behind me. I cocked my eyebrow, stopping to look behind me.

I blinked a few times at Dane, confused. He's naked, and my greedy eyes were quick to look. Of course, he's big. Why wouldn't he be? There's a strong theme here... But why is he on the bed, especially when Theo and I are in the middle of something.

In his hand was that clear lotion that Duke had in his bedside drawer. "What's that?" I asked.

Dane smiled at me, "Lube. It makes it easier for my dick to fit into your little ass," he said casually.

My mouth dropped open. Excuse me? Wait- I turned to Duke, giving him a shocked look, "Why do you have this?!"

Dukes lips slowly turned into a small devious smirk as he looked away.

Theo suddenly thrusted into me, causing pleasure to ripple through my body. I made a sound between a whimper and a moan at the unexpectedness of it. Theo gave me a stern gaze, "He's gonna fuck your ass, too, princess. Now bend down," he explained bluntly.

Okay then...

I leaned down with dick still buried inside me, resting my chest against his. He glanced behind me, "Be a pal and hurry up. I'm dying over here," he sounded frustrated.

Dane sighed in annoyance, about to respond but Quin beat him to it. "Theo one more snide comment and you'll be the one with ball gag," Quin warned.

Theo pressed his lips together, amusement clear on his face. I actually like Theo and his jokes. Is this the best time for it? No. But it makes me less nervous. Everyone else is so serious, it scares me.

I felt Dane shift behind me again, and the plug in my ass was tapped, making my butt feel weird. Dane ran his hand over my ass cheek a few times, "Are you okay with this, angel?" He asked.

Uh. I think it's weird, really weird. But I'm willing to try it. It felt okay when Eugene fingered my ass, so I have a bit of hope that it won't be as bad as it sounds. I was looking at Theo, but nodded at Dane, "Yeah, just go slow, okay?"

Dane chuckled, "Of course."

I tensed, feeling the plug being taken out of me. I should be used to it by now, after having it in for a few days. Eugene showed me how to take it out for bathroom breaks and whatnot. He requested that I keep it in as often as I could, so I've only removed it to use the bathroom and shower. I can do it myself, but it feels extra weird having someone else do it.

Theo placed a small kiss to the tip of my nose and I smiled at him. His dick inside me is rock hard, and I think both of us are getting impatient. This is torture. He put his finger under my chin, lifting my head to his lips. He kissed me, and I opened my mouth for him. I massaged his tongue with my own, feeling my core pulse with want.

As we made out, Dane put something cold on my ass. I didn't know exactly what he was doing, but there's a lot going on back there, to say the least. I tried to focus on the kiss instead, but when I felt something bigger than a finger or plug against my hole, I tensed.

"Relax," Dane reminded gently. There was pressure as he slowly pushed into me. It felt incredibly strange. It didn't exactly hurt, probably because he's being gentle, but it was uncomfortable. Having sex for the first time hurt horribly, this is nothing.

Feeling his torso against my ass, I knew he was completely in me. I feel so full, and there's definitely a mild stretching sting from the two of them being in me at the same time, but it wasn't unpleasant.

Dane gently ran his hand over my ass cheek, that's still incredibly hot and sore from Felix. "Are you okay? Do you need a few more minutes to-"

"I'm okay." I think I'd die if I had to stay still for another second. I've waited patiently, now I want them to fuck me.

Dane gave my ass a slap, making me flinch, "Watch the attitude," he warned.

Theo wrapped his arms around my lower waist, hugging me to him, "Let us do the work. We don't want you to hurt yourself, princess," he explained.

"That's my job," Lucifer said somewhere behind me.

I raised my eyebrows, but nodded at Theo, "Okay."

An intense shiver rippled through me as Theo rocked his hips, pushing into me. I moaned quietly, finally getting what I wanted.

Theo held my hips down, so I couldn't move them even if I wanted to. Dane didn't move as Theo's thrusts became faster, hitting that deep spot in me that makes my eyes roll back.

I watched Theo in awe as his lips parted in pleasure. Soft moans escaped his lips as his gaze was cast down between us. I ran my hands through his hair, wanting to touch him, but my options are limited in this position.

I gasped feeling movement that wasn't Theo. Dane slowly pulled out of my ass before going back in. I squeezed my fist around Theo's hair, the sensation of both of them thrusting into me and different times is overwhelming.

Danes hands were placed on each of my hips, pulling me back onto him. Their movements worked together, using me like I weighed nothing. Theo was pushing me down, and Dane was rocking my hips.

The room filled with my moans and wet sounds as liquid poured out of my pussy. I like this more than I thought I would...

"Look at how much our little slut likes being filled with cock," Felix chuckled. I gazed up at him as he moved to the side of the bed. I blushed, but couldn't stop moaning as Dane and Theo sped up in unison. He was looking down at me with an evil smirk, taking off his belt.

I tried to go out on him, curious as to what he's doing. But I couldn't as Theo suddenly started roughly bouncing me on top of him, our thighs slapping together. I cried out, pulling his hair more. Deep inside me, I felt the familiar tingles start to build. Dane took the opportunity to speed up as well, his own whimpers escaping his lips.

Dane gave my ass a slap and I moaned, the pain still very much present. "Such a good girl, using your desperate little holes to show us how sorry you are," Dane rasped.

I heard the sound of Felix's pants unzipping, and hazily looked up at him. I blinked, watching him pull his dick out, holding the massive thing by the base of his groin.

My mouth watered, knowing what he's going to do. I struggled to hold back moans as my core clenched around Theo and Dane. Theo smirked, not looking away from my face as he pounded into me impossibly faster. My legs felt like jelly and I was crying again, but I loved this.

Theo tilted his head at me, "I can feel your greedy pussy pulsing, princess," he said in a teasing tone. "Are you going to cum?" He taunted in a sympathetic voice.

I whimpered, feeling seconds away from my release. I nodded, pleading him with my eyes.

Theo kept his eyes on me, "This is a punishment. Do you think you deserve to cum?" He asked.

I was fighting the orgasm with everything in me, knowing I'd be in more trouble if I came without permission. I wanted to scream yes at the top of my lungs and beg them to allow me, but I had a better idea.

I blinked up at Theo with my doe eyes, "It's not u-up to me," I struggled to say through moans. As much as I desperately need this, it's important to me that they know I really am sorry. They need to understand that I know I deserve this.

Theo raised his eyebrows with a pleased expression. His eyes looked far away for a moment, and I knew they were talking through their mind link. He smirked at me, pulling my waist tighter against him, keeping the same fast pace. "Cum for us, princess."

Before he even finished his sentence I came. I moaned loudly into the thick air, my legs shaking from the intensity.

I whimpered when they didn't slow down. I just need a second... My pussy was dripping down Theo's dick, and my legs shook. "Wait-" I panted.

"Ah ah ah, angel," Dane rasped out, sounding more stern than usual. "No breaks," he denied.

It's too much, I don't think I can go much longer if they don't give me time to recuperate between orgasms.

My moans turned to desperate whimpers as Theo's thrusts got harder and messier. "Theo!" I cried out, close again so soon after my last one.

Danes grip on my hips got harder, almost painful, as a string of sexy deep whimpers left him. His thrusts also got sloppier and I knew it wouldn't be long until they came.

Exhausted, limbs shaking, and overstimulated, I slowly blinked down at Theo, watching his eyebrows press together in pleasure. I felt his dick twitch in me and he slammed my waist down on him once more before he groaned lowly, "Fuck princess, I'm going to cum so deep in that hot little cunt," he moaned in a strained voice.

His dirty words went straight to my girly parts and pushed me over the edge. For the second time I came all over his dick, soaking it. I cried out in pleasure as warm liquid filled both my pussy and my ass.