At the sound of Star’s confession there as she lay beneath Sky, his desire for her increased tenfold. When he looked down into her dark eyes there beneath the moonlit night, every scrap of willpower the two had been clinging to since they could even feel sexual desire; it suddenly just fell away. With a ragged breath, he moved his fevered kisses to her neck as his hands came up to pull her black tank top down from her bare breasts, revealing her lack of a bra that night and her already hardened nipples.

His breath caught again as his eyes moved to her slightly heaving breasts, a sure sign that the desire she was feeling for him was just as intense. Sky then moved to begin kissing and tasting her breasts as her hands tangled in his hair, her back arching to meet his lips and tongue.

Passion fueling their motions, it wasn’t long before his hands found their way to the hem of that short leather skirt. Looking down into her eyes once more to assure himself that she didn’t want him to stop anything he was doing, his hands slid up under her skirt, his fingers desperately finding her panties and pulling them down from her hips. One more look back at her, and he pulled them the rest of the way down her pale legs and discarded them somewhere on the ground next to them.

He then moved lower and began pushing her skirt upwards, revealing all of that body he wanted so badly to his eyes at last. One more look to see that she still wanted all of this to be happening, and Sky moved to spread Star’s legs and begin placing more kisses along her inner thighs.

It was mere moments before he then moved his kisses to that spot at her core. There he found that she was so wet with desire for him already that it nearly made him give into his own climax at just the thought that he had caused that much arousal in her as well. He continued kissing her, tasting all of that wetness he had caused with only his nearness and his touch. Only another few moments of those continued kisses before he slid that studded tongue deep inside her, causing Star to loudly gasp and arch her hips to further deepen the penetration.

Only a few more seconds passed with his tongue moving inside her, that tiny metal stud easily causing tremors to already begin in her. Finally, she gasped for enough air to speak, “Sky, stop.”

His body immediately tensing at her words, he moved back and looked up at her, “tell me that’s a joke” he responded raggedly.

Star then let out a small laugh through another ragged breath as the beginnings of her orgasm had already started, “no, I mean...” she took another deep, brave breath as she looked down at him, “I mean, did you bring a condom?”

At the sound of that question, he nearly came already just thinking of the implications of what she was asking. Taking a moment to just try and compose himself, he managed to speak, “are you sure? I mean, really sure?”

Star smiled again, her breath still ragged, “considering what you were just doing, I think you know exactly how sure I am.”

Biting back his own breathless laugh, he smiled and nodded. He then reached into the back pocket of his now excruciatingly tight pants, and pulled the item in question out. Another smile down at her, and he handed it to her shakily. Taking it from his fingers just as shakily, Star watched as Sky took a deep breath and began undoing his pants while she fumbled to get the condom out of its wrapper.

Once the condom was open as well as his pants, revealing the fact that he was painfully aroused at that point, Star smiled again, and gently reached out to begin sliding it over his erection. Just the feel of her touching him enough to put it on nearly made him come again and he knew without a doubt that he desperately needed to be inside of her right then.

Once it was on and he had nearly bit a hole in his lip to stop his own orgasm from arriving too soon, Sky took another breath and moved to that spot laying above her again. Shakily spreading her legs to allow him to move even closer Star looked up at him for one last assurance that she would be ok. He smiled down at her again and slowly began guiding himself inside her.

Once just the tip was inside, he had to be sure, just one more more time, “and you’re positive you really want this, with me, right now?”

Breathing heavily already at just the feel of him barely entering her at all yet, she managed to speak, “I don’t just want it Sky. I think I need it” she whispered as she tightly grasped his waist and braced herself for that inevitable pain that would make way for so much pleasure.

Biting back another tremor trying to begin in him, Sky took another breath and finally, slowly moved to slide himself the rest of the way inside her. As that barrier broke, he gasped a bit as she yelped in pain, slight tears forming at the corner of her now tightly closed eyes.

“Star?” he choked her name as her body remained tense with pain for another moment.

Taking a few quick, deep breaths, she finally started to relax around him ever so slightly, finally opening her dark eyes to him again.

“Does it hurt too much? I can...” he whispered, his own body more than tense as well then as he remained inside her, frozen, afraid to move at all for fear of causing her any more pain.

Star then managed another smile up at him, “no, the pain’s gone now, I think” she smiled again, “now make it stay gone” she added as his own lips smiled down at her.

Already feeling a bit tipsy from the two more beers she had finished while waiting on Sky to reappear, Cassie glanced up the hill after him. With another sigh, she debated on going to search for him. It had been at least fifteen or twenty minutes since he went to check on Star. That should have been plenty of time to discern her well-being, Cassie thought wryly.

She then tossed away the plastic cup and stood. Taking a moment to get her balance, she finally started making her way toward the incline to determine where her current bad boy obsession had gotten himself off to. It was true that she could never see herself dating someone like Sky in any serious way. But he was pretty enough for a few discreet and drunken encounters. And she had to admit she was curious to see exactly how ‘not gay’ he was, considering the assumptions others tended to make about a boy who looked that much like a girl. Or maybe she was just a lesbian who wasn’t ready to give up the idea of being straight yet, she thought wryly, though she doubted that one was really true. But what better way to test it than with a boy who honestly could pass for a girl without even trying as hard as Sky did.

As she neared the top of the cliff several minutes later, her ears caught the sound of moans of pleasure coming from somewhere nearby. She scoffed with a slight chuckle, amazed at how many random hook ups happened at these parties. Then again, that’s what she was looking to try to have with Sky, so who was she to judge? She looked around the top of the cliff and couldn’t really make out much in the dark except a fallen tree several feet off.

Hearing the moans grow louder as she took a few steps toward the tree nearer the edge of the cliff, she narrowed her eyes. She then moved around to the other side of said tree only to then find the couple in question. They were not just fooling around though; she discovered that there was all out intercourse going on as her eyes adjusted in the dark to make out the outline of the boy as he was thrusting deeply into his partner, whose hips were arching to meet every thrust, her own moans of that approaching orgasm clear.

But as her eyes finished adjusting, she felt her breath catch as she realized that the boy in question was Sky. She took another short breath, attempting to decide whether or not she should even make her presence known. After all, she had no real claim of any sort on Sky, but her pride was taking a bit of a hit as she realized that he had likely lied to her to go and meet some other girl that night. And of course, that led to a bit of anger, as no one liked rejection, let alone an already self-conscious fifteen year old girl who had already stepped way out of her comfort zone to make her interest known to a boy that none of her friends would ever approve of.

She watched for a few more seconds, her anger and curiosity wanting to know exactly what other girl she had been spurned for. The problem being that Sky’s long locks, as well as the rather dark night were both making it nearly impossible for her to make out the face of his partner. She finally shook her head, the anger winning as she cleared her throat from her spot watching them, about fifteen feet away, near the edge of the cliff.

Startled from the climax that they had already started in each other, the two froze and looked her way, “So, I thought you were coming to check on your---” Cassie began angrily, only to completely lose her voice as she saw Star’s more than mortified expression looking back at her, “sister” she choked on the last word as she immediately turned away and doubled over to expel all of that alcohol from her stomach once more.

“Fuck” Sky whispered as he and Star both scrambled to end their connection and quickly try to readjust their clothes again, their cheeks both painfully burning then.

“Your sister?” Cassie nearly shrieked, once she had finished throwing up and forced her eyes back to them, “oh my god” she choked on the words again.

“Cassie, you don’t...” Sky attempted though he had no idea how he would even make her believe any denial, all things considered. She would almost definitely think it was some poorly constructed lie to try and hide their shame, no matter what he tried to say.

“Don’t get it?” Cassie offered, tears in her eyes as well as Star’s as the younger girl sobbed into her hands at the thought of what Cassie must be thinking of them now. “No fucking shit I don’t get it! She’s your fucking sister, Sky. You are the most twisted, disgusting fucks on the planet!” she shouted back to them.

“But Cassie...” Sky attempted again, his heart breaking as he saw Star’s trauma then, but trying his best to diffuse it any way he could.

“Don’t even say my name like we’re friends. We are not friends!” she shouted back, “I could never be friends with anyone as twisted and sick as....” she just shook her head.

“Could you please just...please, stop yelling for a second, Cassie?” Sky begged, warily looking toward the still rather large group of teens on the bluffs below them.

“What?” she scoffed loudly, “you afraid they’re gonna hear? Hear about what twisted sick fucks you both are? You’re fucking right they’re gonna hear. I’m gonna tell every single person I know to stay as far fucking away as possible from you two sick goddamn freaks!” she struggled for the words, as Star’s sobs became even more intense at the sound of all that misplaced accusation and the threats this girl was delivering that would truly destroy their lives.

Desperate to stop Star’s complete breakdown, Sky finally raised his voice in return, “would you just listen? We’re not actually fucking brother and sister, Cassie!” he exclaimed.

“Really?” Cassie laughed loudly, “cause it looks like that’s exactly what you are” she shook her head as she moved her hand to her stomach again, “and I’m sure everyone’s really gonna believe that you’re not related, considering the only time you even tried to claim that was when you got caught fucking your own twin sister. Oh god, you are so... so fucking wrong” she turned away again, “and everyone will know exactly how wrong you two are. It’s just sick” she repeated again.

Fighting his own tears, Sky tried once more, “please, you have to believe us. We really aren’t, and you can’t go tell everybody about this. It would destroy our entire lives, Cassie” he pleaded.

“Didn’t I tell you not to call me Cassie?” she growled back, “and make up your mind, are you not related?” another scoff, “or would your lives be destroyed because you are” she added coldly, “I think it’s obvious which one’s true.”

“You can’t fucking tell people this, Cassie” Sky told her, going from despair to anger at that point as he stood, reaching out to pull Star to her feet with him, “you just can’t” he repeated.

“Watch me” she growled back as she turned on her heel to head back down to the party.

Only at that point, all those emotions as well as the physical state they were both in combined in one giant buildup of emotion as Sky and Star gripped each other’s hand tightly. Staring at the girl turning away, their breaths barely managing to pass their lips, the two centered both sets of dark teary eyes on her, and in the next moment, she flew backwards...but too far...as her body landed at the very edge of the cliff, where the loose rocks gave way, and she plummeted to the ground below.

~Present Day~

Sky and Star both returned to the present with a start, pulling their minds back from Cassie’s as each had tears in their eyes at the revelation they had just discovered. They looked at each other and sniffled in disbelief, speechless, not able to find any words to describe their feelings right then.

Stammering, Star tried to find words then, “she didn’t die though, right? We didn’t kill her, right?”

“I don’t think what fucked us up was just rumors. That was... awful.” Sky agreed in his own stammer.

“And it started out so... “ Star couldn’t even finish.

The two sat there sniffling and stewing in these new horrible memories when they heard the front door to Crista’s house open. Looking up as though just then remembering where they even were, they saw Cassie and the state they had left her in. There the frail now eighteen year old sat in a wheelchair, glaring over at their car, as all she could do was glare, considering she appeared to be completely paralyzed from the neck down.

“What the fuck are you freaks doing in front of my house?” she called out to them, tears rushing to her eyes.

Not able to say anything at all in return, the two bit back more sobs of their own and quickly pulled out of the driveway, now having a very clear picture of exactly why they had become who they had become in this world too.