《Game On》NAC: Special Reader Thanks
Advertisement
I was looking over the reviews for 'Game On' and I wanted to take a moment to thank everyone who's voted, or left a review or comment on the story. I truly appreciate all the support from everyone -- even the guys who don't seem to like the story all that much -- for taking the time to read the work and then offer their personal insight and feedback on the story.
One reader in particular, I'd like to offer heartfelt thanks to, for giving me a review that truly made me smile:
gnarleytreeman Wrote: Absolutely aweful 20/08/16 By gnarlytreeman
Overall Score: 1 star
Style Score: 1 star
Story Score: 2 star
Grammar Score: 1/2 star
Character Score: 1/2 star
There were spelling mistakes in the first paragraph, this thing has not been proofread at all, it is noticable.
The style, is meh,it is a clone of 8th day, written by someone who is a pervert. There is a place for sex in stories, but this author just can’t do it right.
2 stars for the rest of the plot, even though its gotten popular lately.
All of the characters are complete shit, very limited back story, created solely for the authors whim as a powermongering sexfest.
Read to chapter 30. Characters need to have character, not be stripped of all clothing and exist as fantasy dolls.
Now, some people reading this might take it as being a bad review. Personally, I don't. I take this to be one of the most endorsing reviews that a person could give the story. WHY?
Let's break it down bit by bit:
1) spelling mistakes and the story has not been proofread at all. (Which I freely admit to, as I do that when I go back later and edit the story. I won't argue one bit over this assessment.)
Advertisement
2) the style is a clone of The 8th Day... (Again, what's to argue over? This *is* the rebooted version of that theme for me, and I even announced it as the spiritual successor of The 8th Day.)
3) apparently I'm a pervert. What my moral character has to do with anything, I don't know, but I've been called much worse. I won't argue.
4) there's a place for sex in stories, but I do it wrong. (Fair enough. Not everyone has to like the sex in the story, or my way of handling it.)
5) 2 stars for the rest of the plot, even though its gotten popular lately. (Here, I must admit, I'm a little confused. Does it only get 2 stars because its popular? This statement is a little vague and gnarly should hopefully expand upon it some.)
6) All of the characters are complete shit, very limited back story, created solely for the authors whim as a powermongering sexfest. (So all the characters are shit and the story must be erotica?)
And the ratings given tell us that gnarleytreeman absolutely HATES the work. There's not much worse that it could get in his eyes. The spelling sucks. The grammer sucks. The plot sucks. The characters suck. This is a sucky, sucky story...
"Read to chapter 30."
... that he couldn't put down and walk away from until he'd read every word written and shared on the site here so far! O_o!
When your writing is so mesmerizing that a person who hates it can't put it down and stop reading it, you're doing something right!
I know I've personally found stories with grammar so bad, I'd have to rate them 1/2 stars, and I never waste my time or effort in trying to stick with them past the first few pages. When the characters are so bad that I rate them 1/2 a star, I drop the work. When the style is so terrible I rate it that low, I drop it. Same with the plot.
Advertisement
And yet...
Here is someone who apparently hates 'Game On' and everything about it, and yet they couldn't put it down and stop reading it until they'd consumed every word written!
And to me, as an author, that's the greatest compliment someone can give. "Your work sucks, but it mesmerized me and I couldn't stop reading it."
Maybe it's just me. Maybe I have an odd way of looking at things -- but it's true: Reviews like this one absolutely bolster my confidence and encourage me to keep going.
Many thanks gnarleytreeman! I'll look back on your review whenever I start to doubt myself and remember the power my words had to force you to keep coming back chapter after chapter to read them. If the people who *don't* like my work can't put it down, then how could I ever give up and let down the people who *do* like it?
One little thing for the irony police though, which I just have to point out because it made it laugh when I noticed it:
Quote:Absolutely aweful
There were spelling mistakes in the first paragraph, this thing has not been proofread at all, it is noticable.
For someone who was so concerned about spelling mistakes in the first paragraph, I have to point out a few things:
1) Aweful is misspelled in your title. You don't even wait to get to the first paragraph. It's AWFUL
2) In your first paragraph, the last word is spelled incorrectly. it's NOTICEABLE, not noticable.
3) If we're actually talking about the first paragraph of the story, there's no misspellings there:
Quote:“Come on class, everyone settle down please. The bell’s already rang.”
This is inside quotes and denotes speech. Not every person speaks in perfect grammar, and this is 100% how the teacher in the classroom would talk. (Some folks would say the bell has already RUNG as proper grammar, but character's don't need to speak in proper grammar.)
Perhaps he's viewing the "bell's" as being a spelling mistake, but it's not. "bell's", as it's being used here, is an improper spoken form for "The bell has already rang." It's a common contracted form of verbal communication, with "bell's" being used as the contraction for "bell has".
So in a rather amusing twist of irony (at least I see it as such), the person complaining about the spelling and grammar in the story is apparently unable to spell or use grammar properly...
I dunno. Maybe it's just the fact that I've been up the last 48+ hours without sleep, but somehow gnarleytreeman's review hit me as extremely flattering and amusing. Yesterday my wife went to the hospital for bronchitis and how it was affecting her asthma, and I haven't had a drop of sleep in days. I was wore down, tired, and ready to just flop over for a week...
... and then the review just hit me the right way and bolstered me, while making me laugh.
And, I'm thankful for that. Many thanks treeman; you truly are gnarley! :D
Advertisement
- In Serial177 Chapters
The Devil in White: An Awakened Aspirations Online Series
Amelia Patrick. Student. VR Gamer. Book Nerd. An unlikely heroine that is unprepared for the storm that sweeps her away and carries her from one adventure to the next. Luckily she has Aidan, the enigmatic Devil in White, a cool and steely-eyed swordsman named Forsythe, and the human-shaped hurricane called Raven to pull her from one disaster to the next. Don't take yourselves too seriously and enjoy chaos. Volume I: The Devil in White Volume II: Amelia Volume III: The Rebellion Hiatus: The Hiatusing.
8 183 - In Serial42 Chapters
Shadowrun: Blake Island School of Magic
It's a high tech, low life. It's the Seattle Metroplex in 2074. It rises like a steel and concrete cancer out of the earth. Poverty is rampant, corruption is everywhere, crime is out of control, corporations basically control everything, the old United States is fractured, magic has come back and now it turns out that humanity has been joined by elves, dwarves, orks and trolls. The old world ended but the rent is still due. Life goes on. You'd be surprised what people can adapt to, especially if they don't have a choice. One of the places where life goes on is just west of Seattle. Surrounded by the waters of the Puget Sound is an island. On that island is the Blake Island School of Magic. A decade ago it was known for producing some of the most talented awakened in the world. That reputation was hijacked by the wealthy corporate elite who now park their teenage children there. And since it's a boarding school, their parents mostly forget about them. Three young people, who are certainly not wealthy or elite, are chosen this year to attend this school of magic in hopes of revitalizing their reputation for talent. One from the ash drifts of the Puyallup Barrens, one from the most densely populated slum hive in the world and one from prison. This is their story. -- This story is set in the Shadowrun universe. If you're not familiar with Shadowrun, it mostly tells the stories of deniable mercenaries called shadowrunners in a cyberpunk dystopia. Instead of telling another story solely about shadowrunners, this story will tell the tale of young people navigating a world that is indifferent to them at best and actively hostile at worst. Shadowrunners will be in the story and we'll see them operate, but they won't be its main focus. This story originally began in 2017 as a passion project and continues to this day on the Somethingawful.com forums. The unedited version is over a million words strong. There are currently seven books in this series and I am currently in the process of editing them. If you read this story then you won't lack for content. -- The Topps Company, Inc. has sole ownership of the names, logo, artwork, marks, photographs, sounds, audio, video and/or any proprietary material used in connection with the game Shadowrun. The Topps Company, Inc. has granted permission to the Blake Island on Royal Road to use such names, logos, artwork, marks and/or any proprietary materials for promotional and informational purposes on its website but does not endorse, and is not affiliated with Blake Island on Royal Road in any official capacity whatsoever.
8 164 - In Serial38 Chapters
Worthless (jeff the killer x fem reader)
Kidnaped at 12 I'v lived at slender mansion for four years now. I work and maintain the grounds during the days while the creepypasta sleep. Ingrained in my head over the years:"I (Y/N) am worthless"
8 219 - In Serial20 Chapters
E
8 150 - In Serial187 Chapters
New Life
Follow the story of a college boy who gains extraordinary powers. Is he going to become a hero to save people? Or is he going to become a villain? Or do nothing with his power? And reveal the secrets of the world, universe and more with him.
8 147 - In Serial6 Chapters
Unbeknownst Tragedy [Classroom of the Elite]
[The White Room] She shall die. He shall not react. Why? Because he is unbeknownst to such Tragedy. [Classroom of the Elite]
8 161

